But are they queer?
QUEER TO ETERNITY / If straight people call themselves queer, what are we?
Mette Bach / Vancouver / Thursday, January 14, 2010
Share |

Everyone gossips. Ask anyone in junior high or anyone who regularly attends a house of worship. Ask anyone who lives in a seniors’ centre or a co-op. Gossip is part of what we do. It’s “natural.” 
 
But that doesn’t mean it isn’t awful and destructive.
 
There’s a couple I’ve heard about for years. A man and a woman who live together in a couple-like scenario. They’ve built a home together, they go to each other’s family functions and, presumably, they have sex. So they are what they claim to be: partners.
 
But here’s the snag: They also both claim to be queer, and this is why they are so legendary that I know all about the details of their sexuality from all kinds of people even though I’ve never met them myself. 
 
Did they have their same-sex experiences before they got together? Can you call yourself queer after you’ve coupled with the opposite sex? Isn’t it bad etiquette to go to queer events with your opposite-sex partner?
 
Maybe they are impostors, eager to appropriate the cachet of queerness, trying to hang with the cool kids, talkin’ the talk but not walkin’ the walk. Yap. Yap. Yap. 
 
As usual, these questions and observations negate the bisexual experience and are offensive and nosey and ultimately really inappropriate. Love is love wherever you find it. 
 
But there’s more to it, of course. The word queer is a word of change. It is its own little mini-revolution within the larger more historical context of the sexual liberation movement.
 
The word queer engages all sexualities outside of what these two appear to be living. This is what gets everyone’s back up. I get it. The real question on everyone’s mind is “If straight people can call themselves queer, what are we?”
 
It boils down to something like this: If “those people” can say they are a part of this movement, that changes what “this movement” is. It just does. Camps are created, sides are taken, and differences are noticed.
 
Personally, I think that the beauty of the word queer is that it includes all kinds of experience, even that of the folks in the eye of the gossip storm (who hopefully have no idea that a little trail of whispers follows them everywhere they go).
 
Queerness is not an exclusive club. If people want to label themselves queer, that’s good enough for me.
 
Let the masses appropriate all they want. Let us dilute this precious pool we’re swimming in. I don’t see the harm. The problem isn’t with those who want to identify as queer. The problem is with sticking our noses where they don’t belong.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
"Queer" is a big country
A lot of homosexuals forget that the word "Queer" was coined in part to unite the wide range of ways of living outside the norm - undoing some of the damage wrought by psychiatry, which defined homosexuality as an illness, distinct from breaking other gender norms. And I know many one-woman/one-man couples who are definitely Queer. [---paragraph break---] Some are gender-variant, and when not holding hands (and sometimes even when they are), get read as gay or lesbian. If one of them acts gender-normative, and the other does not, the "normal" one may still be ejected from the hetero club on account of hooking up with a swishy dude who might be mistaken for a woman, or a woman who's too butch, and who may be mistaken for a man. [---paragraph break---] Sometimes one or both are bisexual. If they're both bisexual, one of the things they have in common is constantly taking flack from hets for being too homo, and flack from homosexuals from being too het - homosexuals who refuse to date them, and then who condemn them for sleeping with the other sex rather than choosing a life of bisexual celibacy. [---paragraph break---] Sometimes, one or both people are transsexual. Your relationship might be hetero, but bigots won't see it that way. Remember Pvt. Barry Winchell, murdered by his coworkers for going out with a transsexual woman? [---paragraph break---] Or they could be poly - many forms of which are still illegal in Canada. [---paragraph break---] Or they could be more than one of the above. [---paragraph break---] All of the people in these couples can be targeted by anti-queer laws, slurs or fists, just as much as anyone in a same-gender relationship. [---paragraph break---] Think also of norms of dating based on race, religion, ability, class and age. [---paragraph break---] What unites us as Queers is breaking with the assumption that everyone should be heterosexual, cisgendered, and live in a suburban bung
Amy Fox, Vancouver BC
01/14/10 12:13 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
It ate my comment!
...suburban bungalow.
Amy Fox, Vancouver BC
01/14/10 12:16 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
re: Queer is a big country
I am pleased to see Amy's comment, which covers a lot of the ways that queer people in hetero-appearing circumstances are marginalized. I'm in love with a male-bodied person, and I'm female-bodied... does that mean I give up my queerness? I haven't - this has not feminized nor normalized me at all.
jael, Vancouver BC
01/14/10 12:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.