Toronto's gay community to storm city hall rotunda May 16
NEWS / Bringing a message to Rob Ford before axe falls on Pride Toronto funding
Andrea Houston / Toronto / Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Share |

On the eve of the International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia - and with potential cuts to Pride Toronto (PT) funding looming - Toronto’s queer community will bring a big gay message to the city hall rotunda on May 16.

The message will be directed to Mayor Rob Ford and city councillors: PT is more than just a parade and a party. “It’s about building community, creating jobs and saving lives,” former Community Advisory Panel member Michael Went tells the group of about 20 activists, community members and representatives from various gay, lesbian and trans organizations who gathered at Ryerson University on May 9.

Call it City Hall Pride. Billed as “a celebration of the best of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans community,” speakers have been lined up to talk candidly about how the festival touches lives every year. Expect to see drag queens and performers and hear personal stories and heartfelt testimonials.

The Proud of Toronto group formed in April when it became clear that Ford had put a target on the gay community, beginning with Pride Week. PT may soon face devastating funding cuts, which could cost the city World Pride in 2014 and quite likely force the organization into bankruptcy, says PT co-chair Francisco Alvarez.

“We're a group of people who see the risk and decided to do something to stop it,” Went says. “The mission is to protect LGBT services.”
The Proud of Toronto group plans the May 16 city hall event.
(Andrea Houston)


Many of those programs and services, like the 519 Church Street Community Centre, the AIDS Committee of Toronto, Planned Parenthood and the Inside Out film festival will also be involved on May 16. Other groups, such as Tourism Toronto, will speak to PT’s economic impact.

Youth will play a big role in the event: members of the St Joe’s GSA in Mississauga and youth from Buddies in Bad Times Theatre will take part.

“Youth are really powerful,” notes Brendan Healy, artistic director at Buddies.

PT is on the agenda at the next executive committee meeting, on May 24, and the final vote on funding at city council is expected in June. The issue was previously on the agenda to be debated April 20, but Ford deferred the item because it fell on Passover, allowing the Jewish community time to mobilize. Alvarez notes that the threats to funding should have ended when it was determined that Queers Against Israeli Apartheid’s message was not hate speech, according to the city manager’s report, released on April 12.

Just days after the release of the report, QuAIA announced that the group would not march in the parade. The move was meant to serve as a challenge to Ford and city council to continue to fund PT, now that there are seemingly no more excuses not to.

“Now the city wants a written guarantee that QuAIA won’t take part in the festival,” Alvarez says. “They won’t get that from anyone.”

Kevin Beaulieu, executive assistant to Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam, also stresses the urgency of the event. He says the key will be convincing councillors before the motion hits the floor for a vote.

“It’s hard to win something at council if it's been approved at executive committee,” he says. “That’s why this event is so important.”

Went says PT’s funding is likely just the first in a series of chops to Toronto’s arts, culture and HIV-prevention programs.

“When Rob Ford voted against HIV funding, it sent a chill through our community,” Went says, citing the recent council vote where Ford was the only dissenter against $100,000 in provincial funding for an anti-HIV/syphilis initiative. The investment passed with a vote of 44 to one.

Went points to the upcoming “core services review” as the place the cuts will be decided for next year. With a projected shortfall now nearing $800 million, many in the city are bracing for the axe to fall as council searches for savings. The review is happening through May and June.

“To have an impact on what happens next year, you will have to get involved now,” he says.

Proud of Toronto at city hall:

Read more:


