Loving a trans man isn't easy
TRANS SPOUSE / A femme's perspective on losing her butch
Andréa Hector / Vancouver / Thursday, October 06, 2011
Share |

When I married the perfect butch, I didn’t know that only four short months after our wedding I’d be married to a trans man.

My perfect “masculine woman” couldn’t take the inner turmoil anymore and began to transition.

Transitioning may be more common these days, but my reaction was anything but. I was a catatonic, newlywed wife, crying in a La-Z-Boy for six weeks straight.

I cried tears of grief. I felt as if my love was leaving me, and in exchange there would be a potbellied, hairy-bodied, balding, middle-aged man.

If I wanted this, I would’ve stayed in the closet.
Nobody wants to be the one to say, "This fucking hurts," lest we be judged by the politically fuelled who would label us transphobic, writes Andréa Hector (left), whose butch is transitioning.
(Sarah Race)


For several months Papi was going through the changes so fast, it seemed like the train had left the station and I could only helplessly watch mi esposo disappear.

I was afraid, especially of the unknown: who would I be married to now?

I agonized that I would lose the seductive pull I once felt for Papi. I was terrified that my love would fade because I’ve never been attracted to someone who has gone through with the procedures of transitioning.

And besides, I love butches, dammit! How unfair it seemed.

After all the years I spent feeling hopeless and suicidal in the closet, I was now going to be thrown back in, the door hitting me in the ass, the key tossed away. 

To the rest of the world, I’m just going to look like any other straight woman out there. As femmes, we’re hardly seen as queer unless we’re on the arms of our butches. Now where would I fit in? I fought too hard to be recognized as a femme! Do not strip me of my title, tiara and stilettos.

I was also distraught about my love’s growing clit, not to mention the man hair that seems to now be growing up Papi’s thigh like an out-of-control ivy in a race for time to surpass the groin.

Would the new clit be huge? Massive? A five-foot fucking clitoris?

Well, it wasn’t as bad as my rampant imagination made it out to be. Still, that longtime friend looks a hell of a lot different than the one mi esposo had in the beginning of our relationship. Plus I now get a fistful of hair when I stroke my love’s thigh.

Unfortunately, I spent enough time in the closet to know what man stink smells like. I thought those days were behind me, until my love started taking hormones.

When my love realized that the smell was making it difficult for me to have sex, it really created a wall between us. Mi esposo didn’t know what to do with me, and I didn’t know what to do with my morphing spouse.

Like most ill-informed people, the biggest myth I fell for was the “roid rage” phenomenon. I didn’t want our relationship to go belly-up because there may be a storming spouse around the house.

My love promised me that this truly is a myth, and now, nine months into the transition, I still get to have my silly spouse that I fell in love with more than three years ago.

We are all going to change over time, but the abruptness of going through top surgery was shocking. I really thought I’d be okay, until I had my bags packed to catch a plane, en route to help with the aftercare.

It was hard enough to see the overt sign of my butch being stolen from me, but to see Papi’s body in trauma was equally difficult.

Most sad and distressing was the fact that I couldn’t cuddle with Papi anymore. I needed to hear my love’s heartbeat, as I used to when I’d lay my head upon those soft pillows of paradise. But they were no longer there, and mi esposo was in so much pain it didn’t even allow for hugs.

Only the other day was I able to lie on my love’s chest and hear that familiar heartbeat again. It’s not the soft, cradling pillow I was used to, but at least I can listen to mi esposo’s heart.

I looked for support but found very little because partners don’t generally talk about the difficulties we face in transition. Nobody wants to be the one to say, “This fucking hurts,” lest we be judged by the politically fuelled who would label us transphobic.

The Rah-Rah Tranny people on the sidelines say we’re not supposed to grieve the loss of our soulmate to a new gender. We should a) keep it quiet and support the transgender person or b) leave the relationship or c) both.

But I screamed for support! I called a queer crisis line and they didn’t return my call for weeks on end, which I found really unacceptable.

Eventually, Papi and I found great support from people who don’t judge or label us, regardless of our feelings or choices. These friends also don’t flock to a forum to discuss how they feel Papi and I should live.

Yes, I am disliked for the honesty with which I’ve expressed my feelings toward the process and my part in it, but I will not be silenced.

Having insisted on expressing my grief, I am now slowly finding that I can love my spouse, no matter the changes.

