Dealing with depression
HEALTH / I thought something was wrong but learned it's common for adult gay men to suffer from depression
Kaj Hasselriis / Toronto / Wednesday, March 06, 2013
Share |

A couple of days before New Year’s, right after Toronto finally got its first major snowfall of winter, my friend Andrew organized a tobogganing party at Riverdale Park. It was a beautiful afternoon for sledding, and every kid in the neighbourhood showed up to tackle the hill. Our small group was surrounded by smiling and laughter.
 
Still, I hated every minute of it. As I observed all the joy around me, including on the faces of the friends I was with, all I could think about was how miserable I felt. On an afternoon that was producing so much happiness, I was consumed by unhappiness. Seeing how much fun everyone else was having only made it worse.
 
But I also realized, for the first time ever, how absurd my feelings were. How could I not be enjoying this afternoon? There must be something wrong with me. It felt like my mind had been poisoned by negative thoughts and I couldn’t force them out, as if the cartoon devil in my head had defeated the angel. Then I finally acknowledged to myself that I was depressed.
 
For me, that moment was like coming out. For years, I had experienced — on and off — the same feelings as I was having that day. But even though my depression often lasted for weeks at a time, I had always been able to deny it and make it go away for a while. Now I realized it was always going to come back, a bit worse each time, unless I found a way to break the cycle.
 
Depression isn’t something that hits only gay men. But it’s a mental health issue that seems to strike us harder than the broader community. When I started doing a bit of research, I discovered one study after another showing that adult gay men experience depression, reach out for mental health services, and commit suicide at a rate at least three times higher than straight men. Yet this issue is rarely written about or discussed. Perhaps we don’t want to ruin our well-earned rep for being “out and proud,” but in some cases, depression is killing us. Just last year, The New York Times published a disturbing feature about a 49-year-old gay motivational speaker in Manhattan — attractive, popular and financially successful — who surprised all his friends one day by killing himself. His name was Bob Bergeron and he was just weeks away from publishing a book called The Right Side of Forty: The Complete Guide to Happiness for Gay Men at Midlife and Beyond.
Studies show that adult gay men experience depression, reach out for mental health services, and commit suicide at a rate at least three times higher than straight men.
(thinkstock)
 
I had just turned 39. In 10 years, I didn’t want that to happen to me. So, a couple of weeks after the tobogganing party I went to see a psychiatrist at Sunnybrook Hospital. After quizzing me for 20 minutes about my symptoms — sleepless nights; self-hating, suicidal thoughts; lack of motivation; constant attempts to escape unhappiness by quitting jobs, ending relationships and changing cities — he diagnosed me with depression. Then the psychiatrist said the most hopeful words I’d been able to hear in a long time: “If you get the help you need, you will be amazed at how happy you can feel and how much more you can accomplish.” 
 
Ever since I started “coming out” with depression I’ve been wondering what makes gay men more prone to experiencing it than straight men. I talked to a few therapists who see gay patients and, according to them, there’s one issue that keeps coming up: self-esteem. “That’s a huge issue for gay men that can lead to depression and anxiety,” says Scott Duggan, a gay psychologist in Toronto who has been counselling patients for 10 years. “Many gay men feel ‘less than’ because of societal expectations and norms, and that can cause internalized homophobia,” he says. “They feel like they somehow failed, even though they didn’t.” 
 
Being gay means resisting the traditional heterosexual expectations of life, and some guys have a harder time doing it than others.
 
Since my trip to Sunnybrook, I’ve started seeing a therapist. So far I don’t feel like my “issue” is self-esteem. Then again, Duggan says most other guys don’t realize it at first, either. A friend of mine said he started going to see a therapist a few years ago because he wanted to unpack his relationship with his mother. But over the next few months, he discovered his real problem was a feeling of low self-worth. This kind of anecdote is not surprising to Phillip Banks, a guy I met recently who works as a manager at the AIDS Committee of Simcoe County. Banks believes that many gay men suffer from “minority stress,” meaning that — as outsiders — we often feel the effects of social exclusion more than others. 
 
“A lifetime of homophobia and heterosexism can be deep and hard to address,” he says. There’s no shortage of gay men looking for help. Banks points to a recent survey of nearly 8,000 gay men across Canada in which half of all respondents said they had sought out psychological services. Depression was stated as the most common reason. Currently, Banks is developing a program to address gay men’s mental health issues in Barrie.
 