Share |


Reader Comments


 
What exactly will be debated
I'm still not sure what's going to be debated on May 24. I thought that the item deferred to the 24th was whether or not to accept/receive the City Manager's report. Does anyone know if there is actually going to be a motion to strip funding? It's hard to make a deputation on a motion if you don't know what the motion is.
Robert, Toronto Ontario
05/10/11 12:50 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Who is the Trans Speaker?
Perhaps they'll have something positive to report about Pride Toronto by the 16th...
Nichola (Nicki) Ward, toronto Ontario
05/10/11 6:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pride Toronto must take a stand against HATE
The leadership of Pride Toronto must take a stand against hate. The anti Israel gang must have nothing to do with the parade.
Meir Weinstein, Toronto Ontario
05/10/11 8:04 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pride of Toronto campaign is misleading
One is lead believe from their advertising campaign (Proud of Toronto aka Pride toronto) that it is all queer groups in Toronto this is totally misleading. Don't believe it. It's Only LGBTQ groups that march in Pride Parade or are located in the Church St village. Since it is a well know fact that Pride Toronto absolutely hates the Queer West Arts and Culture Centre and everything they stand for (An organization that holds the Annual Queer West Arts Festival) in the west end of city you won't find this organization listed in The Proud Toronto Campaign or promoted on Pride Toronto web site. Proud of Toronto Campaign has the long knives out with all sorts of guest speakers on May 16th and May 20th. PTC has only one goal save the city funding for about $123,807, plus roughly $300,000 in-kind services like policing and cleanup.for the 2011 their festival. The Community Advisory Panel report (CAP) which Pride Toronto accepted in whole, states in Executive Summary: Pride Toronto should be decreasing dependence upon government funding. Yet here they are whining, pleading and threatening Toronto City Council to not withhold funding. Pride Toronto followers and the Proud of Toronto Campaign and Church Street politicos are constantly berating the new Mayor of Toronto Rob Ford, never, ever have say anything nice about him. They have also turned their hatchets on Stephen Harper, Prime Minister of Canada for no apparent reason. Pride Toronto doesn't care about any other queer festival in the city. When in fact there are two others. The 3rd annual LGBTQ Trigger Festival and 11th annual Queer West Arts Festival. The Proud of Toronto Campaign is all about ME ME ME! I hope City Council sees through this phony baloney campaign who have less that 400 supporters.
michel, Toronto ON
05/10/11 11:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Debate topic
Two items are being debated regarding funding and they're both happening this month - one is specific to Pride Toronto while the second is for all programs (including LGBTQ and HIV/AIDS services). 1. On May 24, 2011, the City's Executive Committee will debate a report on Pride Toronto’s compliance with the City’s Anti-Discrimination Policy and whether the participation of Queers Against Israeli Apartheid (QUAIA) including carrying banners in the Pride Parade constitutes a violation under the City’s Anti-Discrimination Policy. The City Staff has therefore concluded that the participation of QUAIA in the Pride Parade based solely on the phrase "Israeli Apartheid" does not violate the City’s Anti-Discrimination Policy. http://app.toronto.ca/tmmis/viewAgendaItemHistory.do?item=2011.EX5.1 2. Core Services Review - The public engagement program begins Wed. May 11 and runs for 5 weeks. Some details: http://bit.ly/lxBoNR We look forward to having many LGBTQ, HIV/AIDS, and supportive organizations represented on May 16, 2011, along with our diverse community including allies. Stay tuned for details.
Proud of Toronto Campaign, Toronto Ontario
05/11/11 12:09 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Two part debate topics
Proud of Toronto Campaign aka Pride Toronto sure loves committee work not only is the city subjected to close to 3 months of Community Advisory Panel Discussions there are now an additional 5 more weeks (or more?) of panel discussions this is just more of the Pride Toronto ME Me Me phony baloney Campaign. If you look at the Poster for the May 16 event (& May 24) PTC aka Pride Toronto - we will tell the city why programs and services are important - this is about Pride Toronto and the Church St gay village crowd and not all queer festivals or districts in the city. Have City Councillors looked at Proud of Toronto Campaign Facebook page bashing, dare I say gays bashing City Hall and Mayor Rob Ford. The author of Xtra's article today posted a mean spirited YouTube Video alleging the Toronto's Mayor is a homophobe, when there is no proof. just a lot of scurrilous allegations. Councillors need to sit up and really think about what Pride Toronto and its supporters really represent in the City of Toronto. For example The flag raising ceremony is a branded event only for Pride Toronto, it doesn't represent any other queer festival in city.
Michel, Toronto ON
05/11/11 9:28 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pride Toronto is bully and not to be trusted
