The abuse of 'bullying'
FRASER'S EDGE / A world without conflict is unlikely and undesirable
Brad Fraser / Toronto / Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Share |

Being bullied as a child or teen is hell. I know from experience. 
 
My upbringing involved constant, unannounced moves to new locales. By the ninth grade I had attended 14 different schools in 11 different towns in BC and Alberta and knew firsthand just how dangerous it is to be eternally the new kid.
 
However, this nomadic existence also ensured that I figured out the rules early on and learned to prepare myself for the inevitable confrontations. I wasn’t a particularly big kid, but I was smart and figured out that making people laugh and having a slightly dangerous quality were excellent ways to keep the bullies at bay.
 
In fact, there are only a few bullying incidents I recall with any detail.
 
One encounter happened in the fifth grade while I was living in a BC mining town. It involved a very tall girl — one of those who go through puberty early — who seemed like a high-school student sitting among children. Why this girl, whom I’d previously been kind of friendly with, took such a sudden dislike to me I don’t know. 
Bullying is complex. It's not confined to a particular class, age group or gender.
(Thinkstock)
 
The campaign started with her whispering insults about me to the other kids and telling terrible lies behind my back. It quickly progressed to open derision of the most hurtful kind. Attempts to speak to her about this brought on nothing but more abuse. Over several months the events escalated — from her kicking me so hard in the ass on the playground while my back was turned that I ended up in the mud, to her throwing my belongings in the garbage (including my only pair of gym shoes) when I wasn’t around. This was fairly often because I started avoiding school as much as possible because this girl made it hell.
 
What was really frustrating was the fact I couldn’t figure out what to do about it. If it had been a boy, there would’ve been a fight that decided dominance. I didn’t have that option with her. Hitting a girl for any reason was, rightly, a huge taboo. 
 
I finally spoke to my parents about it, and my teacher, separately. Their contempt for my complaint was palpable: no boy worth his salt would be bullied by a girl. All disputed that such a thing could even happen. I was shamed for reporting it.
 
So the next time we encountered one another in a hallway when no one was around, I told the girl I was tired of her bullying and said she wasn’t going to push me around anymore. She laughed and called me a name that had something to do with my partial native heritage. I punched her in the centre of the chest as hard as I could, knocking the breath out of her as she fell back against the wall.
 
She never reported the incident and never bullied me again. I wasn’t at all proud of what I’d done, but I was quite sure it was the only recourse I’d had left.
 
This story’s been on my mind because I read so much about bullying in today’s news — the term itself has been abused. 
 
Bullying is complex. It’s not confined to a particular class, age group or gender. It can be extremely obvious and physical, but it can also be subtle and all but invisible. It can take place between the most unlikely parties, and, in some cases, the co-dependent relationship between victim and bully can be as nuanced as any other social coupling.
 
However, when rightwing shills in the political arena and the popular media start whinging about “being bullied” by people who don’t accept their hateful words and actions, a problem must be acknowledged.
 
Bullying, by definition (Merriam-Webster), is “one habitually cruel to others who are weaker.” That seems pretty clear to me. It does not say, “people who don’t accept every stupid thing I say without challenge.” It doesn’t say, “someone who doesn’t like me even though I wish they did.” It doesn’t say, “anyone who does anything that puts me in conflict because I don’t want conflict of any kind.” And it certainly doesn’t say, “people who admonish or correct me because I’m hopelessly bad at a job I represent myself as being able to do.”
 
While everyone has an obligation to acknowledge and battle bullying among youth, we also have to acknowledge that a society or a world without conflict is not only highly unlikely, but undesirable as well. 
 
“Weaker” is a very subjective term and not necessarily one of permanence. It is possible to become stronger, and we all benefit by doing it.
Tags: bullying


Share |


Reader Comments


 
#abusedterms
excellent piece. I've been thinking a lot lately about abused terms - "bullying" being one. I wonder if hashtags contributing. It seems to me when folks want desperately to be part of something, they resort to a hashtag that doesn't mean what they mean, or a blanket statement hastag because they can't think of the correct word to describe the person/situation- which is usually #asshole or #unpleasant.
Sue, Toronto ON
02/23/13 9:43 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Well said!
I too am tired of certain politicos crying "bully" when they get called on their crap. It's all about who has the power. Nobody elected to office and pulling down a six figure salary is being bullied when taken to task for breaking the rules. I was once bullied by a teacher; that one was harder to take than all the "fatty fatty two by four" cracks combined as my parents refused to do anything. Glad you stood up to that girl. Another great column.
Darlene Stimson, Toronto Ontario
02/23/13 10:33 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Well said.
This nails it. The bullshit victim mentality that allows hateful people to bully - Christians, Ann Coulter, Repuglicans - makes my head pop off. Breaks my heart that you were shamed for speaking up. Although it seems as if that's changed, the ability to address it effectively is still elusive. Thanks for this.
Diane Flacks, Toronto Ontario
02/23/13 10:35 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Couldn't Agree More
I couldn't agree more with your astute comments, Brad. I won't embellish--there's no need to do so. Thanks, as ever, for your insight.
Garry Bodnar, Edmonton Alberta
02/23/13 11:35 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bravo
This is a very clearly articulated definition of bullying, something which seems to be escalating as a means of human discourse even as we shine a light on it. You are, of course, right in calling out all those who misuse this term. To create a place of respect and trust in the workplace, in the community, in schools, in our homes, we need to validate the acknowledge and value the differences we all bring to the circle, and cherish the linkages we find. Fie on bullies everywhere. Fie on the additional shaming of victims of bullies. As Barbara Coloroso has said, it takes the bystander to speak up and say no before much of anything can happen.
Janice MacDonald, Edmonton Alberta
02/23/13 11:42 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yes.
I've been feeling this for a while, thanks for articulating it. If blow the bully whistle every time we are made to feel the slightest bit challenged or uncomfortable, it does a disservice to the kids and other vulnerable folks who are genuinely being preyed on by genuine bullies. We're crying wolf for them, so when they need actual help it is them no one will come to help.
Ryan, Toronto ON
02/23/13 11:44 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Professional victims
The LGBT adult community is divided into two camps: (1) people who work, pay taxes and try to make a decent life for themselves, and (2) professional victims who always seek someone else to blame for their own failures and their own disappointments (e.g, Rahim Thawer of ACT, Hassle Free Clinic and Queers for Social Justice who tweets about being oppressed when he reads a Grindr profile from a guy who says he's not into effeminate men). I care about LGBT teens who are truly being bullied by their peers in schools. I don't care about LGBT adults who are professional victims.
Ray, Toronto ON
02/23/13 12:09 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.