Day by day, I find I’m falling in love all over again.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
I love you for your honesty!
Thank you for sharing this, hopefully it will help to create more support groups that can be honest about the feelings everyone goes through in the relationship! It is a fact that we as transmen change in ways that we arent even aware of once we start hormones as each body is different. I know my brother and sister are both hairier than I was, so I guessed I would be despite folks looking at my hairless body and sure enough hair sprawling all over. I hated it at first, but now am growing to love it! Thank you for accepting your partner through the changes and having the courage to talk about it in all its glorious messes! That is what love is about, loving the person, even if they make drastic changes to themselves, the core of who they are remains the same. We are also relearning ourselves in this process and how we fit into this new world!
Justin Hur, Vancouver BC
10/05/11 7:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
You are both amazng
Thanks for sharing your story so candidly. When I began transitioning, my partner at the time left me. (Being gay now, I suppose I would have left her, anyway but still). Your resilience and love for each other is amazing. It's an honour to be connected. Deeper respect for you both here.
Ryan Furber, Vancouver BC
10/05/11 7:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
... but loving a trans-woman seems impossible...
... but loving a trans-woman seems impossible... kudos for you for realizing the butch love you loved was still more butch (more buchiness to love) and not as bad as you thought... hard it may have been... but in my predicament... my spouse... loving me as her gentle 'hubby' turned out too 'femme' for my wife, as she could not accept being a 'lesbian' with a trans-woman as a spouse... me; and I have lost her forever. She told me to go find someone else who can accept me, but from my experience so far, amongst women, none are open me as far as I know from others. Trans-men do have appeal with women, but not Trans-women with women. I'm not sure why but I suspect if only because of what's between my legs, then, there is something there that does not sit well with women, unless they are open to only men with the same thing 'down there'. :(
Stefanie (SaintSuelle) Yue, Mississauga Ontario
10/06/11 4:34 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Andrea has courage and integrity
Andrea, thank you for your honesty, candour and courage. Any time a story like your comes out, the hate crowd is there with their ice picks waiting to attack the non-trans partner who dares to express anything but joy at their partner's change. Since your sexual orientation was to women's sex and bodies, you are trying to change what is innate in you to suit the change of your partner who it must be noted must have known they were trans long before they transitioned so why get married to you and then tell you! I found this duplicity disturbing. Good luck to you Andrea. Your love for this person shows your integrity. I hope you can find the courage to move on and find the butch woman you can love. In the meantime here's some support in the face of the usual hate attacks from people like the twitterers on the Xtra web page who hate you for being honest and telling the truth they cannot hear. That sexual orientation actually exists. No matter what how hard they try to pretennd it doesn't; sexual attraction is not fluid and changeable for everyone. Therefore some trans people are going to lose their partners when they change. Not out of hate and ignorance but out of the same human nature that makes a person trans also makes some people's sexual orientation fixed.
david, Toronto Ontario
10/06/11 8:24 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
inspirational and necessary
my gratitude is immense, my inspiration soars; thank you for your words, Andréa. my other half posted your story on his FB wall this AM and i haven't been able to get this line out of my head:"But I screamed for support! I called a queer crisis line and they didn’t return my call for weeks on end, which I found really unacceptable."... hence my providing feedback and extending support via cyber land to you and yours.as a woman who identifies as queer/lesbian(i like girls and bois) and as a woman who is in her 1st relationship with a trans man(previous partners have transitioned post our parting ways), i can definitely relate to a majority of your story. while sen was already 2 yrs into his transition when we met, i had inordinate questions re: how far he wanted to take his transition, etc. we were able to create a healthy dialogue and support for 1 another, as we both felt on the outskirts of the ‘community’. He still identifies as a “butch lesbian” but appears / passes as male, while i appear ‘lesbian’ (whatever that looks like). most of my 'blah' experiences are with gay men refusing to accept he is trans, which has been quite the curve ball for me (that’s another story). so, in three months, he will have top surgery. i'm grappling with this process lately, even though i've been prepared for 3 years. there are definitely silent judgments in my so called, 'open minded' queer community but, i'm happy to say, we have worked to surrounded ourselves with people who are open (despite their orientation, as that's of no concern to me, as long as you are a GOOD, HONEST and GENUINE person, who am i to judge?).I AM grateful. the reality is, the world isn't kind, but it IS getting better. i commend you on your courage and ability to evolve in your love/life. you’re a survivor! after all, love IS transition. love IS an art. and, love can surprise us in those moments we might be close to giving up. my hat goes off to you, merci beaucoup! best in health to you
