Opposition swells
NAKED EYE / Why Denike and Woo should resign on Jan 16
Robin Perelle / Vancouver / Thursday, January 12, 2012
Share |

I didn’t see the swell coming when Parents’ Voice formed last May to oppose the Burnaby School Board’s passage of its anti-homophobia policy.

I didn’t see the swell building when conservative activist Kari Simpson suddenly re-emerged from an all-too-brief moment of silence to take aim at Out in Schools.

I didn’t fully register the connection when Vancouver School Board (VSB) candidates Ken Denike and Sophia Woo parroted Simpson, then got caught echoing her in a video filmed for an American anti-gay-marriage group’s fundraising campaign.

I only realized the dots likely weren’t so random when Denike and Woo got caught blatantly lying to voters in a second video.

We know that Simpson and Parents’ Voice (PV) are working together. Simpson encouraged PV to file a human rights complaint against Xtra three days before the municipal election in November. Tribunal records name her as “the complainant’s agent in this matter,” and PV spokesperson Charter Lau credits Simpson with “really helping us.”

What we don’t yet know is where Denike and Woo fit in.

Did they simply get inspired by the backlash in Burnaby and Simpson’s spiel against Out in Schools and decide to capitalize on it for a few votes of their own? Or did they all sit down for tea to plan their election strategies together?

It wouldn’t be the first time a vocal conservative minority has pooled its resources in the Lower Mainland. The last wave of concerted anti-gay protest swelled (then fizzled) in September 2006 after the BC government admitted its classrooms lacked queer content and reached an agreement with Peter and Murray Corren to slowly foster gay-friendlier schools.

About 1,000 people attended a rally then, including representatives from the Catholic Civil Rights League, BC Parents and Teachers for Life, REAL Women, the Canadian Alliance for Social Justice and Family Values Association, and a new group launched specifically to oppose the Corren agreement: Concerned Parents of BC.

“We’re not fighting against homosexuality,” Concerned Parents leader Brian Roodnick told me at the time. “We’re fighting for parents’ rights.”

Sound familiar?

Roodnick assured me he had no objection to making the curriculum more inclusive, provided it’s done right.

“What’s the right way to teach kids about gays and lesbians?” I asked.

“It’s kind of like evolution and creationism,” he replied. “The theory of evolution, it’s still just a theory. I mean, a lot of people think it’s a fact, but they call it the theory of evolution.”

In other words, according to Roodnick, teachers should respect the demonstrably outdated beliefs some parents are still feeding their kids and tell the kids “you’re completely within your right to have that view.”

Roodnick and his cohorts were particularly adamant about parents maintaining the leeway to yank their kids out of classes they find morally objectionable — leeway the government restricted when it enforced existing policy exempting kids only from health and planning classes.

Imagine my surprise when Denike trotted out the old “parents’ right to withdraw kids” argument when pressed about his appearance in the two videos.

“It’s a matter of the parents having a right to withdraw kids if it’s something that they consider sort of goes against their culture, morals or whatever,” he told CKNW host Simi Sara on Dec 20, trying to evade questions about the Christian video.

In that video, Denike and Woo explicitly tell voters at a Christian Social Concern Fellowship picnic that, unlike Burnaby, the VSB has no policy specifically addressing homophobia.

Vancouver has only a general  anti-discrimination policy, they say, warning everyone to vote for them and their party if they want to keep it that way.

As Denike should well know, the VSB passed anti-homophobia policy in 2004. He was on the board when the policy was first presented in 2002 and funded in 2005.

Denike and Woo are entitled to their views. They are entitled to jump on a Conservative bandwagon, form coalitions, oppose policy, seek its repeal and openly run on that promise. What I find repugnant is their dishonesty — their willingness to misrepresent policy, stoke unfounded fear and seek votes on false pretenses.

For that, they should resign at the next VSB meeting on Jan 16, whether they’re part of a concerted swell or not.



