The Catholic Church's hate
EDITORIAL
Andrea Houston / Toronto / Thursday, December 27, 2012
Share |

Pope Benedict XVI recently joined Twitter. On the same day he sent his first tweet, he also met with — and blessed — a Ugandan politician committed to implementing a new policy that would introduce the death penalty for some gay people.
 
Guess which one made the news?
 
Rebecca Kadaga, speaker of the Ugandan Parliament and the sponsor of its horrific “Kill the Gays” bill — one of the world’s harshest pieces of anti-gay legislation — called the meeting a “very great moment.” 
 
Once the bill passes (and it will pass in some form, even if Kadaga failed to deliver it by Christmas, as she had hoped), it will mean gay Ugandans convicted of “aggravated homosexuality” could face the death penalty. The proposed bill requires that parents turn their gay children in to authorities to face prosecution. If passed, gay refugees could face the death penalty for their “crimes” in other countries if they return home, and gay support groups, such as those that work in HIV prevention, would be shut down. 
 
By blessing Kadaga, who was given a personal audience with the pope, the Vatican has sent an unmistakable message to the world: that Uganda is following the teachings of the Catholic Church.
 
Kadaga, who was at the Vatican for a human rights conference (uh-huh), gave the pope a portrait of the Uganda Martyrs Shrine, a place where followers of the Catholic faith were murdered in cold blood. The grisly irony was lost on her.
 
The world’s mainstream media has said barely a peep about this. The Media Matters blog on Dec 14 criticized American cable networks for their lack of coverage, sharing a poll that found that since October — when Kadaga promised to bring the bill to vote — major American networks had spent just 15 minutes reporting on the bill. The situation in Canada has not been any better. Yet media reported widely about the pope’s new Twitter account, painting Benedict as an endearing older gentleman learning how to use an iPad.
 
This is unacceptable. What the pope did in blessing Kadaga was so outrageous and so unambiguous that only one question needs now to be asked: how can anyone continue to follow the Catholic Church, knowing its leader openly supports those who would murder gay people?
 
This requires immediate action. Catholics who consider themselves queer allies need to speak up, express outrage or even walk away from the church entirely. Otherwise, they are complicit.
 
The Southern Poverty Law Center’s definition of hate groups includes those organizations “having beliefs or practices that attack or malign an entire class of people, typically for their immutable characteristics.” Does the Catholic Church fit this description?
 
Two days after giving the blessing to Kadaga — and on the same day that a gunman massacred 27 people in Newtown, Connecticut — the pope announced that gay marriage is a threat to justice and peace. With all the legitimate evils in the world — murder, rape, poverty, sickness, war — he chose to highlight gay marriage.
 
Such insidious and cruel statements from the head of an organization that is supposed to stand for love, generosity and peace constitute hate speech. They directly inspire rabidly anti-gay sentiment, as we have seen in Uganda. Religious parents, teachers, pastors and priests follow the pope’s lead by telling gay youth they are worthless, making them feel guilt and shame, and trying to force them to change who they are. It is no wonder that many queer youth opt for suicide.
 
How much longer can Catholics allow their lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans brothers and sisters to endure this bullying and abuse? The real threats to “humanity itself” are hatred, bigotry and indifference to other human beings — as well as those who use their religious beliefs to justify such contempt.
 
For progressive Catholics embarrassed and saddened by their church’s position on homosexuality, it is time to speak up. It is time to voice your disgust and be counted as an ally — or to walk away from the church altogether.
 
