WorldPride worries
EDITORIAL
Danny Glenwright / Toronto / Thursday, March 21, 2013
Share |

Let’s be honest — Toronto does not feel ready to host the world’s gay masses in a little more than a year. When winter bids adieu and the snow melts on Church Street, the strip always feels a bit sad. This year, however, there is something foreboding about it. They are coming. And this is what we have to show them.

Meanwhile, despite their success in getting out of debt and righting a once-troubled ship, there have been worrying signals from those in charge. In a very public cock-up of their WorldPride theme announcement in January, the team at Pride Toronto prematurely released a video featuring the Parachute Club’s “Rise Up” before they’d secured the rights to use the song. What’s worse, the sophomoric video (thankfully, only a few were able to view it before it was hastily taken down) was a study in how not to do PR. It featured what appeared to be a series of mostly straight drunken Halloween revellers. One man sang the praises of several Toronto neighbourhoods yet failed to mention the gay village.

It’s the same story with the lamentable WorldPride logo, a collection of rainbow-coloured falling leaves created not by gay people, but on the cheap by Tourism Toronto. Then again, withered foliage that once clung proudly to a strong tree may be an appropriate metaphor for the Church Wellesley Village in the wider city of Toronto.
The team behind the Cawthra Park Green Space Pride parties has artwork that puts WorldPride's logo to shame.

But why do we feel the need to use the rainbow for every gay representation? Gay people are supposed to be imaginative; let’s move beyond it. The Church Wellesley Village BIA’s new gateway markers are a case in point. Who thought these were a good idea? And regrettable design aside, aren’t “gateway markers” supposed to stand opposite each other as a sort of, you know, gateway to a neighbourhood?

Perhaps the greatest disappointment is the City of Toronto’s complete lack of interest in contributing to an improvement of the gaybourhood and thus increasing the potential to bring in bucketloads of tourist dollars. Casinos and the Pan Am Games, instead, consume those at city hall. A study way back in 2006 found that Pride Week brings $99 million into the regional economy every year and creates more than 800 jobs in Ontario. So with WorldPride coming in 2014, the city surely has recognized the opportunity to introduce Toronto to thousands of new gay tourists — and hopefully kindle a love for the city, drawing them back, wallets bulging with pink currency. Nope.

An office was instead created to prepare for the 2015 Pan Am Games, and councillors have earmarked tens of millions for the one-off sporting event, including up to $23 million for soil remediation, whatever that means, on the parcel of land in Scarborough to be used for the Pan Am Aquatics Centre. Toronto’s shortsighted councillors obviously did not read the literature out of Winnipeg after that city hosted the Pan Am Games in 1999. “If one was to ask: ‘On an investment of $130 million, what did we get for it?’ most would be hard-pressed to come up with a significant list,” Winnipeg Mayor Sam Katz told the National Post in 2008.

Sadly, Pride Toronto remains last among those cultural organizations that receive money from the city. It got just $123,807 in 2012. (Not even enough to buy two more rainbow gateway markers to complete the set.)

Yet there are some glimmers of hope. Ward 27 Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam has worked doggedly at lighting fires under the rear ends of apathetic Village business owners. Her idea for a mural project has taken off and is a good start to rejuvenating the area where, like it or not, most of WorldPride will take place. And Xtra recently sat down with Mathieu Chantelois, one of the people behind the wildly successful Cawthra Park Green Space Pride parties in support of The 519. His team is organized and resourceful and last year brought in more than $224,000. Their artwork puts Pride’s rainbow leaves to shame, and they’ll soon be announcing an exciting new project that will radically alter the geography of this summer’s Pride festivity.

Yet Chantelois expressed frustration that potential partners at Pride Toronto and the Church Wellesley Village BIA have so far spurned his requests for cooperation. It’s a position those groups may want to reconsider — Chantelois’s team is burgeoning with creative energy, and they have shown they can turn a big profit. If our oft-divided and underfunded community is going to pull off a WorldPride to be proud of, this silo mentality has got to go. When the snow melts on Church Street three years from now, the Pan Am athletes will have long gone home and Rob Ford’s city hall will hopefully be a distant memory. But our community, and its awesome annual Pride celebration, will remain. Let’s work together to keep making it even better, if only for ourselves.


