A mother's fight for bullied gay son ushers sweeping changes in Thunder Bay
NEWS / 'Any time someone calls you a fucking faggot, go public': Picard
Andrea Houston / Toronto / Sunday, February 13, 2011
Share |

When Ellen Chambers Picard found out her son Gabe was being viciously bullied every day at his high school, she took action, beginning a five-year battle to make schools in Thunder Bay safer places for gay, lesbian and trans students.

It isn’t just the Lakehead District School Board that has changed as a result.
Thanks to her fierce activism, Thunder Bay will celebrate its first ever Pride this summer. Not bad for a mom on a mission.

“I knew damn well he wasn’t the only student in Canada that experienced this,” says Ellen, proudly holding up the board’s positive-space action kit. “Schools have a duty to ensure all students are safe.


Ellen told her story to a roomful of hundreds of teachers at And Still We Rise, a women’s conference for members of the Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario (ETFO) at the Royal York Hotel on Feb 11. At the end of her inspiring story, every teacher stood and cheered.
Ellen Chambers Picard and her son Gabe.
(Andrea Houston)


Gabe sat at a table in front, beaming at his mom as she spoke. There wasn’t a dry eye in the house.

“Because of my mom, students don’t have to go through what I went through,” Gabe tells Xtra. Overcome with emotion, he wipes away tears and continues, “It’s really cool. I’m just so proud.”

Ellen’s venture into activism started in 2003 when Gabe, then 17, came home from school and told his mom he’d been kicked out for fighting; he had smashed another student against a locker. Gabe had had enough of being called a fag.

Gabe said to his mom, “Please make this go away. Don’t let this happen to anyone else.”

The next day, Ellen – then an elementary teacher – marched into the office demanding answers. A school staffer asked, “How was your son teased?”

“This isn’t teasing,” she shot back. “This is abuse.”

It was suggested that Gabe change schools. “Why should he have to change schools? I didn’t know anything about this. My son taught me everything.”

The vice-principal told Gabe it was impossible to change the school culture. “So I told the vice-principal that if she couldn’t change the culture she failed as an educator. I was a bit of a smart-ass,” Gabe, now a plucky 25-year-old, tells Xtra.

“It was a dark time. It was awful. No one wants things thrown at them or to be called a fag, but I was never one to be a victim.”

Ellen wrote searing letters, slamming the school’s lack of action. In 2004 she filed the first of two Ontario Human Rights complaints against Lakehead District School Board because the board had failed to take any measures to protect Gabe from bullying.

“I became obsessed,” she admits. “It’s all I talked about. In my house, it became known as ‘the complaint.’”

Her family started to worry about her. “They asked, ‘Ellen, is this good for you?’ This is very good for me. I need to do this for my son. I just knew I was right and they were wrong.”

She worried she would jeopardize her job, which was with the same board. But in the end she didn’t care. Her son was more important.

“I became a teacher because I wanted to change the world,” she says, a ferocious look in her eye. “My son was harassed since the age of eight. I didn’t see it and neither did his teachers. Where was I? Obviously not paying attention.”

Gay, lesbian and trans students should be visible at school, she says. “Can you imagine going to school from junior kindergarten to Grade 12 and not seeing any gay boy or girl in class, not one in any of the stories, not one in the history books?

“There wasn’t one textbook approved by the Ministry of Education with a picture of two boys holding hands. Not one book telling the story of a family with two moms. No wonder gay kids feel isolated.”

Together she and Gabe pushed for gay-straight alliances (GSA) in all four Thunder Bay public high schools. “The school board lied to us. There were no GSAs in any schools.”

When Gabe was in Grade 12, they went public. The normally media-shy family held a press conference. Ellen had grown frustrated with the board’s lack of action.

“My son was outed on the front page of the local newspaper,” she says. “There was both backlash and support from the community. What upset me most was we didn’t get one call from any of Gabe’s teachers.

“Anytime someone calls you a fucking faggot, go public.”
Ellen Chambers Picard speaking at And Still We Rise, a women's conference for members of the Elementary Teachers' Federation of Ontario (ETFO).
(Andrea Houston)


Gabe took his mom to gay dances, drag shows and queer youth groups. She immersed herself in gay culture. “I met so many queer youth. These are fabulous kids.”

The students who joined the newly created GSAs became leaders in their schools. “The kids are fine. It’s the adults that were holding everything back,” she says.

“I learned this is a heterosexist world,” she says. “It gets better? We have to make it better.

“Through it all I was driven by my son’s courage. It’s been seven years since the first complaint. The board was supposed to train teachers in recognizing homophobia. They still haven’t done that yet. So the fight continues.”

As a result of her astonishing advocacy, Ellen was honoured with the ETFO’s humanitarian award. She’s no longer a teacher; she is now the local ETFO union president.