alex, tucson usa
10/06/11 1:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yay and Boo
As a transman married to a femme, I enjoyed reading this. I enjoyed your blunt honesty. Both partners go through a different kind of transition- and the transition for the partner can be just as difficult.... But "Rah-Rah Tranny people?" I really wish you'd found a different way to express this sentiment.
Alexander, Holyoke MA
10/06/11 2:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Just a little note
I just wanted to thank you, Andrea, for writing. I have read tons of articles about spouses with transpeople, and this has been the most candid and honest article I've ever read. I appreciate that you don't explicitly blame your partner for his need to transition, and yet it is important to hear voices like yours that show how hard it is for spouses to handle transition. Spouses of transpeople need to know that they are not alone. Also, hopefully it also allows transpeople to learn to understand and empathize with some of the feelings and needs that spouses go through. I personally know that as a transperson who has gone through transition, it can be easy to look at everything from only your own point of view, and not from the people around you. As they say, a transperson doesn't just transition; everyone around them transitions with them. Thanks again, Andrea!
Amy S, Victoria BC
10/06/11 3:33 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Not impressed
I second Alexander's denouncement of your phrase rah rah tranny people. In case you weren't familiar, tranny is a vile, vicious word used almost (but not entirely) exclusively against trans women. It's a really freaking gross term! And, I'm actually quite dismayed at Xtra printing it. A question for the editors: If this article had been about a straight woman staying with her partner after he came out as a gay man, can you honestly say you'd allow a quote like "The rah-rah faggot crowd..." I highly doubt it. Anyway, I guess I fall into that category because I do think this article is just plain busted! Oh its so hard to love a trans person, *boohoo* imagine for two seconds what it's like to *live* as a trans person!
Kay Lamothe, Vancouver BC
10/06/11 3:44 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Re: Not Impressed
I was not aware that there was a contest here. Just because it is difficult to live as a trans person does not mean it is not difficult to love one, especially considering that Andrea was blindsided with her spouse's desire to transition AFTER they got married. Her pain is no less valid than that of her spouse. Where so many would have fled Andrea fought hard to continue her marriage, and for that she should be commended.
Melissa, Victoria BC
10/06/11 4:33 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Amor Vincit Omnia
Thank you, and bless you, for your open and honest writing. I too am a high-femme queer woman who loved a trans-man. The issues with which I wrestled were not exactly the same as the ones that you are dealing with (we are not the same people, after all :) )--but there were plenty of issues in my own quest to be at peace with that relationship. The most important part of that struggle was the dawning realization that love is NOT about bodies, and NOT about gender. I realized that I loved my (newly made) man's HEART, and MIND, and SOUL--and that all that was much more important than what was currently going on with his body and his gender. I also realized that the love that I felt for him, and the connection that we shared, was MUCH more important than how I would be defined (in terms of MY sexual orientation)by being in relationship with a trans-man. But not until I wrestled mightily with it! I was able to come to terms with the issues that arose for me, and we rode off into the sunset together (for a time...but that's another story...our break-up had nothing to do with his trans-sexuality). I remain profoundly and absolutely grateful for the lessons and transformation that were gifted to ME as the result of my struggle with his transition. The realization that TRUE love is bigger and deeper than gender and sex, and that TRUE love is about the SOUL is a gift that has enriched and evolved me in ways that I could never have previously imagined. Learning to let go of being defined by my sexual-orientation(s!)was also very powerfully freeing for me. Loving a trans-man is one of the most wonderfully amazing things that has ever happened to me, and turned out to be a profound emotional and spiritual initiation that has altered me in wonderful ways. May it be so for you as well! May our Creator bless you and your Papi with a love that transcends all struggle, and lights your hearts, and enriches our world,forever! <3 <3 <3
Heather, Eureka CA
10/06/11 4:44 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
WONDERFUL!!!!
As someone who is, for technicalities sake, a transguy, I say bravo to speaking out about it! There desperately NEEDS to be discourse around relationships in which one person decides to transition, be it MtF or FtM. I love you for partaking of this need even with people saying 'no don't do it...'
ScarUponTheSky, Las Vegas NV (USA)
10/06/11 11:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A matter of magnitude