Share |


Reader Comments

These reader comments are posted directly. No editorial review is made prior to posting. Readers may contact the moderator with any complaints or concerns, and these will be reviewed within two business days.

 
Learn from London
I certainly hope Toronto can pull it together and learn from London when it hosted WorldPride last year and nearly had to cancel the entire endeavour. http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2012/06/28/pride-london-funding-shortfall-sees-worldpride-heavily-scaled-back/
Justen, Toronto Ontario
03/21/13 11:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
No one does silos like Xtra/PTP
'this silo mentality has got to go' Really, Xtra is complaining about a silo mentality? That's funny. As usual with Xtra and Pink Triangle Press it's 'do as we say, not as we do.'
PTP Layoffs, Toronto Ontario
03/21/13 11:19 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Why do we believe this?
Why does anyone think that World Pride is going to be anything other than another Toronto Pride - but with more decorations? World Pride has failed all three times that it has been attempted. It is NOT the draw that professional pride event organizers want us to believe it is. No one outside of the InterPride voting members cares. World Pride Rome (2000) - claims 250,000 people in their march. World Pride Jersualem (2005 / 2006) - cancelled two years in a row. World Pride London 2012 - cancelled 9 days before it was to happen. Millions of people were NOT affected by any of the cancellations. And we are left to believe Traci Sandilands when she told us that 5 MILLION people would come to Toronto for our World Pride. I don't see World Pride in Toronto being any bigger than it usually is unless San Francisco and New York agree to cancel their events that year. World Pride is NOT the draw that we've been led to believe it will be. And we're going to pay the price...
Brian, Toronto ontario
03/21/13 12:21 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
CORRECTION BRIAN
Just to be sure history is not recorded wrong here... WORLD PRIDE JERUSALEM 2005 was cancelled because of security concerns, Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip had their security forces working overtime, plus there was a $5000 (us) bounty on the head of any homosexual who attended. 2006 World Pride Jerusalem happened, during Israel-Lebanon conflict, the government cancelled the march, saying there were not enough soldiers to protect marchers. World Pride Conference and gathering was staged. Much in part because of the strength and support of Pride Toronto volunteers.
mark, Toronto ON
03/21/13 9:55 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Oh man,
I got a bad feeling about this.
badgayman, Toronto ON
03/21/13 10:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
QuAIA and World Pride 2014
The above editorial expresses disappointment that the City of Toronto is not giving more money to Pride Toronto for World Pride 2014. Since many City councillors are opposed to funding QuAIA's hate crusade at annual Pride events, why would they support giving even more money for World Pride 2014? At World Pride 2012 in London, QuAIA-types hijacked the gay rights agenda of the international event in order to demonize gay-friendly Israel and support Israel's homophobic enemies in the Mid-East who persecute and kill gays. See: http://mondoweiss.net/2012/07/palestine-takes-center-stage-at-world-pride.html QuAIA will undoubtedly do the same for World Pride 2014 in Toronto. I expect that QuAIA will go far beyond their usual tactics to make a real spectable for the foreign media covering the event. It's only going to get worse.
David, Toronto ON
03/21/13 11:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Post Your Comment!
Your Name:
(required)


City/Town:
(required)


Province:
(required)




Email Address:
(required)



For verification purposes only. Not for publication, nor released to any mailing list. (Privacy statement)

Title of your comment:
(required)


Your Comment: (max. 2000 characters)
(required)
characters remaining

 Refresh
Enter the code shown on the left (case-sensitive):
(required)




   
Click here to read guidelines

Guidelines for reader comments

Submissions go directly online, without being seen by editors. So, it’s important that you follow the laws against defamation. Do that by keeping your comments focussed on issues, and on your ideas and opinions. Do not get personal and do not defame others. If you see defamatory comments made in other people’s postings, report them to our moderator, who will investigate within two business days.

Your comment must directly relate to the subject of the article.

Avoid confusing statements; express your thoughts clearly and succinctly so readers will understand your opinion. Do not post superficial comments, such as a short phrase or just a few words.

Do not post promotions of products, services or events. If you see such postings, report them to our moderator, who will investigate within two business days.

Your comment and name may also be published in an Xtra paper.

Publication of your comments on Xtra.ca or in an Xtra paper is not an endorsement of your views by Xtra.ca or Pink Triangle Press.