Toronto Ontario is the only city in world where a Gay Pride festival and a Queer Arts festival can NOT live side by side in peace, love and joy for the good of community. Pride Toronto bullies queer arts festival - Proud of Toronto Campaign, yeah right, what's to be proud of? Read more: http://www.digitaljournal.com/blog/10870#ixzz1M3GcZKOd
michel, Toronto ON
05/11/11 9:59 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
This is about public support for our communities
As a volunteer organizer for the Proud of Toronto campaign, I just have to clarify a few things: This campaign is a coalition of MANY individuals and organizations that believe that the City should support queer culture, LGBTQ services and HIV/AIDS services - including Pride Toronto. Pride is the organization that Ford and his allies on council are attacking today. But we are just as concerned about the future. And for those who say that Ford is not homophobic and we have nothing to worry about, I'd direct you to some of Ford's past words and actions. He publicly stated during the campaign last fall that he is against same-sex marriage. He recently was the SOLE vote against the City accepting provincial dollars for HIV/AIDS and STD prevention. So we have reason to be concerned. The Proud of Toronto campaign is about far more than Pride, although we are very keen to ensure that Pride continues and received equitable support as one of Toronto's major community events.
Doug Kerr, Toronto Ontario
05/11/11 10:04 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
response to doug
Doug, it is very unfair to target the mayor in your statement "He recently was the SOLE vote against the City accepting provincial dollars for HIV/AIDS and STD prevention". Hiv/Aids and Std prevention is generously funded by the federal goverment, as well as through other provincial fundings that are directed to health care. Language is everything, and you are manipulating readers to suggest that the mayor is homophobic, when indeed there as as great, or greater needs in our city at large, outside of the LGBT community. I am gay, does this position also make me a homophobe?
Jamie, Toronto ON
05/11/11 11:22 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Inaccurate headline
Xtra's misleading headline inaccurately suggests that Toronto's gay community plans to storm City Hall, while further reading of the article and review of the Facebook page tell a different story. It's not "the gay community" storming City Hall, it's more like "a coalition of several hundred activists from several gay community groups.". Xtra should correct the headline. Also, if reporter Andrea Houston is involved in organizing this event, as the Facebook page implies, then this should be disclosed by Xtra.
Jay, Toronto On
05/11/11 11:42 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A small group
Jay, ever hear what Margaret Mead had to say about small groups - Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.
roy, toronto ON
05/11/11 12:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pride Toronto is not small group Roy
Come Roy (Mitchell Pride Toronto director?) Pride Toronto aka PTC is not small group its complete nonsense to suggest it, quoting Margaret Mead.
michel, Toronto ON
05/11/11 12:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Mayor Ford's Vote on HIV/AIDS, Syphillis Testing
On February 24, 2011, the mayor was the only member of city council to vote against accepting $100,000 from the provincial government to establish screening programs for syphilis and HIV. Specifically, Mayor Ford voted against "Council increase the Toronto Public Health 2011 Budget Committee Recommended Operating Budget for one-time funding of $100,000 gross and $0.0 net as provided by the Ministry of Health and Long Term Care to support a communication strategy encouraging HIV and syphilis screening" http://app.toronto.ca/tmmis/viewAgendaItemHistory.do?item=2011.EX3.4 Here's a look at some other votes on HIV/AIDS: http://fordfortoronto.mattelliott.ca/2011/02/28/a-short-summary-of-rob-fords-voting-record-on-hivaids/
Proud of Toronto, Toronto Ontario
05/12/11 12:23 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Michel: Deep Breath in slow breath out.
First: Proud of TO has no direct connection to Pride TO, but they are the focal point of this action. WHY? because the only reason that Mayor Ford and the Executive commitee could possibly have cut PTs funding is based on Homophobia. HOW DO I KNOW THIS? Because Proud of TO started in my living room a month of Sundays ago. The numbers, dollars and benifits that are delivered to TO because of PT is well known and on the record. ANY cut to funding for PT is just the start, Caribana, arts orgs and communitee outreach orgs are all about to face the axe. Mayor Ford is doing this because we scare him not because he is doing the tax payer a favour. What else scares him, black people, "orientals", artists and people who vote NDP. Why is he attacking PT, because they are the week point and in his mind a fair target for attacks because homo's do not belong, they are perverts and freaks. He may not be saying that directly but look at the comentary and blogs that is what they are saying. Fords attacks on PT justify the hatred,even if his belief is not based on anything more then fear. My faith in what PT can be was not destroyed over the past 2 years of bad management and self centered decision making. I believe that PT is, was and can be the organisation that can deliver a strong playful support structure for everyone has a place to find a voice. And this is why I ask that you take a deep breath, self centred decision making and self promotion only create a greater divide in the community. Take a deep breath take your head out of your arse and then maybe we could enjoy a Queer West event that enhances the queer livability of our city.