Your silence is killing us.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Complicit?
"Catholics who consider themselves queer allies need to speak up, express outrage or even walk away from the church entirely. Otherwise, they are complicit." This is the same language that extremists in the post-9/11 US used about Muslims and Arabs -- that unless they stood up to disown bin Laden, they were complicit or suspect. As much as we may dislike statements that come from the Pope, at some point, we have to realize that the world's one billion Catholics are a diverse and free-thinking group of individuals who don't simply absorb the messages of the man in Rome as if from a hypodermic needle. Catholics around the world -- including many that you've covered -- have been standing up and providing opposition voices within the Church. I don't think it's helpful to have outsiders labeling them all as bigots, murderers, etc. This sort of language deepens divisions and shuts down dialogue and understanding. Moreover, despite the Pope's blessing of this person, the Catholic Church (including the archbishop for Uganda) has been vocally opposed to the "kill the gays" bill. It's part of the Church's whole "thou shalt not kill"/anti-death-penalty stance (which also gets rarely reported). Granted, they haven't done enough. A parallel: We don't condemn all Saudi-Canadians who fail to speak out against that nation's just as horrible antigay track record. Nor should we.
Rob Salerno, Toronto ON
12/23/12 3:59 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Intolerant
You are so intolerant that you do not accept any possition against same sex marriage. The LGBT community is ussing the same methods that used to criticize.... At the end, everyone will realize that you are just a bunch of intolerants and sectarians lunatics with no moral or political groundings. History will tell...
Roberto, London London
12/23/12 5:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The problem is assuming
The problem is assuming that progressive Catholics have not already left the Church. Many gay-friendly Catholics have already left the institutional Church. We sometimes imagine that there is a silent majority of progressives in the Roman Catholic Church. While that might have been true 10 or 20 years ago, the fact remains that many of them have already left and either become secular or gone to other churches. The Pope might be reflecting what many people in his Church might believe.
JC, Vancouver British Columbia
12/23/12 11:16 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
History
The Roman Catholic church was also might quiet during the Hitler years.
Connie Elkin, Thessalon Ontario
12/24/12 9:40 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Tolerance is nice, but forcing it is intolerant.
As a gay man, I wholeheartedly support human rights. Hatred and bigotry are disgusting, but where all movements towards acceptance of any group fail is forcing tolerance upon people. People resent being told what to think and believe, and this is adding fuel to the fire. You cannot change a deep conviction by force. They must come to a conclusion on their own or they will fight you every step of the way. We will never eradicate discrimination as it is a response to fear of those who are different. It is far better that we find ways to ensure anyone is free to pursue their own happiness.
Thomas Mrak, Proctor MN
12/24/12 11:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Toot! Toot! Popemobile Coming Through.
Any belief system that rests on a supernatural foundation skirts accountability to reason, logic and reality. Add in our species' instincts towards order and authority and religion is nothing more than an easy ride to the top for power hungry men, and easy access to a sense of purpose for their undiscerning followers. Once you see the absurdity of a celibate old bureaucrat in a dress defining what's "natural" you can't un-see it. It's time to revoke this old fools' driver's license. You need to make your own way towards understanding the wonder, beauty and impermanence of existence.
@quinkster, Toronto Ontario
12/24/12 12:39 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bringing to our attention
Thank you for reporting on this - there is so much hate in the name of religion and it takes a strong person to call this out. Continue your excellent work - I am behind (and beside) you 100% - Voting with our feet or walking away as you suggest can sometimes effective. Working from within is another approach that takes a lot of courage and conviction. Each one of us needs to take action in whatever ways we are called to. Thanks again for bringing the facts to our attention so that we discuss and decide how to best address this.
Ann, Bowmanville ON
12/24/12 12:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A key issue
A key issue is why LGBT Catholics continue to stay in the Catholic Church. They should really leave the Catholic Church and stop identifying as Catholics.
Kevin, Toronto ON
12/24/12 5:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Missing piece
"How much longer can Catholics allow their lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans brothers and sisters to endure this bullying and abuse?" Why are you only focusing on Catholics? I know of many other religious groups that are not doing enough to stop violence. Actually some of these religious groups also hold anti-gay views -- this includes some Protestant denominations, Evangelicals, Muslims, Jews (especially Orthodox), and so on. Also I think it would have been worthwile to mention that it was actually the US evangelicals (not Catholics) who had a heavy influence in Uganda in introducing this "Kill the Gays" bill. There was article on this subject in Harper's magazine in Sept. 2010 issue under the title: Straight Man’s Burden The American roots of Uganda’s anti-gay persecutions by Jeff Sharlet. While I'm not trying to defend the Catholic Church, it does bother me when the LGBT media seem to ignore much more homophobic Christian evangelicals and other religious groups (some of whom hold much more extreme views than the Catholic church).
