Manga men
CONVENTIONEERING / Anime North's bent offerings
Miriam Boon / Toronto / Thursday, May 24, 2007
Share |

UNIVERSAL APPEAL. Guy-on-guy anime finds fans among queer men and bi/straight women, alike.
(Suzy Malik)
On May 25 some 15,000 anime fans will be flooding Toronto for the annual Anime North convention. Throw in the yaoi and you've got the makings of a gay 'ole time. But where do the real live homos fit in?

"Ya-what?" you ask? Yaoi, pronounced yah-oh-ee, is the North American term for man-on-man anime, ranging from the romantic to the hardcore.

"Yaoi is about men who are idealized by women, for women," explains Yaoi North spokesperson and bi gal Lisa "Hideto" Lai.

"But just because that's what they intended it to be, doesn't mean that's what the effect has been," adds fellow Yaoi North organizer Matthew Schwartz. Schwartz is one of the homos on the ever-popular "Gay Sex 101" panel. "You get straight guys in there asking questions.... It's wonderful."

This year's convention will feature two rooms dedicated to all things yaoi. Programming will include viewings of yaoi films and TV shows, panel discussions with titles including "World History Of Homosexuality" and "Crossplay 101" (in other words, drag) and Café Nocturne — a Japanese-style drag café featuring flirty female waiters dressed as men.

But Kat Williams, a Toronto-based anime artist and author who organized queer panels at the convention for several years beginning in 2000, says she's dismayed by the lack of queer content created specifically for queers at recent Anime North gatherings.

"[Last year's Yaoi North] was pretty much straight girls squealing about their favourite [gay anime] couples," says Williams.

Lai makes no bones about the genre's objectification of queer men. "But yaoi men are as ridiculous as gay porn men," she says.

Nor is she worried about the lack of gay activism at the conference. "We don't discourage people being proud and out or talking about issues like that... [but] this is a hobby, an interest. Our purview is discussing cartoons. We're not saving lives."

Schwartz is all for straight anime lovers' queer obsessions. "These people are our straight allies. They're the ones who are with us at gay pride marches, and if they relate to gay media, then that makes me happy bringing them into the gay community."

He adds that Yaoi North attendees run the gamut of gender and orientation, and notes that he hasn't heard any complaints from gay attendees about feeling objectified.

Gay men may be getting the red carpet treatment, but last year when Williams was promoting lesbian events, her experience was quite the opposite.

"I got spat at. I had things thrown at me," says Williams, adding that she heard similar complaints from other queer attendees.

Williams says she didn't report the incidents to convention security. "There isn't much security can do about people being overly rude unless [the homophobes] stick around and continue to harass someone repeatedly."

Todd Spencley, who handles security for Anime North, says he is unaware of an escalation in homophobic incidents at recent conventions.

"Anything that is reported to me, I make sure I track it down," says Spencely. "If I find somebody behaving in a discriminatory manner I have a nice long talk with them. I do not put up with that at our convention."

Spencley says that offenders may be banned from the conventions, offering as an example the hosts of The Conventioneers, a reality show on Bite TV, who reportedly harassed crossdressing attendees and body checked a child on camera without his guardian's consent at the 2006 convention.

"For those actions we decided The Conventioneers are no longer permitted to attend Anime North," says Spencley.

Williams is also disappointed with the lack of girl-on-girl anime, or Shoujo-ai (pronounced show-joe-eye), compared to yaoi. Although Williams is presenting a two-hour panel on girl-on-girl anime, it's a far cry from a 24-hour dedicated space.

Anime North's director of programming Eileen McEvoy agrees that there's room for more Shoujo-ai at the convention. She says that there had been a room set aside for a three-day track focussing on dykey fun but that panel organizers — including Williams — backed out at the last minute.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
I did not Bail on AN
I am Kat Williams and I did not bail on the con at last minute. I don't know where that info came from, but I dropped the three day lesbian portion of the con because we had only 3 Volunteers to run 72 hours worth of video programming, panels and events. I am only one person and can't run all of that along with my own art/writing business at the same time. I spot with Eileen in November explaining the situation and she agreed, which is why I only hosted a two hour panel instead of 3 days worth. Also, sure there are a lot events geared towards gay activities, but they make one feel more like a spectical then welcome. It is the attendees that need to be taught that they can't treat gays like sex objects just because they feel like it. Hitting gays with paddles without warning, demanding two men to kiss and the like. AN, along with myself, have been trying to figure out how to teach these kids how to respect people more, but we need more help in doing so. If anyone is interested in helping turn a lesbian anime portion of the con then please contact me at Kathryn@Shoujoai.ca and if we get enough people to help out then we'll what the coming year will bring. Writer/Artist Kathryn K Williams http://www.shoujoai.ca
Kathryn K Williams, Toronto Ontario
06/03/07 1:51 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Attitudes and Harassment
It's one thing to say that security addresses harassment at the convention, but the reality is somewhat different. I did not attend this year's convention, but last year there were Yaoi-north attendees (not the staff) using paddles on people without asking, to which security seemed to think was "harmless". There were attendees who would harass same sex couples, insisting that they "make out" for their entertainment. Again, the attitude of the security staff was "Well, they didn't actually DO anything harmful" I must state, however, that while the security staff was nonchalant about the incidents, the senior staff were not, and were clearly appalled that such behaviour was happening at the convention. As far as the events run by Yaoi north, it's one thing to say that they have panels and events devoted to gay culture, but the reality of what happens is quite different. Crossdressing as your favorite character is accepted, but anyone who is a genuine transvestite or transexual is often treated with scorn and distain even within those same groups. I am not saying that the staff of both Anime North and Yaoi North are encouraging this behaviour, but I felt I had to step in and say that I have seen behaviour exactly as Williams described, and I have seen security that is tolerant of such incidents. Finally, as for the mentioned shoujo-ai room, I spoke to Williams concerning this, and while the convention is willing to offer space for shoujo-ai content, they are not forthcoming with any other support, particularly staff, and Williams would have the task not only of programming the entire event, but running it single-handedly as well, so was forced to decline the offer until could find the support she needed. There was nothing "last minute" about this. What the convention needs, in my opinion, is for the queer community who are anime fans to be vocal. Speak up when you are mistrea
Andrew Torrens, Toronto Ontario
06/03/07 9:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.