Thanks, Andrea, for your piece. Partners of trans-people are rarely heard from, and your thoughts and feelings are valuable. I can't imagine belittling your experience, as I've seen pain and stress even from mundane transitions, like an argument and hurt feelings over a simple haircut! Your agony and anxiety can only have been orders of magnitudes more acute. I'm writing/drawing a graphic novel which deals with the subjects and your article will color some of the scenes. As a note, in some communities 'tranny' is no curse word, but a normal/standard term for general use, so 'Rah-rah-tranny' is perfectly descriptive of those folk who are all supportive of the transperson's changes, but undervalue what's required of all those around him/her. Thank you for your honesty and good luck with your marriage.
Larry Lewis, Shoreline WA, USA
10/06/11 11:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks
I'm a transguy and I am also someone who honors story. Thanks for writing this and sharing with us.
Evan Gorman, San Diego CA
10/07/11 1:53 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Coyote Grace
This article caught my eye, as my bandmates in Coyote Grace experienced this transition themselves. Ingrid Elizabeth wrote the song "Picture Frame" about watching Joe's transition unfold in the course of their relationship. There's a youtube video of us playing it a few years back if anyone's interested. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nH-nGRCPEY
Michael Connolly, Seattle, WA USA
10/07/11 2:24 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I love you my sweet Wife &amp;lt;3
Thank you all who have commented and given their views and especially to those who are understanding where my wife is coming from. I feel it is important to have support for the partner of the Tranny (yes i just used that word and use it proudly) I found a lot of support for myself, but not much at all for my Wife. I am hoping her blogging or this article helps anyone else feeling alone or in pain being a partner of a Tranny. I also wanted to point out not all Tranny's have had a hard life or a hard transition. I have been supported by more people then I ever thought possible through friends, family,coworkers, strangers and medical professionals. signed....so proud of my Wife!
Easton, Vancouver BC
10/07/11 3:18 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Disappointed
I tend to tense up when reading articles, such as this, about the blues of being with a trans person. It creates a really disempowering dialogue, this notion that you should love someone &amp;amp;amp;amp;quot;in spite of&amp;amp;amp;amp;quot; who they are, rather than because of who they are. And we don't need this disempowerment. Especially when there is still so much transphobia, even in our queer communities, telling us that trans people are unsexy, unattractive, unlovable, and hard to be with. And then we have this, this article, entitled &amp;amp;amp;amp;quot;loving a trans man isn't easy.&amp;amp;amp;amp;quot; I appreciate that this is your story, but the title alone leaves me feeling disheartened at the stereotype that is being perpetuated here. I think that this article also reinforces another really problematic and hurtful stereotype: that you can't be trans and be butch. If you identify as a butch, then you're a butch. I'm sick and tired of hearing about how trans guys or trans masculine folks have to trade in their butch badge when they transition. I was really hoping that this article would be a departure from that exclusionary narrative.
Quinn, Vancouver British Columbia
10/07/11 3:55 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Disappointed
I tend to tense up when reading articles, such as this, about the blues of being with a trans person. It creates a really disempowering dialogue, this notion that you should love someone in spite of who they are, rather than because of who they are. And we don't need this disempowerment. Especially when there is still so much transphobia, even in our queer communities, telling us that trans people are unsexy, unattractive, unlovable, and hard to be with. And then we have this, this article, entitled 'loving a trans man isn't easy'. I appreciate that this is your story, but the title alone leaves me feeling disheartened at the stereotype that is being perpetuated here. I think that this article also reinforces another really problematic and hurtful stereotype: that you can't be trans and be butch. If you identify as a butch, then you're a butch. I'm sick and tired of hearing about how trans guys or trans masculine folks have to trade in their butch badge when they transition. I was really hoping that this article would be a departure from that exclusionary narrative.
Quinn, Vancouver BC
10/07/11 3:59 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Familiar Story
It is too bad you arent here in London ON. We have an AMAZING trans community (huge) and several support systems both peer and professional. Your story is so familiar and there are no answers except those you hold within. I would suggest you contact Melady Preece for some counselling and resources for support. She is listed in the Vancouver book. Best of luck to both of you and please have a long and happy marriage. Huggs Kim
Kimberley Anne, London ON
10/07/11 11:26 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ty for your kind wishes Kim
We have a HUGE trans community here and lots of resources for Trans people. Some for Partners but not much. I'm glad you have an amazing community! We've both been to Dr Preece and she is amazing! Easton (The Tranny in the pic)
