Dispatch: Toronto's Occupy movement
COMMUNITY NEWS / Queer community joins the battle to end corporate greed
Katie Toth / Toronto / Friday, October 28, 2011
Share |

From Rome to Cape Town, London to Buenos Aires, the world has been occupied.
 
The anti-corporate Occupy Wall St movement has been spreading, pulling together disparate but passionate activist groups hoping to end economic inequality and corporate avarice.
 
Toronto’s small Occupy puzzle piece is nestled between Church and Jarvis streets in St James Park, ensuring it has a slight pink tinge as some outspoken members of the queer community bring their issues to the mostly straight encampment.
 
Anastasia Zavarella, one of hundreds of demonstrators taking part in the protests, says she wants to see more people from the queer community fighting capitalism, rather than participating in it.
Stefonknee Wolscht, a key organizer with Occupy Toronto, says the Toronto group has welcomed diversity.
(Katie Toth)
 
“Whoop-de-fucking-doo that Apple’s new CEO is a gay man,” she says. “That’s not super helpful for those of us that are in massive amounts of debt, had our land stolen hundreds of years ago, are coping with disabilities in a healthcare system that marginalizes us and rejects us on multiple levels due to our queerness and perhaps being trans and perhaps having a disability. No, participating in capitalism, that’s not going to help at all.”
 
Occupy Toronto’s Darryl Richardson calls himself an ally to the LGBT community. “I came down here and the atmosphere infected me,” he says. “Everybody is included here; there is so much support.
 
“We’re here to talk about issues that affect all of us,” Richardson adds. “Part of equality is that we can’t say that queer, bi, trans people are affected by different issues than we are . . . everybody is affected by inequality or discrimination in one way or another.”
 
However, Elizabeth Troughton, who is on the LGBTQ committee at Occupy Toronto, says the queer presence hasn't been as big as she'd hoped it would be.  
 
Elizabeth Troughton wants to see a greater queer presence at Occupy Toronto. 
(Katie Toth)
“We [the committee] have only met twice. The first time we met there were 19 people, and that was really good,” Troughton says, noting that numbers have dropped off. “I don’t really know why there hasn’t been as much involvement as there could be with the queer community, but I just haven’t seen it.
 
“So far we’ve created safe spaces for LGBT people who don’t see themselves represented in the camp,” she says. “If that’s the reason they’re not coming out, we’ve talked about setting up tents for people who want to get involved but who might not want to share a tent with somebody who might be transphobic, homophobic or otherwise oppressive to them.”
 
Stefonknee Wolscht, a trans woman who has been a key organizer with the protest, says she is surprised by people’s willingness to educate themselves about queer issues. “People are willing to learn, and I’ve been treated very well here,” she says.
 
The first few days were an adjustment. “I have heard comments from different people in the crowd saying, ‘There’s a guy in a dress’ or something like that,” she says. “People said, ‘Excuse me, she’s transgendered, and she happens to look good in a dress’ . . . then very quickly it didn’t happen anymore.”
 
Emily Green, who identifies as bisexual and disabled, thinks Toronto’s movement is unique in the steps it has taken to accommodate the queer community.
 
Green says it’s an aspect of Occupy Toronto she hasn’t seen at other protests or other Occupy groups around the world. “I think that’s a major strength to our movement here in Toronto,” she says. “We’ve got a woman’s safe area, we’ve got a quiet area where you can go meditate, we have people on the Occupy Toronto staff who are LGBTQ themselves and understand where people are coming from.”
 
Wolscht says she’s found a community that’s different from the one she sees in the Village. “Quite often the discrimination of trans people I feel comes directly from the corner of Church and Wellesley,” she says. “You don’t go into battle and leave someone behind. Whether it’s trans people, sex workers . . . the war’s not over.”
 
