Dear younger self
LOOSE END / When did I become a butch elder?
Ivan Coyote / Vancouver / Thursday, June 02, 2011
Share |

A couple of weeks ago a young butch friend of mine asked me if I would help her out with her art-school homework. She said she was doing a photo project, taking pictures of older butches. You know, like, documenting her elders.

Sure, I thought to myself, I know several older butches who I could hook her up with. A couple of them have moved to the Sunshine Coast, like they do, but I could certainly track them down, no problem.

It slowly dawned on me that she was referring to me. I was the older butch she wanted to document. At first this realization made me laugh, and then it made my right knee ache, like it does.

I am 42. She is 21. I can’t help but do the math. I had been out of the closet for three years already by the time she was born. I was navigating my way through the gender binary blues when she was learning to do up the Velcro straps on her first-day-of-school shoes. She has probably never dialled a rotary phone.

More and more at my shows, young butches and barely whiskered trans guys have been coming up and telling me that my books and stories helped them get through high school, or even junior high. They thank me for being a role model. This makes me feel simultaneously honoured and terrified. It makes my heart sing to know that they had what I didn’t even know I needed when I was a kid: someone they could imagine growing up to be like. It makes my heart pound to know that this means I now have to somehow be worthy of this kind of respect.

How can I possibly be a role model when I feel like I am just now starting to fit into my own skin? When I am still stretching and bending the space around me to make room for myself? How could I possibly give advice away when I just got my hands on it?

I find it way easier to imagine whispering any wisdom I may have gleaned from the last four decades into the ear of a younger me. If I could magically tell my younger self something I know now that I wish I had known then, what would that be?

First of all, I would tell myself not to be too proud to ask for advice. Remember, you don’t have to take advice just because someone has given it. Of course, my 21-year-old self may not have taken the time to listen to present-day me, but I will continue, regardless.

Dear younger self: floss your teeth. It turns out you will eventually be a working artist, just like you always dreamed. A man named Stephen Harper will one day rule this land, and he will care nothing for artists or queers or even healthcare. You need teeth, and you alone will be financially responsible for them. Floss is cheaper than even your commie pinko East End lesbian dentist will be.

Quit smoking. Please see above. I am not going to say this again. Okay, I am. Quit smoking right now.

Your mother is worried that no one will like you or hire you or even love you if you look “like that.” She is wrong. This next bit is really important: she does not mean to intentionally do you harm or cause you to fear who and what you truly are. She worries because she fears what the world might do to you, and because she doesn’t know any successful tattooed butch storytellers with biceps and a brush cut. Yet. But one day she will, and she is going to love the hell out of future you. Trust me on this one.

Do not cave in to pressure from mainstream society to fit in. You do not, and will not ever, fit in. One day you will realize you don’t even want to anymore, and that your difference is inherently tied to your beauty, and your bravery, and your giant, mystical, invisible brass balls. You will love these balls, and they will swing majestically between your ears, inside the head you will hold up proudly.

Do not cave in to pressure from the queer community to fit in, either. Make your own decisions, and trust your own heart. Being butch is not just a bus stop on the highway to transitioning. You will learn to love your butch self. If you do ever decide to go on testosterone, build yourself into a good man. The last thing the world needs is another misogynist prick. Be the man your father accidentally taught you to be, even if it was only because you didn’t have a brother to help him out in the shop.

Make and keep long-term friendships. You will need them, and they will need you. This is one of the most important things you will ever do in your entire life.

Whenever possible, be polite. In the long run, your good manners will serve you better than even your most righteous rage.

Find a tailor, and be good to them. Get your pants hemmed properly, and learn what it feels like to have your clothes really fit your body. People come in all shapes; clothes do not. This is a wrong that can be easily righted. The world is going to try to squeeze you into many things that do not fit you, but your clothes need not be one of them.