Easton, Vancouver BC
10/07/11 11:16 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rah Rah!
Excuse me, could someone tell me exactly who gave us the authority to be so divisionist? For many years the trans community has fought to unite, to obtain acceptance and inclusion, but now, that inclusion covers only the ones that fit in a certain box? Suddenly those of us who have been called tranny in hatred and who have chosen to title ourselves tranny in pride and rise above the hatred don't exist? Suddenly it is acceptable to attack someone for using a word or having an oppinion you personally don't like? Yes the word tranny is offensive to some, and that fact should be mentioned in the interest of fairness, and yes, the views in this article represent an experience rarely spoken of, but don't cut down the entire article on the basis of one word or the fact that the viewpoint is different from yours! When exactly did it become ok to cut out a voice that differs from the majority? Does anyone else remember when the world at large did that to the members of the trans community? We reacted as one, standing up for all our members. Yet now it seems it is fine for us to do this to each other. As a proud member of the "Rah Rah Tranny People" looking at the debacle of judgement and and denouncment appearing in some of the comments made about this article, I am forced to leave my spot on the sidelines and speak up. Andrea Hector has written a brilliant and breathtakingly honest article about the pain and turmoil the partners of trans people find themselves walking through. She has done what the activists of our community have been doing for years; stood up, broke the silence and spoken her truth about the pain and anxiety our partners face when the ones they love transition. It may differ from the opinions of some, it may be new and scary, but that doesn't mean it isn't valuable. If for honestly expressing herself we would condemn Andrea Hector, then we are no better than those who would condemn us for being who we are.
Erik Eide, Nanaimo BC
10/08/11 2:05 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
We are not alone
Thank you for speaking the truth! Often I find myself and other partners unwilling to share our struggles, because frankly it isn't like we are changing our gender or anything... (Smile) I identify as a dyke on the masculine scale and have gotten more comfortable expressing my more feminine side outside of my partners transition to a straight white man - and it has been a challenge for both of us. I love him and he loves me. AND often his heterosexual privilege, our heterosexual legal marriage, etc., can distance if not remove me/us entirely from the queer community and then can disclosure of difficulties can further remove me/us by being perceived as transphobia, biphobia, or what I call straightphobia. I worked hard to be queer. In a lot of ways I am still very very queer - it is just not widely validated in my everyday life. Thank you SO much for reminding me and others - we are not alone. Jess
Jessica Pettitt, Eureka CA
10/08/11 11:02 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Easton, I'm appalled.
You say that "I feel it is important to have support for the partner of the Tranny (yes i just used that word and use it proudly)". That word isn't yours. It hasn't historically been used against trans men, and it's not really yours to claim, let alone "proudly". If you want more context on why you really really REALLY shouldn't be using that word, Tobi Hill-Meyer explains it very succinctly here: http://nodesignation.com/?p=32
Steph, Vancouver BC
10/16/11 9:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
missed the point
A few of you have missed the point of the critique of ANDREA's (allcaps for emphasis, not volume) use of "tr**ny". It goes something like this: ANDREA IS NOT TRANS, therefore ANDREA has no business flinging that word around. There are ongoing conversations in trans communities about who WITHIN our communities can use the word in a reclaimed sense (mostly whether and to what extent trans men can rightfully use it), but those are not conversations I care to have with non trans people, and certainly not in a space like this. Here is a link to some discussion about language people may find interesting/ helpful: http://dglenn.dreamwidth.org/1588929.html And no, that cannot be simplistically boiled down to "If for honestly expressing herself we would condemn Andrea Hector, then we are no better than those who would condemn us for being who we are." What an intriguing twist you've made, Erik! So now when trans people speak out about something that is hurting us, we are actually no better than our oppressors? Neato! I bet those who would condemn us would actually love to hear from you about joining their campaign. It is quite simply about setting boundaries with people WHO ARE NOT TRANS (for starters) around using words that are actually painful for many (not all) of us. As Lisa Harney over at http://www.questioningtransphobia.com/ says: "There’s a difference between a member of a minority using a word with a painful history and members of the majority reifying that painful history." As someone who professes so much desire to be understood and respected for speaking out about her "situation", I would like to imagine that Andrea is quite capable of understanding and respecting that.
anonymous, vancouver bc
10/21/11 2:47 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
It's just a fucking word!