 
 
 
 
  


Share |


Reader Comments


 
I've been to
the Occupy Toronto site. Spent some time there talking to the -people-. Heard terminology such as -fucking faggot- and the overriding embrace of Radical Islam. I'll be visiting again to speak to more of the -Occupy Movement- people. Perhaps I went at a bad time? Right now, my advice, beware! This -movement- is not helpful to the LGBT community at all, in spite of words spoken claiming the other.
Kyle, Toronto ON
10/28/11 11:57 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The gay community is capitalist
The article states that Anastasia Zavarella, one of the demonstrators taking part in the protests, says she wants to see more people from the queer community fighting capitalism, rather than participating in it. The problem with this sentiment is that the gay community is capitalist. We readily pay for the products and services that businesses offer. If you want sex, you can pay to get (by paying to get into a bathhouse or sex club, use a cruising or sex personals website or hire an escort). In order to meet the standards of the young gale male community, you need to pay to join a workout gym, buy nice clothes, watches, cologne, etc. and pay for aesthetic services (nice haircuts, facials, etc.) and the latest technological toys (e.g., iPads, iPhones, etc.). In order to meet the standards of the older gay male community, you need to pay to buy a nice condo or house, renovate it, buy nice furniture, go on nice trips, etc. If you don’t pay to do these things, then you are considered to undesirable (in the eyes of young gay men) or a loser (in the eyes of older gay men). In the gay community, everything is commoditized and everything has a price. If you want to camp out in an “Occupy Toronto” tent in St James Park wearing days-old dirty underwear and marching in poorly-planned demonstrations, you’ll only be a saint in the eyes of left-wing activists. The Bay Street millionaires you hate aren't even around when you finally get your act together and decide to march by the downtown office towers at night or on weekends.
David, Toronto Ontario
10/28/11 9:21 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Today the Occupy Toronto
crowd (Oct.29,2011) are marching in solidarity with the Tamil Tigers. Occupy Toronto simply do not represent the interests of the LGBT in ways that truly matter and that are affirming. At least not mine.
Kyle, Toronto ON
10/29/11 8:49 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Agreed
Many of the gains made by the GLBT community were made through the system: acts of parliament, membership in political parties, partnerships with police and the military, partnerships with corporations and small business. Why would any of us want to march in a ''movement'' that claims to be against the very system that gave us so much and that we have so heavily integrated into? Also if this movement so presumptuously claims to be the 99% then why have the provinces, territories and the country been consistently election incumbent governments (albeit Ontario with a minority)? If the so called 99% had gotten out and actually voted instead of winning about not having a voice or being ignored then we would have had change when it was the easiest and most direct way possible.
George, Winnipeg Manitoba
10/29/11 11:02 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The far left hates gays
The Occupying scum are pro-jihad, anti-white, Che Guevara-wannabes(a mass murderer who loathed gays and put them in concentration camps). Any gay man is seriously nuts to support these filthy animals. Xtra! will never tell you the truth.
ron, Vancouver Bc
10/30/11 1:15 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
rights movement
The modern LGBTI rights movement was kicked off at Stonewall by a riot against the police. The primary gains of the LGBTI community may have in the end been legalized in parliament, etc., but the movement for rights and respect began and continued for quite some time with rioting in the street by people who were far more dedicated than you lazy ignorant wannabes.
Savannah, Toronto ON
10/30/11 2:05 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A response to Savannah Garmon of QuAIA
While the Stonewall riots in New York on June 28, 1969 were an important event in LGBT history, it’s not accurate to say that the movement “began” with that rioting in the streets. Many people have been responsible for the advancement of LGBT rights, not just street protestors. For example, on September 4, 1957, the Wolfenden Report in the United Kingdom called for the decriminalization of homosexuality. This led to the decriminalization of homosexuality in England and Wales in 1967 and Canada in 1969 – before the Stonewell riots occurred. Even Xtra columnists have noted this. For example, see http://www.xtra.ca/public/Vancouver/The_decriminalization_of_homosexuality-2057.aspx. But, I realize that people like Savannah Garmon of QuAIA have their own agenda in trying to glorify left-wing street protestors, while referring to everyone else as “lazy ignorant wannabes”.
Jake, Toronto Ontario
10/30/11 4:14 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Intellectual/legal activism did morethan Stonewall