Mark Smith, Toronto ON
05/12/11 12:27 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I didn't vote for them...
Who can say they speak for the hundreds of thousands of diverse people who make up this community? People should speak twice before they make statements about what the "gay community" wants or does. The "gay community" is not storming anything. This all feels anti-democractic somehow. People in this city did vote in Ford. No-one voted in "Proud of Toronto".
Jim, Toronto Ontario
05/12/11 12:49 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Re Deep Breath
Mr. Smith, I don't buy your argument. You’re a former director of Pride Toronto an organization that has harassed QWF over the last two years. I intend to write our Mayor as a gay man that I won’t be storming City Hall on Monday, as your campaign alleges in Xtra and layout my feelings about your campaign. I do not support the Proud of Toronto Campaign aka Pride Toronto its hog wash, I have already expressed my reason why here in a couple of places. I will ask the mayor to pass my letter on to other councillors, since I don’t have the petition means that you do. They should know that not every LGBTQ person in Toronto supports this so called attack on City hall. My advice is calling it off try to be nice to our Mayor for once, send him a box of chocolates or something, do it the Ghandi way. Your campaign is shameful. And further It’s beneath me to get dragged myself into your snide comment, about Queer West Fest. No surprise, coming from a former director of Pride Toronto.
michel, Toronto on
05/12/11 2:00 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
advice
Michel, I really think Mark's advice to you would only benefit QWF. I keep hearing you say that Pride Toronto has somehow done something bad to you/QWF, but I never hear you say way they did? Can you elaborate? Inquiring minds want to know.
roy, toronto ON
05/12/11 2:10 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Is the Mayor phobic?
I am very concerned about Rob Ford's public comment about trans people copied below. We need to educate City Councillors about our LGBT communities, about why it is wrong to discriminate, and provide opportunities to enhance LGBT communities' engagement in the City of Toronto. Susan Gapka "June 14, 2005: "I don't understand. No 1, I don't understand a transgender, I don't understand, is it a guy dressed up like a girl or a girl dressed up like a guy? And we're funding this for, I don't know, what does it say here? We're giving them $3,210?" Ford questions the utility of grant programs for transgendered and transsexual people during a council debate." Source: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/toronto/rob-ford-and-a-decade-of-controversy/article1678543/page2/
Susan Gapka, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 6:22 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I didn't vote for Proud of Toronto either
I didn't vote Proud of Toronto either. It just seems to be a reincarnation of the pro-QuAIA "Pride Free Speech Coalition". They like to say that they represent the gay community, but they don't. It seems to be the same left-wing gang that's been supporting QuAIA at every available opportunity during the last 18 months. Last year, on June 7, 2010, the same left-wing gang rallied for QuAIA at The 519. Now on May 16, 2011, they'll rally for QuAIA at City Hall. All that seems to matter to them is defending QuAIA's attacks on gay-friendly Israel "in solidarity" with homophobic Muslim nations that persecute gays and oppress women. That's probably their vision for Toronto hosting World Pride in 2014. If Toronto gay leftists want to use World Pride to attack Israel, then they shouldn't receive taxpayer money to do it.
Kevin, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 7:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Clarity
Hi Michel, Jim, Kevin: As one of the volunteers helping with the Proud of Toronto campaign, please don't make assumptions about the people working on this. To set the record straight (no pun intended) - Proud of Toronto is simply a group of people who believe strongly that City funding that supports LGBTQ and HIV/AIDS services should continue and not be cut. As taxpayers and citizens it is our right (in fact, it's probably our civic duty) to make our views known to our elected officials. The event on Monday is not an anti-Ford protest (although I am sure some people will come who want to yell at Ford) - It is a celebration of our communities. We have designed a program that involves everyone from Tourism Toronto to HIV/AIDS support workers, to a mom of a gay son - who will speak about the importance of city support. As for this campaign being a 'front' for Pride Toronto. It is not. There are over 20 organizations (health services, cultural groups, youth organizations) who are participating on Monday. Pride Toronto is one of them and yes, the current threat to Pride is one of the reasons we are doing this event right now. But our broader goal remains: letting the city know how important ALL of our community institutions are to individuals and families. I hope you'll come on Monday to find out more. And if not, please refrain from making rude and insensitive comments. Cheers!