Seek out a mentor. Listen to what they have to say, and then follow your own path. Keep a journal because one day someone is going to look up to you and even ask you for advice, and you are going to wish you had taken better notes.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Sretching and bending the space!
Thanks for your wonderful new column, Ivan. You inspire me, and many of us. And do not be scared because you do inspire us. Being bi, and a femme bi at that, I never had to learn to "adapt" as much, but believe me: We all are stretching and bending the space around us to fit it in some way. We all still try, no matter what age, to fit into our own skin, in our own life, and in our own visions and dreams of a better world. You make a wonderful role model by just being who you are, don't worry. Thank you for inspiring so many of us.
Nike, Cologne, Germany NRW
06/02/11 12:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Best column ever!
Ivan, you've set a new benchmark! The content, the tone and the wordcrafting in this column is perfect. And I wasn't even halfway through when my eyes started burning with tears. Now I have red eyes and a runny nose. Good on ya! Jo
Jo Seidl, Powell River BC
06/02/11 12:08 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The mystical balls!
Oh, Ivan, I just love you! You made me cry, again, and I love your fierce, intelligent, funny, compassionate self, then and now. Thank you, again and again and again.
Fiona, Vancouver B.C.
06/02/11 12:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
THANK YOU
Ivan, I wish I could have know you or someone like you when I was young. Thank you for helping the next generation of butches grow into themselves with love and pride.
Tracy, Tukwila, Wa United States
06/02/11 4:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thank You
I've never commented here before, but as a twenty-year-old bisexual butch, I'd just like to say that you've done an incredible job of being a role model and an inspiration for me. Before I discovered you, I was lost on the gender spectrum, not understanding how I could feel so masucline without having the desire to transition to male. I didn't know how to identify. I'd heard the word butch, but I didn't understand what it meant. A while ago, I read all your articles on Xtra, and then bought and read all your books. For the first time in my life, I found an identity that fit me perfectly. I've proudly identified as butch ever since. I want to thank you for everything you've done for young people like me. I recently completed a writing challenge in which we had to write to thirty people, including the person we want to be. I wrote that letter to you, and I feel lucky to have you as a role model. Reading your work has made me laugh, and it's made me cry like the little girl I never really was. It's given me a confidence and sense of identity and community that I'd never found before. I want to thank you for all the advice and inspiration you give people like me, and I hope you never feel inadequate as a butch role model.
Sarah, Ottawa Ontario
06/02/11 5:47 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
welcome to the club!
I do not feel like I have grown up yet, this at 55! In one month I'll be 56, where on earth does the time go? Frankly, the measurment of time is futile, what does matter is the journey, this journey shared...I sit an listen, watch, wonder, wait...I share when asked, offering lessons learned-but it si each of us that learns the lessons that are needed...why didn't I listen, why don't they? All I can do is shake my head and remember the knowing smiles that greeted me when I would not understand.. to each his/her own...
sandy, easton usa
06/02/11 8:02 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Once again, Brilliant
Ivan, once again you have given me much food for thought. As a fairly-high femme, I have always wished for a good, old-fashioned, old-school butch that knows how to treat a lady. Finally, I found that in my wife, and am happy and well taken care of. I think that a lot of the younger butches do need a mentor, one who can teach them the gentlemanly and quiet ways of self-confidence and self awareness. And if they cannot find their role model close by, I hope that they read and take to heart your writing. Mela
Mela, Portland Oregon
06/02/11 8:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
You can't help but be inspiring
Ivan, I am so honoured that I had the chance to meet you and through that meeting, be linked into your column. You are such a talented writer. Your honesty shines like a beacon for everyone. I hope one day we can all live in a world where each of us is valued just because we are. Your words made me smile and cry--they touched my heart and that is a very inspiring gift. Thank you for sharing the gift of you.
Camille, Surrey BC
06/02/11 10:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
beautiful
you did it again. note to younger you, keep writing! it makes people happy.
medina, eugene oregon whaa?
06/02/11 11:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wonderful
You're clever and well-spoken, Ivan. There's a woman in my office building in her late-twenties (maybe early 30s; not sure) who identifies as a butch. While she's confident and proud about it, I hear a lot of people scoff at her behind her back for it and it just irks me to no end. In fact, I've gotten into a few arguments with people over it, only to learn that people only listen when it seems to suit their cause. Trying to combat the negative mentality can be so frustrating sometimes. Then again, I wore a tie to work once and heard gay jokes about it for two weeks, so I suppose that's an indicator as to the people I'm contending with. Keep writing. There are a lot of people who benefit from your work. All the best!
Kate, St. John's NL
06/03/11 6:07 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I loved it
This is just beautiful Ivan. What a wonderful column.
bloomie, Brooklyn NY
06/03/11 4:35 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
It only gets better
I've never been butch. I used to think I wanted to be although now, at 64 and a grandmother many times over that identity question has become moot. I'm just an older dyke living with her older dyke wife and being happier and more content than I ever thought possible and finding ourselves looked up to just as you have. Your eloquence and advice are bang on and I agree wholeheartedly with you regarding health and self care. Keep up the excellent work.
Laura, Watsonville CA
06/04/11 1:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Grateful
I had the honor of meeting you last year when you come to LA and tell you in person that you are one of my mentors. I am grateful to all of the elders who come before me and made things better for my generation. I promise to do my best for those that are coming after me. Thank you Ivan for being you, standing up and speaking out your light shines on me and reminds me to do the same.
Claudius Maximus (Max), Los Angeles, CA USA
06/04/11 3:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Love, Want, Can't Get Enough!
Luv ur writing. http://loosefemme.wordpress.com/
Loosefemme, Oakland California
06/07/11 4:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Beautiful
That is all.
Tara, White Rock BC
08/16/11 5:35 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.