She wrote an honest and deeply personal account of an aspect of her life. Cut the PC crap it's a just a fucking word, ''Tranny'' ''Tranny'' ''Tranny'' ''Tranny''. Is it a good appropriate word to use in polite conversation? No. But is the work itself supportive of trans people? Yes. So being so ridiculioulsy critical is completly missplaced. It's not like she was saying, ''I hate trannies and they should all die!" Let's have some common sense here. Also, it's totally ridiculous to suggest that only certain people are aloud to ''reclaim'' a word. It's either an impolite word or it's not.......................................... And just for good measure: Dyke, Dyke, Faggot, Faggot, Faggot, Faggot, Tranny, Tranny, Tranny.
George, Branden Manitoba
10/21/11 4:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thinking Some Just Like To Argue
Steph, do not attempt to make claims which are not fact. You stated, (in regards to Easton's use of the word Tranny) "That word isn't yours. It hasn't historically been used against trans men, and it's not really yours to claim, let alone "proudly"." I am a trans man, and have been attacked for being a trans man, and been called a tranny, in hatred, by my attackers and I am not alone in that. I know quite a few trans men who have had that experience. Honestly, I am sorry you are upset, but do not tell me or any other trans man that “That word isn’t yours” I earned the right to reclaim it as my own with every bone they broke in my face that night, as have many other trans men, and until you know that the trans guy you are speaking to was not one of that group, have some respect that others have struggled just as hard on this journey as our trans sisters Anonymous, you are right, Andrea is not trans, Andrea is a trans supporter and partner of a trans man, ergo in the eyes of the vigilant grammar police of this community she has no rights, no freedom of expression, no room to learn and grow. She isn’t trans, but she has merely done what trans people have done for years, expressed herself honestly. Was it the most PC way to speak up? No, maybe not, but it was Andrea Hector Brown, speaking in her own voice, telling her own story. That is to be commended, perhaps educated, but not silenced as some would try to do.
Erik Eide, Nanaimo BC
10/21/11 7:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Tomayto-Tomahto
Seriously?!?!?! So, you mean to tell me that it is OKAY to invalidate Andrea's experience with her husband's transition just because she used the word "tranny"? Reguardless of the verbiage used (and whether or not some ass-hat is going to get their knickers in a wad over it), the point still remains the same. And what that point is is this: Andrea is a woman who up until her beloved's transition had viewed and identified as a lesbian, and now, with her beloved transitioning, she is now having to "transition" as it were as well, and she is voicing the difficulty of this "transition" because it means something different than how she had seen herself. So, she used the "wrong" term as deemed by some holier-than-thou trans person. All I have to say is grow up and get over it. NOWHERE in the entire article did Andrea say she is anti-trans, NOWHERE did she attack ANYONE for their journey into transition. She merely used a supposedly "out of favour" term. Realistically, the fact that she even spoke up takes a LOT of courage, and through so many people blasting and flaming her for it, this proves my point. Her stance, and experience is the same as MANY of the partners and spouses of trans folk, she is certinaly not the only one and certainly not alone. So rather than making this all about YOU, why don't we look and see that this is HER experience and HER story right now and get the hell over ourselves for a moment and share in the fact that we too have more than likely felt what she is feeling or something very similar to it. *stepping off soap box/end rant*
Behr, Seattle Washington
10/21/11 9:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Oh come on
People, get a grip, no one is "silencing" or "attacking" Andrea for what she wrote here. So the writer can comment on what she pleases, however she pleases, using words and phrases meant to make the point that there is somehow some mob of trans people out there who are being somehow unfair to her (what precisely did you think she was trying to get across when she said "The Rah-Rah Tr**ny people on the sidelines say we’re not supposed to grieve the loss of our soulmate to a new gender. We should a) keep it quiet and support the transgender person or b) leave the relationship or c) both"? Who said this? How is it OK for her to lump trans people into some category as though we're all saying the same thing?), but when people take issue with pieces of it, suddenly we all apparently are silencing and attacking her? Come on now. I support anyone's right to say as they please, I only request that they be open to hearing critique of it. If Andrea didn't actually want to hear from people, she wouldn't have posted this so publicly. Andrea's apparently a grownup, I'm sure she can handle it.
anonymous, vancouver bc
10/21/11 9:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
You never say, he and him
Why is that? Why the avoidance of male pronouns for your -husband-, hmmm? And seriously, man stink? I've known many, many women who have stunk to high heaven. Man stink? Really? -Clit- Are you kidding me? On so many levels I find much of your story details offensive and your writing style crude at best. For those issues alone you should lose access to the tiara and stilettos! Femme Rah! ;)
Cats Ass, South of you USA