Doug, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 7:18 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Re: Clarity
Dear Doug; I have every right to express my opinion in a letter to City Council and The Mayor as a gay man, not as community leader. I think your on a fishing trip, trying to find what I said in my letter. It's really none of your business and you shouldn't be trying manipulate what I can and can not say to City Council. (I often write to Mayor with ideas and concerns.) In this case I received quite a few nice personal letters(not form) addressing (including the Mayor) my concerns. This attack on city hall is not unlike a story which appeared in Xtra a few days after the Mayor was elected, wherein Church St politicos and Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam were going to blitzkrieg City Hall, although I can't find the link and I am not sure the word blitzkrieg was used, but was something that, I am sure its still aroundn in the archives. I did find it interesting your Comment (Hi Michel, Jim, Kevin) Like we are naughty school boys or something, not following in lock step with your campaign. Since when is Proud of Toronto against Freedom of Expression?
michel, Toronto ON
05/13/11 9:55 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
PTC Facebook attacks
I have not discussed PTC on Facebook. Yet on completely unrelated comments on Friends posting Proud of Toronto minions are attacking me for posting here. What's up that? This why I don't buy your arguements or this campaign. Have you no shame?
michel, Toronto ON
05/13/11 10:21 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
michel
You're right, I should have never told you to take anyone's advice. And I apologize. But I am still wondering, as I'm sure a lot of people are, what you mean when you say that Pride Toronto worked against you and your group. I think it's only fair that you come clean with your accusations because if not you're sounding more and more like don quixote against the windmills. love out.
roy, toronto ON
05/13/11 4:43 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pride Toronto fully aware
On a fishing en Roy? Trying to win me over. I could answer your question but chose not, since this forum debate is about Storming City Hall. Its public knowledge and Pride Board is fully aware, likely not when you were on the executive. Well your day is Monday and 24th have fun. I am off to enjoy the weekend
michel, Toronto ON
05/13/11 6:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
But Doug
I don't want the city (or province or anyone) to fund Pride anymore. I think Pride, as it is now, will forever be a plaything for leftists with a hate-on for Israel. I resent the fact that these people are telling the world that they speak for all gay people in this city. They don't.
Jim, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 7:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
But Doug - Part II
Doug, I agree with Jim. You, Michael Went and Proud of Toronto don't represent me. And, if you're worried about rude and insensitive comments, you should have a look at all the rude and insensitive comments made against QuAIA opponents on QuAIA's website and on the Facebook page of Went's Pride Free Speech Coalition in the last year.
Kevin, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 10:15 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
michel it sounds more like sour grapes
michel I've been receiving your Queer West newsletter in my email for several years, I started off as a strong supporter of the Queer West scene but your attacks on Pride and a large section of the LGBT population of Toronto has totally turned me off your organization. A while back you commented that you supported de-funding Pride since in your mind the money that would have went to Pride would then go to other organizations such as your own, what naiviety on your part, if even Pride can't get funded there's even less chance of Queer West Arts Festival getting funded. michel you sound like a very bitter man lashing out at whatever seems to be a convenient target for your lack of success with Queer West, especially when you won;t mention what Pride has allegedly done to you and your organization. You've already lost me as a supporter of Queer West due to your antics attacking Pride and the very large segment of Toronto's LGBT community which is centrred around Church St. You would have done far better to work with other LGBT organizations in this city, including Pride as well as others instead of lashing out at anyone who seems a convenient target. Besides which your arts festival only appealed to those who care to spend their time looking at paintings or other visual art, perhaps it would have done better if you had expanded the offerings of your festival instead of blaming everyone else for its failure to grow beyond being just another arts festival. Pride and the Church St LGBT community aren't the reasons your festival never did very well. You'd do better to work on improving your festival instead of losing supporters like myself due to your lashing out at the rest of the LGBT communities in Toronto.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 11:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