There’s already a lot of free short-term counselling available for gay men in Toronto. The problem is finding it. “For sure you can find resources,” confirms Marco Posadas, a psychotherapist with the AIDS Committee of Toronto, “but you have to know the system.” Guess where you’ll find Posadas? The bathhouse. He’s in charge of a roving counselling service in the city’s spas called TowelTalk. There, he meets guys and, if they want to continue talking beyond the baths, he invites them into his office at ACT for up to eight free sessions (whether they’re HIV-positive or not). 
 
Realistically, though, Posadas says it takes longer than that to get at the root causes of mental health problems. “There’s no such thing as a quick fix,” he says. 
 
The good news is, therapy can work — and Posadas speaks from experience as a patient. “One of the things I loved about my training is that I had to go through the analytic process myself. It made a huge difference in my own personal journey.” Then he laughs. “My family is very happy about it, too!”
 
Of course, gay men are just as complex as every other type of human. So the issues I need to overcome to help with my own depression might have very little to do with my homosexuality, or my self-esteem for that matter. I might have a chemical imbalance in my brain that I need to fix with medication, too. But everyone I interviewed said it’s important for therapists to consider what happens to us as a result of living in a heterocentric (and for some, homophobic) world. Which, by the way, doesn’t mean your therapist needs to be gay. “The best therapist is one who will listen,” says Posadas. “That’s way more important than the sexual orientation of a therapist.”
 
The therapist I picked is a heterosexual woman my psychiatrist recommended. So far, I’m finding her to be thoughtful and conscientious. I’m already feeling better, but she’s not the reason. I think it’s because, for the first time ever, I’m identifying and tackling my mental health problem. 
 
Where you can get help in Toronto: 
 
Private therapy can cost as much as $200 per session, but there is also plenty of free counselling available for Toronto’s queer community. Here are some of the options:
 
Family Service Toronto has an LGBT and HIV/AIDS counselling service. The HIV/AIDS service is free, while the LGBT option operates on a sliding scale; the lowest rate is $5 per session. Both services have a three- or four-month waiting list and offer up to 15 sessions of counselling for individuals, couples or families. To make an appointment, call 416-595-9618.
 
The 519 Community Centre has volunteer counsellors who will see patients up to six times each. After that, they’ll refer you to longer-term counselling or a group. The wait time for the first appointment is usually one to two months. To reserve a spot, call 416-392-6878 x4000.
 
The AIDS Committee of Toronto has the TowelTalk program, but if you’re not a bathhouse-goer you can still see a counsellor at the ACT office. Just check out the walk-in calendar on the ACT website or book an appointment by calling 416-340-2437. At ACT, counselling is seen as a form of HIV prevention, so you don’t need to be HIV-positive to get help.
 
Mount Sinai Hospital has a clinic for HIV-related concerns, for couples and individuals who are affected or infected by HIV. In most cases, patients must be referred by a family doctor. The wait time for a psychiatric assessment is about one month. Treatment usually begins a few weeks or months after that. For more information, call 416-586-4800 x 8714.

Where you can get help in Ottawa: 
 
If you're looking for affordable counselling services in Ottawa, just head to Cooper Street. There are two community organizations there that can help you.
 
The Centretown Community Health Centre, at 420 Cooper St, offers up to 20 free sessions with an LGBT-friendly mental health counsellor. To apply, just call 613-233-4443 x 2109. The current wait time for a counsellor is about one month. In case of emergency, the agency also has a walk-in counselling service every weekday from 1 to 4pm. Ottawa's other community health centres, located across the city, offer counselling programs, too.
 