Today high school teachers in Thunder Bay participate in an anti-homophobia workshop; there are lesbian, gay, bi and trans resources at each school; every high school has a GSA; human rights are discussed at every staff meeting; and schools have dedicated anti-homophobia trainers.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Types of Moms
Some mom's choose to disown their LGBTQ kids when they "come out." Some mom's choose to pretend it away. And then there's Gabe's mom. Never underestimate a mother's love!
Logan, Vail AZ
02/14/11 9:55 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Congratulations Ellen
Ellen Chambers Picard is a member of the Egale Eduation Committee but you would read that here.
Air brush Egale out., Toronto ON
02/14/11 10:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
GAY RIGHTS CANADA
Kudos to this parent, child and family. We need more people like this for my GAY FAMILY CHARTER CHALLENGE for GAY MALE FAMILIES, in FL01-11127 and FL01-01406. These cases have gone from discriminatory to abusive. Parent Alienation Syndrome with proven intent to do so SHOULD BE CRIMINAL. As a GAY Male my "comparitor" should be my other GAY MALE PARENT/GUARDIAN who wasn't protected under FLA to protected by same INTENTION OVER BIOLOGY as I WAS. WTF is discrimination here by asserting my "comparitor" is a WOMAN, If a GAY NON BIO one like FRAESS protected in 2005 then I should have got it at birth as well as conception of my intended child...WTF IS THis SCANDAL WITH Justice Minister ALison Redford who APPOINTED her monkey Phillipe RABOT as Director of the AHRC who agrees and allows discrimination against NON BIO MALE INTENDED FATHER only difference is NO ONE REALIZES In LAW a GAY MALE IS COMPARED TO A GAY MALE and not a god damn woman. HIS RIGHTS ARE MY RIGHTS AND CLEARLY I had LEGAL grounds after the win at COURT OF APPEAL IN 2007, in this consideration of FACTS I HAD RIGHTS THAT BIO DAD did not. 3 factors of discrimiation here one similar to CARON case recently won last Friday. #1 (like Caron) FINANCIAL DISCRIMINATION #2 MALE DISCRIMINATION aka GENDER DISCRIMINATION BY FEMINISTS like REDFORD WHO REFUSE TO remove mother from defination of FAMILY, and abuse the justice and AHRC system with Phillippe Rabot #3 SEXUAL ORIENTATION DISCRIMINATion and just for Kicks the big fat lies in front of Justice Mahoney by the 2 BIOLOGICAL PARENTS...one a proven SURROGATE by court of appeal. Supported by Edward McCann and Laurie Allen, as well as good friend and Collegue Deborah Shenette's who we hired to see gaps even with surrogate's written arrangement or not.ENTER Dr. Terry Pezzot Pearce for defamation and smoke and mirrors from a court ordered professional psychologist who was the ethics chair for the entire College of Alberta Ps
Dakota Wilfred Hart, Calgary AB
02/14/11 10:30 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
In school
"“Can you imagine going to school from junior kindergarten to Grade 12 and not seeing any gay boy or girl in class, not one in any of the stories, not one in the history books? “There wasn’t one textbook approved by the Ministry of Education with a picture of two boys holding hands. Not one book telling the story of a family with two moms. No wonder gay kids feel isolated.”" I've never thought about it like that before but it's so true. I still feel like that now in cegep. It's no small wonder that I hung out with my gay journalism teacher all the time in grade 11. His class was the only place where I felt all of me was accepted. There's still a lack of knowledge even at the college/cegep level. That's why anyone who mentions LGBTQ folks in class automatically gains bonus points in my book. We're so invisible all the time. Out of the dozens of classes I've taken, only four professors have mentioned gays at all, and only one has mentioned transgender folks. I'm glad I've had access to internet and bookstores, where I could order books by LGBTQ authors and learn about others like me. I'm not sure where I'd be otherwise.
Oliver, Montreal Quebec
02/15/11 10:33 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Congrats Ellen, Gabe and Family
I'm so proud of you Ellen. You rock girl. It truly was my pleasure to work beside you on the SAGE committee and more importantly, to become your friend. Hats off to you and your family for enduring this battle for us all! THANK YOU from the bottom of my heart!!! We love you!!! Jamus & Liam
Jamus Dorey, Louisdale Nova Scotia
02/15/11 10:39 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Well Done Ellen!
Ellen is exactly the kind of parent and teacher every school needs, the kind of person who DOES change a school culture because she knows you CAN change a school culture. Schools are not safe and caring for anybody unless they are safe and caring for everybody. Furthermore, if LGBT and questioning youth can be subjected to homophobic bullying, the so will heterosexual youth and LGBT teachers also be bullied. If someone must change schools, then those who engage in bullying must be the ones who change-- and it is up to make sure this happens when we know of homophobic bullying.
Wayne Madden, Edmonton Alberta
02/15/11 6:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Way to go!
Way to go gabe and ellen!
Noel, London Ontario
02/15/11 6:35 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bravo!
An inspiring and heart warming story. It takes courage to stand up and fight back, Gabe must be very proud of his Mom. A wonderful story of the sort I'd like to hear more of, thanks for sharing their story with us, it shows that change is possible if the will is there.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
02/15/11 6:48 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Excited!!