re: Kevin
Kevin this has nothing at all to do with QuAIA, in case you haven't been paying attention not only was it determined that QuAIA didn't violate the city's anti-discrimination policy they also won't be participating in Pride this year so QuAIA is a non-issue. Do you really find it surprising that those who would fight against de-funding Pride last year are also fighting against de-funding Pride this year? Of course they're the same left leaning people and organizations since the right wing LGBT folks have been in full support of de-funding Pride and there are no right wing LGBT organizations, at least that I know of, certainly none that do anything to help LGBT people lead better healthier lives since they're also against spending money on LGBT public health programs just like Ford. I know you right wingers are upset that QuAIA isn't an issue this year since you had such fun bashing Pride and those who stood up for free speech. As well you've lost an argument for de-funding Pride and as LGBT people yourselves that doesn't leave you with much in the way of justification for getting Pride de-funded considering all it does for the economy of Toronto and for fund raising for LGBT organizations. Face it, the LGBT communities in Toronto are overwhelmingly left leaning because it has been the left wing who has supported equality for LGBT people while the right wing opposed it. Yes its true not all right wingers are anti-LGBT social conservatives but can you point to a single right wing LGBT group that has done anything to benefit the LGBT communities of Toronto? Of course not because there aren't any, at least that I'm aware of anyways but I am aware of an awful lot of left leaning organizations who have been working to improve the lives and well being of LGBT people in Toronto. Instead of constantly attacking left leaning LGBT people why not start your own right wing LGBT organization to speak out against funding for health programs and cultural events for LGBT people?
Rich, Toronto Ontario
05/13/11 11:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rich: sour grapes
Michel knows there are those in Toronto's gay community that don't want Queer West to succeed. Michel is determined not to give up, it is just a matter of finding the right dedicated people. Michel doesn't need people to like him. There's an obscenely small minority that don't like him and don’t actually matter. His focus is on people that do care and nothing else. These people– are his champions– they understand his quest. They make him feel good when he's around them, make him laugh or make him feel like he can just be himself. They make him feel relaxed or at ease. He shared things with them. They’re important. His focus on them instead. Michel is creative individual who not only thinks outside the box, he puts his foot down and crushes it.
Michel, Toronto ON
05/14/11 12:48 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rich:Funding
National Post Editorial May 12, 2010: "Grassroots organizers wouldn't have to struggle against a single 800-pound gorilla event that dominates their community's annual agenda. Not all members of Toronto's gay community, for instance, like the huge Pride festival: Some organizers of the small Queer West Arts Festival blame the parade's success for sucking all the funding and attention away from their own, arguably more substantive, event." So its not just me. And as far subscribers in earlier years, any ying yang could sign up for enewsleter with just their email address, we had no way of identifing any one. Also in earlier years we told subscribers we are not promising you a rose garden, we still have 4, 500 loyal subscribers, who do enjoy the newsletter. In the last 5 years we lost 10 subscribers
Michel, Toronto ON
05/14/11 1:05 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Tghe Battle for Queer Culture in Toronto
Written by Siobhan McGuirk (UK) Research and collaboration by Michel F. Paré (Toronto) Jan 5, 2011. 10 years was a landmark for the Toronto Queer West Arts Festival in August 2010. The first Pride event in Toronto took place 30 years ago. It shows how much the visibility and public acceptance of LGBTQ has grown, and how quickly, that Pride Toronto and to a lesser degree Queer West Arts Festival are each as popular as they are now. Of course, there was always a gay scene in Toronto long before then, with bars and cafes situated between drag shows, fetish clubs, alternative nights and cabarets – the type of event now more likely termed queer than synonymous with ‘gay culture’. These still attract audiences year-round, but have shifted further out of the spotlight. They have become niche. The scene, it seems, has been sanitised. It follows a common trend in which liberation rallies commemorating the Stonewall Riots have become Pride parades with organisers able to erect fences and charge entry fees. Pride movements have emerged to bite back, with radical politics and declarations of inclusivity. For its part, Queer West Arts Festival proudly proclaims that only 50% of its audience is defined as lesbian or gay. It is a celebration of diversity. Queer West Arts Festival celebrates and supports artists who create work on their own terms; in their own way… here they can make the work they’re burning to make. They can risk and they can play. Queer movements in general have faced backlash: some see the term “Queer” as offensive rather than reclaimed. Others assert that their sexuality should not be presumed to dictate their politics. Yet queer arts festivals such as Queer West Arts Festival, Edmonton’s Exposure Arts Festival and Montreal’s Divers/Cité among others, at the very least, make space for important questions to be raised. They also offer a platform to unpopular or extraordinary responses. They demonstrate that to be L,G,B, T and/or Q is still seen