Pink Triangle Services, at 331 Cooper St, also offers up to eight sessions of counselling. Clients are charged according to their ability to pay, but the sliding scale doesn't exceed $95 per session. To sign up for counselling at PTS, call 613-563-4818 or e-mail celebrating.self@ptsottawa.org.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Additional Free Counselling
To add to your list of free counselling resources: The Sherbourne Health Centre has a team of counsellors, some of whom are LGBT identified, who specialize in providing queer and trans positive counselling services. The service is free. Amount of sessions depends on presenting issues. Wait time 2-4 mos. Intake: 416-324-4100 X5310 Cheers.
N. Sim, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:12 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Also
Your family doctor can refer you to a psychiatrist (slightly different than a psychologist), not sure what the average wait time is, and they have to be specifically qualified, but with a doctor's referral they are often 100% covered by OHIP. See 'Psychiatrists' --> http://www.camh.ca/en/hospital/visiting_camh/rights_and_policies/Pages/challenges_choices_abouttherapy.aspx
S F, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:46 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
what about services for gay men
N Sim, your referral said that they provide services for queer and trans people but do they also provide services for gay men who the article was about? Queer and trans services are not the same as services for gay men by gay men.
david, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:59 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Online resource for LGBTQ+
When I first was looking for resources, I had a really hard time finding anything that was directed toward LGBTQ+ people. I felt alienated at support groups because I just couldn't relate to straight people. I created a resource and support site, http://www.queermentalhealth.org/ to fill the gap. In the almost 2 years it's been up, the website has grown into a great community of writers. One thing we are lacking though are cis gay men writers - if anyone is interested they should go to http://www.queermentalhealth.org/write/
Hanners Ellicott-Chatham, Vancouver BC
03/15/13 12:09 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
cis is a hate word to many so stop using it
Hanners, no gay male who is labelled as `cis` will get involved in your queer and trans centric group. Sorry but you just do not get it. Many gay men born with penises and raised male who enjoy being males with penises do not want mixed LBGTQ groups as our issues are so different. Gender is usually not an issue for many gay men but is the only issue of interest for most queer and trans people and women. Also it is very difficult to be open and trusting in a group where the other members view you as their oppressor. Queer and trans people and women have stated that gay men (white and not trans) are their oppressors -- so why on earth would any such man attend your group or anything like it.
david, Toronto ON
03/15/13 12:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
An important contribution to breaking the stigma
Shortly after testing positive for HIV in 1989 I began treatment for depression, a combination of medication and "talk therapy". In 2003 I was knocked down by a cab and, after surgery for a broken femur and wrist (with in-patient recovery during the time of SARS). Not long thereafter my meds were changed to reflect the post-traumatic stress I was dealing with. About six years ago, at the height of a family crisis, I was evaluated for bipolar disorder. In the simplest terms a gradual absence of depression, as welcome as that was, began to be replaced with near-manic episodes. A common mood stabilizer has been successful, for which I am very grateful, but talking about all of this is an isolated experience - limited to a group and individuals who have some experience. I don't know when all of this really started. There was plenty of self-destructive behavior going on many years before I was HIV-positive - behavior that still persists in the community today. It's encouraging that mental illness is getting the long overdue coverage that it is.
Kenn Chaplin, Toronto Ontario
03/15/13 12:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
therapy often not nearly enough
When I first sought help for an addiction problem in my early 20s I was diagnosed as being depressed, I was shocked, disgusted, & relieved all at the same time. I had never felt depressed, I just thought I was horrible person that everyone hated. Where & when I grew up before everyone had computers & the internet no one ever talked about mental health problems or being LGBT, not a word ever so I had no idea. But I was so relieved to think that I wasn't a horrible person just someone with an illness that can be treated. I know people who reject the mental illness tag but I embraced it. The antidepressants I was put on helped a bit but they weren't a cure, besides which I had essentially stopped growing when I sunk into my shell at about 13, looking back that was when the depression first hit, that shell only got worse when by 16 or so I was addicted to opiate painkillers. Ironically though the addiction nearly killed me several time over the next 22 years until I got & stayed sober it saved my life as a teenager since once addicted I stopped trying to kill myself with each attempt more violent. Many years of therapy helped a lot, especially CBT (no not that CBT) it made it so I didn't feel so horrible or that people were out to get me. However the meds never did & still don't do enough. Nowadays I rarely feel the emotional agony but I still experience the depressed brain functioning that leads to it. It often feels like I'm stoned, though I'm not, & its w/out any euphoria. My memory is horrible, can't concentrate, hour long TV shows & movies are impossible for me to follow, same with novels all of which I enjoy when doing better. Since middle age things only got worse, especially the anxiety aspect which I find unbearable & I'm currently unable to work because of it. I'm sober nowadays & don't feel like a horrible person thanks to therapy, but its still not nearly enough. All that keeps me going is the hope one day a new med will w