10/21/11 9:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Kettle pot black
I get that you are sorting out your reactions to your husband's transition. Mostly, what I get is your rage and need for your butch to validate your sexuality and orientation. Your anger of having lost that female lover. Sadly, this narrative is going to be camped on. Funny how female to male transsexuals are often blasted for the very same thing, forcing their femmes to go straight. Stealth? Really? Seems your man was stealth before he named his sex and orientation. You are pissed it is not what you want it to be. You are pissed because his transition makes you stealth because he no longer looks like the stereotyped lesbian. Oh, and when does the conversation turn to his being out as a transsexual so that you can keep the visual queer lesbian card? And he never gets to interact socially as a man. Are you going to write another article to talk about how much you love the man you married, more than the two sentences you shared thus far? Will that narrative receive as much support and validation? Will be as validating to the queer community? It will be interesting to read where you are further down along in the transition.
Jack, double standards USA
10/21/11 9:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Loving a transman can be REALLY easy
I married a straight woman. She saw me for who I was/am despite some of the biological accoutrements that came with me. She never had a hard time loving me or accepting me, Pre or Post transition. To be with someone who made her happy was her only desire. The politics of naming identity means nothing to her as the naming of orientation is just a conveniences for other peoples comforts. Just saying that not everyone has a hard time loving a transman. Kinda ironic that in the gay community the femme is considered the perfect match for a transman as he is really an urber butch-lesbian but evidently this troublesome for the author. So at some level she does see the man she married. Anyhow, I just wanted to put it out there, that transmen can find love in all the right places outside the lesbian community and the issues this femme has presented which seem to be common. A side note, if she was really interested in being vocal about her personal experience I am certain she would have been able to make the title of her comment into an I, statement not a generality. But by making such a liberal statement she can garner an audience for her blog which is listed in her article. The title really does detract from the amazing great things transmen bring to relationships and it set a subtle but profound perception that relationships in general with transsexuals are difficult. An I statement would have brought to light her homo-normative social, sexual and cognitive bias/expectation when confronted with heterosexuality via her husbands transition. The article seems to me to be a big blame statement rather than an exploration of her own prejudices. And lastly, I hope the husband is comfortable with the reality that this article and subsequent blog posts can be sourced. That the act of this post in the newspaper and online means that his right to silence and right to privacy has been reduced. I hope you both can find a place with each other. Best of luck.
Mark, cyberland US
10/22/11 12:16 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wow, really people??
I can't believe some of the backlash from this article! I mean, seriously! This is a raw, honest, sincere piece, and as a transman, I totally GET where she's coming from. Yes it's hard to be trans, but don't think for one second that you transition alone in a relationship!! Our partners go through this too, and the thing is, as transfolk, we are allowed to talk about our journey and how hard it was, and point out the things that suck about it - but our partners aren't allowed that same freedom of expression, for fear of being called transphobic. It's BULLSH!T. Transition isn't easy for partners either. And as for the word 'tranny' that has everyone so pi$$ed off - I don't use or particularly love the word - but it's also a regional thing. Some trans communities DO use the word - and besides that, it is more about the WAY it's used, and she didn't use it out of bias or hatred. I am ashamed at how some of my own trans community have attacked the article and the author. I found it to be very honest and very necessary. How about we allow others to speak their truths without ripping them apart...
Mike, SE Minnesota USA
10/23/11 2:13 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Loving a trans man isn't hard.
Loving a trans man isn't hard. Loving an asshole is hard. Loving someone who can't express or respect boundaries is hard. Loving someone who isn't giving you what you need is hard. But loving a trans man isn't hard, because there is no one version of "trans man", there is no one story, way of being, mode of being in a relationship, and so on. When you say "loving a trans man is hard", you are attempting to bunch "trans men" into one category, somehow fraught with peril, and that's just neither fair nor accurate. How about people take ownership of their own bullshit? Their own limitations? Their own desires? THAT would be a true story. THAT would be heartening. THAT would be closer to a real accounting of YOUR struggles, because that's what this story is about. When you attempt to cluster trans men into this "hard to love" group, you do us all a disservice, including yourself.
anonymous, vancouver bc
10/28/11 8:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.