Share |


Reader Comments


 
You're either with us or against us - NOT
When G.W. Bush told the world "You're either with us or against us", he demonstrated the arrogance and ego of a monumental bully. It isolated the US and cost them their status as world leader. It ended them. You seem to be cut from the same cloth. Just because a couple of people happen to share bona fide concerns for the children under their protection - and share the views of a brave woman (Kari Simpson) who only has the best interests of children in mind - you want them to disappear. I don't blame you, actually. As long as there are people who exercise their free speech, people who don't share your support of political indoctrination in the guise of a bogus "anti"-bullying program that has no measurable success to its credit, it's no surprise that you feel threatened. This logic-based, legal-based, moral-based voice of opposition must really be scary to you. But please calm down. Voices of opposition aren't the end all to your agenda. If you bully your opponents into submission - like the VSB has been bullied into accepting Out In Schools - any victory you might claim will be hollow and falsely won. Get in there and debate openly. Accept the challenge and make your case in an open forum. Negotiate, compromise, and come to a mutually agreeable solution. Dictators are falling all over the world. Don't be a dictator; you'll only lose in the long run. Most gays, I believe, are like me. We dislike acrimony. We want love and peace. We want acceptance by way of respect and communication, not of social militarism. We cannot earn an equal footing in society if we're perceived as bullies and haters. Reach out to Denike and Woo and Simpson and all who you perceive as "the enemy". Let go of your ego and prejudices and walk a mile in their shoes. We all have a lot more in common than you may care to admit. Or maybe you're just too much like the war-mongering G.W. Bush, and not up to the task o
Jim, Vancouver BC
01/12/12 2:30 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
January 16 School Board Meeting
I encourage folks who feel strongly about this, or who would like to get clarification from Trustees Denike and Woo to come to the January 16 Vancouver School Board Meeting. It is open to the public, and the public are allowed to speak at the end. Please join us like-minded in supporting our kids.
Rhoda Head, Vancouver BC
01/12/12 10:35 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Maybe you're just too much like... Bush
Oh, get real, Jim. Do you really think that your rhetoric is enough to dissuade people from identifying who is making the mistakes here? It's all well and good that you don't agree with what Bush did in the US, and that you are against dictators, but your hyperbolic and erroneous comparison here is laughable! Your entire premise is based on a presupposition that there has not been any debate on the issue! There has been overwhelming approval for the anti-bullying policy in place in VSB schools, how on earth do you think it was arrived at in 2004 in the first place? I, too, am fond of putting things in people's mouths, but I will not put words in others' mouths as you do. We (supporters of schools where students feel safe to express their identity without discrimination) are already discussing our views openly and honestly. Curious, that you cite our "agenda". What is your agenda? Because it is extremely clear what ours is: to make schools an open, welcome, and safe place for students. Nice try, Jim.
Mark, Vancouver BC
01/12/12 3:33 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Denike NOT on Board 2002-2005
Great piece Robin, but just a point of clarification - Ken Denike was not on the Board during 2002-05 term. He was defeated 2002. The groundbreaking policy was developed, presented and passed and funded between 2003-2004 by a COPE Board. The sole NPA representative was John Cheng who opposed our policy.
Jane Bouey, Vancouver BC
01/12/12 9:34 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Editor's Note
Thanks Jane! What I meant is that Denike was on the board in early 2002, prior to that fall's election, when the idea for an anti-homophobia policy was first introduced by a coalition of education activists for the trustees to contemplate. The Vancouver School Board's groundbreaking policy was then developed by the COPE board, as you said, and passed in 2004. Denike was re-elected to the board in 2005 and, by his own admission, part of the board when it funded portions of the policy's implementation.
Robin Perelle, managing editor, Vancouver BC
01/13/12 1:37 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ignorance is NOT reality!
We are not living in the 50's when children were "seen and not heard", "...must have been doing something wrong...","...boys don't wear pink" and " good girls don't wear red"! I want my grandchildren to be educated in ALL aspects of our present Society morays - discuss drugs, gangs, bullying, missing kids, single parent families, Gay marriages, molestation/obscenity and they will be enlightened and informed and accept CHOICES!! These "elected" people are advocating for NO LIGHT IN THEIR OWN PERSONAL DARK CORNERS!!! Put on your "WHEN I WANT YOUR OPINION, I'LL GIVE TO YOU" t-shirts and resign NOW!!
Bonnie Fournier, Coquitlam BC BC
01/13/12 2:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The fact is neither PV nor BPV filed the complaint
The article incorrectly indicates that Parents' Voice filed a Human Rights complaint. Neither Parents' Voice the 'ad hoc' group, nor Burnaby Parents' Voice the municipal party that ran candidates for School Board filed a complaint with any Human Rights Tribunal. Four Asian-Canadian s including myself filed the complaint as individuals because of numerous racist statements and statements inciting violence against our ethnic/racial group on Xtra’s on-line commentary. One of the complainants was also specifically identified by name in some comments. We understand that making and/or causing to be published these types of statements violates Human Rights codes. Sincerely, Heather Leung, President Burnaby Parents' Voice
Heather Leung, Burnab BC
01/15/12 2:32 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Parents Voice
You don't speak for me or my family. My husband and I voted for the first time EVER in a local election to keep "parent's voice" away from our children's schools.
Stephanie, Burnaby BC
01/16/12 5:50 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.