Rich, Toronto Ontario
03/15/13 8:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
ACT’s TowelTalk Program, Part 1
I am surprised that the above article would suggest that depressed gay men seek counseling from the TowelTalk Program of the AIDS Committee of Toronto (ACT). Firstly, the TowelTalk program generally works out of bathhouses and many gay men find bathhouses to be a depressing place (especially with the seedy atmosphere, the smells of body odour, inhalable drugs and cleaning fluids and the older, morose men sitting in their rooms with the doors open). Secondly, even though the article states that depressed gay men can arrange to see TowelTalk counselors at ACT’s offices, it is not clear that ACT has measures in place so that depressed gay men from certain groups are not assigned to Rahim Thawer, one of the TowelTalk’s counselors who has made comments against those groups. Thawer is one of three TowelTalk counselors at ACT. Source: http://www.actoronto.org/home.nsf/pages/act.docs.0990 In December 2012, Thawer wrote an article for the Huffington Post condemning and expressing his anger for gay men who applauded at a drag queen performance at Woody’s. Source: http://www.xtra.ca/public/Toronto/Drags_dilemma-12958.aspx As a matter of harm reduction, it appears that depressed gay men who are white, who work in law enforcement or who are Jewish supporters of Israel, should not be assigned to Thawer for counseling about their intimate, personal affairs. The reason for this concern is that Thawer appears to have a grudge against white people, policemen and Israel and has made statements against them.
Ray, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
ACT’s TowelTalk Program, Part 2
For example, in a September 13, 2012 internet posting, Rahim Thawer wrote: (quote) I seriously dislike Canada Day - each year is a nonsense celebration of European colonization while still, in 2012, not understanding the impact it's had on indigenous communities here or investing enough to correct the intergenerational trauma along with its other psychosocial-economical consequences. As someone born in Canada of parents who emigrated to this country, I declare my national Pride with great caution. I don't want to be thankful for being free and having rights - I should be able to be an out gay South Asian Muslim Canadian without having to fight for anything. I'd rather not pat White colonizers on the back for welcoming me into a country they raped; it further legitimizes White power. Finally, I think there needs to be great caution with equating things we see as progressive with national identity because it creates a dichotomy that inadvertently labels all other ways of thinking and being as backward. Basically, the caution re-creating Israel's pinkwashing (as an example) in a Canadian context, which we often already do. (end of quote) Source: http://wherehopetakesroot.blogspot.ca/2012/07/dark-side-of-nationalism.html
Ray, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:06 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
ACT’s TowelTalk Program, Part 3
Furthermore, a number of Rahim Thawer’s tweets (which were public until after they were subject to reader comments on the Xtra article at the above link) show the same grudge against white people. Since the quotation marks don’t work well in the comment boxes on Xtra.ca, I’ll just give you a sampling of his recent tweets preceded by a number and the date of the tweet. Here’s the sampling: (1) December 19, 2012 - Why am I being asked to defend Islam's view on gays bc I pointed out that a white person was Islamophobic? (2) December 19, 2012 - There's some very angry people who disagree with us. Many of them are white. (3) October 8, 2012 - If only the dominant group could see themselves through my lens. I reckon I'd have a softer voice, less sarcasm, & less need for therapy. (4) September 26, 2012 - So inspired by your strength to challenge dom powers that perpetuate oppression. (5) August 8, 2012 - Can we please name it as racism already? Oh, the caution of language when white folks are the perpetrators.
Ray, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:08 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
ACT’s TowelTalk Program, Part 4
In terms of his apparent grudge against policemen, Thawer is a member of the so-called Queers Against Social Justice (one of QuAIA’s front organizations - founded by, and composed of, QuAIA supporters). When Queers for Social Justice held a demonstration in June 2012, Thawer noticed that the demonstration was being observed by the police. Thawer then tweeted about how much he hated cops. In conclusion, for the reasons set out above, it appears that Thawer is a person who has an axe to grind against certain groups. ACT should have measures in place so that vulnerable, depressed gay men from those groups are not assigned to him for counseling.
Ray, Toronto ON
03/15/13 11:09 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
thank you
Ray for your expose of this monster of privilege and envy who is actually pretending to counsel gay men who he obviously abhors. Is he counselling for mental illness or only seeing people like himself where he can smugly blame all their problems of whitey. This anti-racist racism should disqualify anyone from any helping or counselling position. But of course at ACT it is all about the lunatics running the asylum so par for the course there. No wonder gay men are depressed. But one up note is the continued expose of these race baiting elitist prig assholes who are lording it over the cowering shame-based anti-racist crowd and know it. Obnoxious.
coelacanth, Toronto ON
03/16/13 8:03 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
How is this relevant?