Michel, Toronto ON
05/14/11 1:17 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Battle for Queer Culture in Toronto Cont..
Yet queer arts festivals such as Queer West Arts Festival, Edmonton’s Exposure Arts Festival and Montreal’s Divers/Cité among others, at the very least, make space for important questions to be raised. They also offer a platform to unpopular or extraordinary responses. They demonstrate that to be L,G,B, T and/or Q is still seen subversive, even if you don’t want it to be. No matter how “pink” mainstream political parties have become, or acceptable gay marriage or civil partnerships are, society still insists on its norms. The arts can explore the boundaries of equality debates and reveal the tension within them, highlighting the prejudices that persist, both on and off “the scene”: sexism, transphobia, body fascism, ageism, and racism only scratch the surface. When a polyamorous, asexual, mixed race, gender queer artist announces that they will vote Conservative because they, too, believe in “family values”, the audience laughs, recognising that the joke is on us Many are self-defining queers who feel “the scene” does not cater to their needs or outlooks and see Queer West Arts Festival as an annual highlight. Paradoxically, another chunk of friends have no idea the festival even exists. Pride Toronto, too, splits opinion. Overly commercial and frustratingly political for many, it is the high point of the year for some. There are overlaps between the two camps, of course, but there is still a discernable divide between the “gay” and “queer” festival scenes, and the gulf between them seems to be widening. It will be interesting to see the results, and by the close of the festival, how far the gay / queer divide has been addressed and whether new ideas will emerge over what it is to be L, G, B, T, I, Q in Toronto 2011. --Written by Siobhan McGuirk (UK) Research and collaboration by Michel F. Paré (Toronto) Jan 5, 2011.
Michel, Toronto ON
05/14/11 1:21 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rich, don't pretend this isn't about QuAIA
Rich, the same members of the gay leftist elite who supported QuAIA in the last 18 months are now supporting Proud of Toronto's current campaign against Mayor Ford. Ford wants to de-fund Pride Toronto unless it gives a guarantee that QuAIA won't march in the Pride parade. So don't pretend that this isn't about QuAIA. And yes, the battle over QuAIA has left a great legacy of bitterness in the LGBT community. The gay leftists (like yourself) who repeatedly attacked QuAIA opponents in the last 18 months shouldn't be surprised if QuAIA opponents no longer want to support or give money to the organizations controlled by those same gay leftists. If a person wants to help LGBT people, there are other organizations outside the Church Street ghetto that they can support. For example, if a person wants to support gay films, they can give to TIFF rather than Inside Out. If a person wants to support AIDS charities, they can give to CANFAR rather than ACT or the PWA Foundation.
Kevin, Toronto Ontario
05/14/11 5:32 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Kevin: QuAIA
Your absolutely right this is at top of The Mayor's agenda, which he has said publicly a number of times - There is no room in our city for hate speech and taxpayers' dollars should not go fund hate speech. He is not against the parade, which he calls a celebration - Not the media circus planned by Proud of Toronto for Monday May 16th or May 24th. I can't not understand Pride's waffling on this issue. Either they stand up make a decision in Support of QuAIA or distances themselves, appears to be no real leadership running Pride and as you say it has dragged on for 18 months.
Michel, Toronto On
05/14/11 8:11 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
@Rich
What you write is all well and good, but the fact remains that the left do not "own" or "run" or even "speak for" the gay community. The gay community is a huge amorphous thing, not the 200 queers that live between the 519 and Xtra's offices. If left-leaning gays want to do something, then do so under the "queer" aegis and stop trying to co-opt the symbols, events, etc. of the gay community. You don't represent us. Stop using phrases like "gay community".
Jim, Toronto Ontario
05/14/11 10:20 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
@Jim