tj, Vancouver BC
12/26/12 10:56 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
No Virginia - There is no God
The Jewish religion was begun by praying to an obscure rain god called Ba'al to deliver rain to a parched plain. This was embellished over time to include all kinds of religious sentiment. Jesus was Jewish. He could neither read nor write but was considered a rabbi. He died. Later, the Roman Emperor Constantine thought he saw a cross on a hill just before a battle in which he wanted to kill and maim people. He vowed to change the Roman religion to Christian if he won the battle. He did win and the rest of Europe got dragged into this religion. Today we would still be praying to the Druids or a Celtic God if Constantine had lost. Folks: There is no God. There never was. Look at the land and buildings (including multi-million dollar homes) the Catholic Church owns in Parkdale. Most of them are empty except for a security guard. Yet did the church help the poor in Parkdale this Xmas? As for the Evangelicals. The original British-Americans wanted one established state Church called the Anglican Church. Someone was kind enough to allow the Baptists to practice anyway and now this aggressive proselytising cult has aggressively pushed out the rest.
Bryan Charlebois, Toronto Ontario
12/27/12 9:46 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The Pope is not mentioned in the Bible.
BTW: The Pope is not mentioned in the Bible. Or is he mentioned as the Anti-Christ?
Joe, TO ON
12/27/12 1:02 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Separation of Church, Mosque Synagogue and State
We know why Spain, France, Belgium and Quebec are such hellholes of homophobia - Catholicism! Next issue of Xtra Toronto: Islam gets the same gloves-off treatment we gave the Catholic Church this week, we taunt gay Muslims with the Bush Doctrine-inspired sentiment of "You're With Us or With the Terrorists, Hey, Salaam. Pick a fucking side!" admonitions. Then, to spice things up, we reprint those hilarious Danish cartoons (those zany Danes!) of the prophet Mohammed and show the extra-judicial killings of gay men in Iran/Iraq. Right, Andrea?
Nadine Obermanq, Toronto ON
12/30/12 1:33 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Its a filthy rich, child rape cult
Jesus started a church, and Catholics turned it into a business, and a child rape cult, and invented confession so anyone could get away with anything.
neiL ALLEN, NY NY
12/30/12 6:08 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Anti-Catholic and Anti-religion
1. what has Andrea Houston and her ilk done for Ugandan victims of homophobia besides rant? 2. Neil Allen - in confession you have to repent and promise not to do it again. 3. Will Andrea dare touch Islamic homophobia? don't hold your breath. 4. hey Joe the Pope is the Successor of St. Peter, it is called Apostolic Succession. 5. this cult of Christianity has 2 billion followers. 6. read tj, Vancouver above. 7. Connie Elkin - Hitler was more likely to listen to the German Protestant church than to the Pope as German catholics are a minority 8. Roberto in London - some posters have an issue with not only Catholics but religion in general.
Geoff, Toronto ON
12/31/12 9:53 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Gay atheists and Gay Catholics
1. hey Kevin - gay atheists should leave atheism and not identify as atheists since their atheist brother eg. communists - persecute gays. 2. read Rob Salerno above. 3. hey, JC, Vancouver, are all gay atheists "progressives"? LOL
Geoff, Toronto ON
12/31/12 10:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bryan Charlebois - hellooo
Atheist smugness and cynicism - Par exemple, j'accuse Bryan Charlebois who asks if the church helped the poor this Xmas in Parkdale - DID BRYAN ? Do Good Shepherd Centre, St. Vincent de Paul. St. Patrick's Out of the cold etc. etc. count
Geoff, Toronto ON
12/31/12 10:12 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
As a Christian, I Made the Choice to Leave
It is now ten years since I left the Roman Catholic Church. As a Christian, I could not tolerate the ongoing discrimination against women, homophobia, cover-ups of sexual abuse of minors and false teachings such as purgatory and the elevation of Mary to the status of near goddess. I have never been sorry for that choice, particularly since Cardinal Ratzinger was elevated to the papacy. I invite other progressive Christians to make the same choice.
Wayne M., Edmonton Alberta
01/01/13 12:40 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
GREAT article.
This was a great article and I think we have been 'afraid' to speak our minds on this issue for far too long. As for Thomas M.'s comment above "People resent being told what to think and believe, and this is adding fuel to the fire." ummm... I agree we should not 'kick the hornet's nest' unless it is absolutely necessary, but, at the same time, it is religious teachings that tell people WHAT to think, rather than HOW to think. That would be the job of a great, solid, public-school, fully tolerant education imho.
Tom, Toronto Ontario
01/18/13 1:38 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.