Is there any article on xtra.ca that some pseudonymous commenter can't somehow relate to Israel? Even though Rahim Thawer has nothing to do with this article, "Ray" brings him into the discussion, and he coincidentally is Muslim. Xtra articles are great to read, but everyone I know has started avoiding the comment sections altogether because there is so much racist vitriol against Muslims and people of colour that has nothing to do with the topics being covered. Is it the same person posting all these comments, or is our community really that racist?
Brad, Toronto Ontario
03/16/13 4:09 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
he has everything to do with this article
Brad, the comments about the Thawer person have everything to do with this article. It is about gay men with mental illness as a huge untreated issue and the difficulty of finding help since there is nothing out there and the scarce places there are, as Brad points out are staffed with radical white and gay male hating maniacs like Rahim Thawer. Do you actually believe that anyone could get psychological help from someone so full of hate towards specific groups of people (with the evidence of this from his own hands on his own web media and quotes). Everyone you know may be boycotting the racism of the comments, but everyone I know are loving the fresh new breeze as the strangle bullshit of PC white shame and blame and the endless queer holier than thou crap is no longer the only point of view being allowed. Xtra used to edit these comments so severely that you must have loved it. Now that people are slapping down ALL bullshit in all colours and genders and kinds, your superiority over the "haters" is being shown up as unadultered condescending elitism.
david, Toronto ON
03/17/13 8:12 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
It IS different for gay men.
Yes, it's no secret we experience profound depression at rates unseen in straight society. For one, all this discussion about marriage during a time where it really sinks in that gay men get to choose from only 2% of the population, at some point it's clear that you're either meeting nobody at all, of this is not happening in the way you had hoped; many of us want companionship only to never find it. No matter where we move we 'know who everyone is' within six months. We don't respect each other, we reject one another, nor do we care what happens to other gay men. We have no support system in place for gay men to help one another through tough times because there is no TRUST. Our first instinct, when meeting a new gay man, is to LIE. It's what we've done to survive as long as we knew our identities. After a while we don't bother trying anymore, because we know these other guys have no intentions of calling again, and there goes another guy who knows your life story who you'll never hear from again. We also have two very different gay communities that never speak to one another. One is very highly educated, elite, affluent, centres on looks and income; the other struggles with affordable housing and homelessness, addiction, isolation and severe loneliness. This group sees none of the benefits of marriage because that's low on the list when you are trying to find housing or employment. And again, it's clear to us that we are on our own; don't expect other gay people to show up and support, or even say something encouraging. It's at this moment that I think many of us start to regret coming out at all, for it's been a waste of a life, these people who were supposed to be our friends and potential lovers are nowhere to be found, and year after year we go home to an empty apartment with a phone that never rings. There is no control over that. There is no control over the disappointment and lack of selection within the gay world. And that really sucks.
Jonathan, Fort Frances Ontario
03/17/13 4:48 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Jonathan can we talk...
...you have written the same thing over and over here (for years) and for many gay men all over the place there is some truth to what you write (lonliness and bitter isolation are universal), but moreso what you write about is what YOU experience (so using I instead of we may be more accurate). Sorry to be Toronto centric but I had to look up Fort Francis on the map and it is in the middle of nowhere. There is a reason that many gay men move to larger cities -- because there are so few of us, the smaller the place, the fewer there are. Perhaps if you relocated to Winnepeg of Regina that are smaller than nasty Toronto but have many more gay men than Fort F. Also seek therapy -- you sound clinically depressed. Hope this helps. An online long-distance support and counselling service for gay men in Ontario would be very useful, but identity politics prevents this from ever getting off the ground.
sympathetic but, Toronto ON
03/17/13 5:37 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ya lot's of problems
with depression. Most of the depression among Gay Men is caused by the so called Gay "helping" professionals themself. The various Counselors, Social Workers, Psychiatrists and so forth who continue to pathologise those with HIV, those who are proud gay MEN or putting their nose down at people's chosen lifestyle,(you think your clients don't know?) and these "helpers" often work for organizations that support the oppression and criminalization of Gay MEN with hiv, whose helper's "progressive" worldview is fundamentally opposed to any reasonable intelligent thinking Gay MAN, or the endless "helpers" who refuse to accept the very real discrimination Gay Men experience, and don't get me started on the quest for Hetero Normative state as the prize of Gay mental well being. Depressed. No shit, they're paying attention and it's not pretty. Who wouldn't be depressed? Towel Talk? See the problem? OMFG. It's hopeless.
tweedle do, tweedle dum
03/17/13 8:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
nice to read
That you weren't just put on medication right away was nice to read. Most will put you on medication right away which imo is not the answer. Good luck.
Mike, Toronto Ontario
03/25/13 12:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.