Jim there isn't one gay community in Toronto but there are many LGBT communities. There has always been division between different segments, different sub-communities going right back to the 70s where often gay men wanted nothing to do with lesbians and those in the closet outside the bars and baths wanted nothing to do with the activists who were out everywhere and making noise about it. The reality is all the organizations that have sprung up over the years to help sexual minorities in Toronto have been left leaning and many left leaning sexual minorities identify as gay, so why should any left leaning organization give up a designation used by many who belong to such organizations and many who such organizations serve? Your claim that the many dozens of left leaning LGBT organizations in Toronto have co-opted the symbols and events of the gay community is absolutely ridiculous. Its the right wing gays who are the new ones on the block, before we had full legal equality the vast majority were left leaning since it was the left who were fighting for LGBT equality while the right wing fought against it. Now that the left leaning have achieved full legal equality, for gays and lesbians at least, hopefully soon for trans people too, we have right wingers such as yourself trying to claim the left wingers just showed up to take over. I know the right wing is big on historical revisionism but come one, do you really believe that the LGBT communities in Toronto have traditionally and currently been primarily right wing? That's a laugh. Jim you hardly speak for the entire LGBT communities yourself even though you seem to think you do. Why don't you start your own right wing organization? That way at least you could legitimately claim that you speak for the segment of the LGBT communities that you represent just like the left wing organizations legitimately speak for those they represent.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
05/14/11 5:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Kevin it take two to tango
Kevin you complain about gay leftists like myself attacking opponents of QuAIA yet you conveniently leave out that opponents of QuAIA started the attacks with the smear campaign full of lies and distortions of reality first against QuAIA and then against people like myself who defended their right of free speech. If I had seen any evidence of hate speech from QuAIA I would be among the loudest calling for them to banned but QuAIA never used hate speech and isn't a hate group as has been shown by 3 independent legal opinions and the city manager's report, besides the complete lack of evidence of any use of hate speech. Kevin its not like opponents of QuAIA were being attacked out of the blue, I started off correcting the lies that were being spread about QuAIA for which I was subjected to many attacks and called all sorts of nasty names, should I not have defended myself from attack? Yes there still is bitterness, especially among those who are opposed to QuAIA because you didn't get your way and QuAIA was never censored and your efforts to silence them did far more to spread their message to many millions more people than would have heard it had you just ignored them and allowed them their right of free speech. I'd be bitter too if I were trying to silence a group but through my attempts to silence them I actually helped spread their message far and wide to far more people than they ever could have done on their own. But that doesn't change the fact QuAIA isn't an issue this year because they won't be participating in Pride of their own free choice. You can remain angry if you want to but I would advise against it, its bad for your health. I'm not still angry at those who attacked me for standing up for free speech at Pride. Its time to move on Kevin and stop fighting last year's battles. If you want to see Pride de-funded you'll need some other excuse than QuAIA this year whether you like it or not.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
05/14/11 6:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Queer West Welcome
Michel, if you would like to change your mind and join the Proud of Toronto campaign as we advocate for LGBTQ services, please join us. The May 16 event includes over 25 organizations, including other arts organizations such as the Inside Out Film & Video Festival and Buddies In Bad Times Theatre. With the city's Core Services Review now underway, we are concerned about arts funding generally, and hope for a flourishing arts & culture sector across the entire City.
Proud of Toronto Campaign, Toronto Ontario
05/14/11 9:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rich
I'm afraid this QuAIA issue has grown out of control, thanks to its inept handling by people like you. What this QuAIA fiasco has revealed is that Pride has been taken over by extremists. The only way to deal with this is to politicize it immediately. The gay community needs to remove or split off the non-gay political element from Pride altogether. As a member of the gay community, I urge governments at all levels to deny funding to Pride until it is made completely apolitical when it comes to non-gay issues. However, this should not affect genuine political comment about countries where gays are actively prosecuted. Palestine, for example. This kind of gay-oriented political expression does belong at Pride.
Jim, Toronto Ontario
05/15/11 10:51 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
oops
I meant "DEpoliticize"
Jim, Toronto Ontario
05/15/11 10:55 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Welcome Queer West
Michel hasn't changed is mind, he still thinks its a publicity stunt for Pride Toronto. He does thank the organizers for reaching out. Michel will be busy Monday evening 6-9pm taking a National Post reporter and press photographer for previews, interviews and reviews of Queer West Village new hotspots in the old Brockton Village for colour spread in the Post magazine
Michel, Toronto ON
05/15/11 11:36 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.