“Harry Hay conceived of the idea of a homosexual activist group in 1948.” He and several other Gay men formed the Mattachine Society in 1950 in the U.S. Meanwhile, Western European Gays were also forming “Homophile” movements. “By 1969, there were dozens of homophile organizations and publications in the U.S, and a national organization had been formed, but they were largely ignored by the media.” (Wikipedia) The Stonewall Drag Queens got their spunk from 20 years of intellectual/legal activism and encouragement by mostly Gay men who put their life and careers on the line, lobbying people in high places to legalize Homosexuality. Drag Queens got media attention with their attack on police. Drag Queens became just catalysts of a movement, not originators, as the media just love colourful Drag Queens. It was the sudden media splash which speeded up the process that Harry Hay started. Savannah Garmon QuAIA, wants everyone to believe that Drag Queens and by association Trans, were the birth mothers of the Gay movement. But they had no ovaries nor uterus and could not have given birth...And still today Trans Queens have no ovaries/eggs nor uterus, but are as colourful, loud, brassy and mouthy as ever. The louder the barrel the more empty it is.
GAY, TO ONT
10/30/11 5:41 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks, Jake.
Jake, Savannah "QUAIA" Garmon likes to have the last word on every subject and is the expert on every single issue, or so s/he tells us, so if you're going to respond to all her rantings, get a comfortable computer chair and crack open a beer. I've given up feeding that particular troll, who seems to think that posting inane comments here and writing in to Xtra is a form of "activism." But getting rid of he/r is simple - put h/er name second in a list. Apparently that's erasure. So, Lindsay Lohan and Savannah Garmon...poof! Erasure achieved! Thank God of Cunt that's over with.
Alejandro, Toronto ON
10/30/11 3:54 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Learn some history, syster, before you lecture us.
Correction: the modern rights movement started in the 19th century, in Europe before the Nazis put an end to it, for a spell. Only the Americentric point out the beginning of the movement as arising out of New York in 1969. Read some fucking history, bitch, before you lecture the rest of us, you Jew-hating uneducated donkey-blowing whore.
Shalom el Sheikh, Toronto ON
10/30/11 4:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Gross. Hippies. Bring the hoses.
These people are breaking the law - probably several. When are the police going to do their job and get the fucking hippies out of the park? Those of us who pay taxes and go to work would like someone to walk our dogs in the evening or take our kids out on weekends. The b.o. is melting the insides of my nostrils. Enough, already. And no, I'm not right wing nor a Tory. I'm just tired of this inane protest against nothing in particular. What a bunch of inarticulate idiots. Remove them.
Ron, Toronto ON
10/30/11 4:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
hehe
lol u guys are funny :)
Sav., Toronto ON
10/30/11 4:51 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Tranny with a precarious occupation
As a trans woman of color, we can identify easily with marginalized workers, underemployed workers, and the discrimination we face everyday from Coporate Canada. That’s why I think transgender people or sex workers might be interested in the occupy movement, because we know what humiliation , rejection and exploitation is like , we experience them everyday. No one should expect a well to do gay man or lesbian woman will be as likely to join, there are selfish , greedy people in every race, sexual orientation or religious groups. That’s just the way it is, but I do support the occupy movement, because we are at the very bottom of the barrel and we fight everyday to be ourselves and gain a liveliehood, we are the bottom 1 percent of the 99 percent, but we are still part of the 99 percent and that’s why some of us are there.
Stacy, Toronto Ontario
10/30/11 6:37 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
jesus christ on a cracker
I try hard to not read the comments, I try really, really hard. but sometimes I fail. and this is what I get? A bunch of blowhard trolls getting all up in a group-hate-on because they assume one of the comments is from a QUAIA member, and generally hating on "the far left" and making completely inexcusable transphobic comments to 'spice up' their diatribes? um, I hate to break it to you sisters, but it was a COMBINATION of street activism &(by the drag queens, sex workers and working class queer folks who didn't have access to the conversations being had by) middle and upper class white, tony homos who were able to play the inside (strategically, with hopefully less personal loss, though when loss did come it was quite dramatic). So because you folks can't be nice, I reported a bunch of comments because I think they actually qualify as hate-speech. You might want to think about that. Maybe you might also want to speak your mind publicly with your name attached (look me up) to deal with the ACTUAL ramifications of what you say so flippantly here. But I'm not losing my mind over this as I once would, as I've seen some of the same handles making the same inane, thoughtless and intentionally hurtful comments that seek to shut down intelligent discourse. Kyle said: "Occupy Toronto simply do not represent the interests of the LGBT in ways that truly matter and that are affirming. At least not mine." I'm glad that you were able to name that your opinions are actually only YOUR OWN. maybe if more of us on these comments held to that, AND ALSO were able to open our minds to see how other opinions could be validly held by other queers IN OUR COMMUNITY (whether you like it or not) maybe you'd stop sounding like such effing douchebags and I wouldn't be so afraid of the comments section.
Mikiki, Toronto ON
11/08/11 11:05 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.