My wife and I moved to Thunder Bay a little over a year ago now and we love it. The only thing we've ever found trouble with was the seeming lack of GLBTQ presence. We came from a city that had many groups, events, educational programs etc. and it was shocking to see the discrimination and apathy in the city. I came across this article purely by chance and I'm so glad I did. It is reassuring to know that there are so many citizens of Thunder Bay working towards finding solutions to ending ignorance and hate. I look forward to participating in Thunder Bay's 1st Pride ever!!! Way to go everyone!! Thanks
Tweety, Thunder Bay ON
02/15/11 7:20 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The Good Mother
Everyone would benefit from a mom like this. I, too, say enough of this "anti-bullying" lip-service. What we need is more action!! back in the day people thought the Earth was flat, epilepsy was possession by the devil & mentally challenged people should be locked up. Let's "come out" of the middle ages & into the 21st. Century!!
Sun Shine, Edmonton Alberta
02/15/11 9:18 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
If only there were more!!
I so commend ellen for standing up, advocating for her child and all the many others that bullying has affected. It truly is a battle, Thank you for sharing your story , your son must be so proud. I just shared your wonderful story with my own children who teach me new things every day! PS your son sure is a nice looking young man! thanks again
monikacurrie, thunderbay, ontario
02/16/11 10:32 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Blessed
I was so blessed to have both of you in my life when I was a youth growing up into a young gay adult. You both provided so much inspiration and I truly think that you shaped a lot of me and who I am today.
Kyle, Kingston Ontario
02/16/11 10:58 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Blunder Gay
Thunder Bay, Is without a doubt, the most homophobic city in Canada, and Gang violence against even those who are straight, but accused or suspected of being gay is rampant. I have a son who is bullied/abused constantly, simply because he's not a follower, and f'king faggot is the most oft used slanderous epitaph he has to hear daily. No more public skating, or swimming, movies or dances or any activity where I'm not able to supervise 100% as everywhere he goes, (he's 12) he's voraciously attacked, and despite numerous complaints, the abuse is ignored, and even encouraged in most instances. I hate the hate in Thunder Bay, but I realize nothing will ever change. Thunder Bay does not have a Giant Heart, it has a vicious mean streak that continually ruins decent loving people.
Joe, Patrolie Ontario
02/16/11 12:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Gay basing
I did not know that my son was called a fag during high school. He never discussed it with me. He went on a school trip to Europe and for the first time met gays and lesbians and for the first time he started to fit in with a group of kids who understood what he was going through. He started to blossom after that and now at 35 years of age is a remarkable young man. If I had know that he was being bullied I would have reacted as I did with my youngest son who was being bullied a t school. He wasn't gay but I met the same reaction from the Principle and had to take matters into my own hands an brought in the RCMP who were terrific about stopping the abuse. I went into the school and demanded to talk to the kids who were responsible for the bullying and explained to them that they were not to harrass my son any further. The Principle refused to stay in the room and never did acknowledge the bullying but I understand from other parents that it did stop in that school. Parents need to intervene when there is a problem with their child. I am sorry that I was unable to do anything for my 'gay' child as I did not understand that he was gay at the time. Obviously, I was not attentive enough or deaf and blind to not see the obvious. Kudos to Ms. Chambers Pat Reid
Patricia Reid, Nelson B.C.
02/17/11 11:10 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
THANK YOU!
As someone who grew up in Homophobic Thunder Bay I applaud your tenacity and your success in propogating these much delayed and necessary changes. I left Thunder bay when I was 15 becuase I could not be who I was without feeling threatened at every turn. Your son should be very proud of you!
Deb, London Ontario
02/20/11 10:49 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
You were a good educator..and you still are!
It is so nice to see that Ellen fought for her son's human rights! She was an excellent teacher to my son and I was sad to hear she is no longer teaching but very glad she is fighting to change the lives of many students! It is hard enough to be a teen and no one deserves to be bullied!!
Ellen Chadwick, Thunder Bay Ontario
02/21/11 12:43 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thunder Pride Will Still Be A Disappointment
I watched the deputation before Thunder Bay city council. Apparently, there will be no pride parade. I think that is a huge short-coming for these events. A lot of the homophobia in Thunder Bay stems from the fact that the gay community is so closeted. Homosexuality is treated as an academic or an abstract concept. There is no human face or visibility. Visibility is a vital component to bringing change to Thunder Bay. This seems like a social event, which we've had in the past for interested parties, and some academic discussions at a breakfast in a church or hotel, also for a select interested group who wish to attend. Films will be shown, there will be a picnic. We've had these events before. Although they are few and far between, and represent one of the precious few opportunities glbt have to meet one another. Taking a stand for real visibility however, would have been truly revolutionary in Thunder Bay.
Clint, Thunder Bay ON
02/25/11 6:11 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.