We don't always need to work with the cops: community groups
NEWS / Seven organizations release joint statement on Ottawa Police
Noreen Fagan / Ottawa / Thursday, December 02, 2010
Share |

Seven community groups have issued a public statement reaffirming their opposition to police and police violence.

Pierre Beaulieu-Blais from Under Pressure and Karen Cocq from No One Is Illegal drafted the text.

"A lot of groups that had previously been working together on a bunch of different stuff decided to put our names on a statement together, mostly in response to a lot of stories that have been coming out by the Ottawa police in recent weeks,” says Beaulieu-Blais. “We thought it was timely to put the statement out there publicly.”

The statement was then floated to different local groups who suggested edits and eventually signed on as endorsers.

Below is the full text.

*

On Saturday November 20th two queer activists were arrested for unfurling a banner as part of the Trans Day of Remembrance events. The banner, which read ''Remember Stonewall?'', was dropped from a highway overpass near the Ottawa Police station on Elgin street, where a flag-raising ceremony for TDOR was about to take place. Many in the queer and trans community were upset that some TDOR organizers would choose to host an event with the police, given how tense the relationship between queer and trans groups and the cops has become. The flag-raising ceremony at the cop shop was supposed to turn into a march to Parliament Hill, but many in the community chose to gather at Minto park, a few blocks away, as an alternate to the police ceremony – making it clear that the police do not have the trust of many in Ottawa's queer and trans community.

Many groups have found it increasingly difficult, if not impossible, to work with the police, and so we would like to take this opportunity to reiterate our opposition to the idea that we must always work with the cops.

Many of us come from communities that have long been targeted by police forces, and continue today to be harassed by and experience violence from those same forces. We are queer, poor, non-status, trans, racialized, sex-workers, indigenous, disabled and homeless. We have been victims of violence, wrongful arrests, sexual assaults, intimidation and ridicule by the police.

This has been the case for many many years. But recently, in the last year, the systemic nature of abuses on the part of the Ottawa police has been so exposed that even the most sympathetic can no longer excuse it as 'a few bad apples'.

Earlier this year Ottawa Police released the photograph of a man who didn't disclose his HIV-positive status to partners, using the words "sexual predator” in media communications. The young man is now being charged with aggravated sexual assault for allegedly spreading a sexually transmitted disease. His picture made the front page of Ottawa newspapers. Despite this being widely condemned by HIV activists and community organizations, Police Chief Vern White stood by his decision earlier this year to release the photograph. By flatly rejecting a community proposal to review and develop policy guidelines for prosecution for HIV non-disclosure cases, Chief White showed no interest in collaboration and chose to ignore the expertise of HIV/AIDS community organizations and legal opinions denouncing this intensification of the criminalization of HIV. The outrage over this incident caused deep divisions in the queer community during Ottawa Pride in August, when official Pride organizers invited the Ottawa police to speak at the human rights vigil as part of the week's events, prompting an outcry from community-based HIV/AIDS organizations and activists in which they stated that if the police were not uninvited from the event they would be forced to withdraw and organize independently.

This summer well over a thousand people were arrested at the mass anti-G20 mobilizations in Toronto. Some were beaten, some were dragged from their beds in the early hours of the days of action, some were captured on their way to or from the protests and some were caught in mass arrests. Most of the arrestees have had their charges dropped, though some still face serious Conspiracy charges, draconian bail conditions, while some remain in jail and others face deportation.

On June 18th of this year three local activists were arrested. One was released a few days later under strict conditions, another spent months in jail, and another remains locked up today. Charges have been stayed for two of the arrestees, but the damage to their lives has already been done. In addition, through the court proceedings it was discovered that police had not only had active surveillance on local activist groups, but actually had an undercover agent infiltrating social justice organizations.

Recently, an Ottawa police officer who followed a cab driver to the airport, in a fit of road-rage after being cut off on the road, and broke the cab driver's arm after uttering racial slurs, was acquitted. Despite the obvious racist motivations behind the attack, and the complicity of other officers in the incident, the Police Chief chose to defend his officers and faced sharp criticisms from the taxi driver's union who could not be appeased, and demanded that the entirety of the Ottawa police force be reviewed and that Chief White address the systemic racism of the force.

Recently, a number of women have gone public with charges of harassment and assault against Ottawa police officers, many of them implicating the same officers in a more than one incident of abuse – officers who remain employed by the Ottawa police. We learned about the case of a young woman who was arrested, sexually assaulted – violence which was caught on police video – and held for hours by the Ottawa police after having committed no crime. Walking through the Byward Market late at night she was a victim of social profiling. A judge called her treatment a ''travesty.'' Two weeks later, another woman came forward with a lawsuit against the same officers, among others, for assault while in custody and wrongful arrest. And this past weekend, another Ottawa woman also came forward with charges of sexual assault and mistreatment while in custody after being arrested without cause.

We say that these are not random or unrelated incidents. And they are also just the tip of the iceberg, further proof of a bad system that must be changed immediately.

These are not just a few bad apples – this is a corrupt, illegitimate, and violent institution. More than the high profile cases that we see on the news, it is the institutionalized discrimination and day-to-day abuses of the police that worry us the most: systemic racism and misogyny, the continued arrests of sex workers, the ticketing of panhandlers, the lack of any real action for the hundreds of missing aboriginal women, the harassment and criminalization of drug users and countless other offences.

Despite mountains of proof that criminalization does more harm than good, it continues to be the only agenda that this city is willing to put money behind. This dangerous strategy is being implemented by a police force with a long and troubling history of violence, abuse of authority, and impunity. This is not a system that we deem fair and democratic and this is not a system that we will cooperate with.

We applaud the efforts of all those struggling for justice and freedom, and those who have risked or lost their freedoms in this fight. We stand in solidarity with all prisoners and all those struggling to survive in the face of a system that would rather see them dead. We will continue to support all political arrestees and all those subjected to police brutality, and continue to proclaim loudly that the police are not our friends.

endorsed by:
No One Is Illegal (Ottawa)
POWER
Common Cause
Indigenous People's Solidarity Movement
Pro-Choice Coalition of Ottawa
Agitate!
Under Pressure


Share |


Reader Comments


 
......
BRAVO!!!
Rick Lobodzinski, Toronto Ontario
12/08/10 1:24 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
AGREED!
The same can be said of most metropolitan police forces in this country. I've personally seen actions that were on par in Vancouver, Victoria and Edmonton. Trust is earned. And the police of this country are doing between little and NOTHING to EARN that trust.
Leslea, Coronation Alberta
12/08/10 3:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
LAME
Grow up already! No system is perfect. A few, yes very few incidents don't make the Ottawa police corrupt. Also, It's ridiculous to lump in a sexual assault with G20 actions considering that we're talking about two different cities. As for the bit about the minorities, sex workers and HIV positive people, I have some advice, Stop breaking the law, get a real job and quit doing drugs and the police will not bother you anymore. It's that simple. Yes there is the whole homophobia/transphobia/racism thing but really we all have two options, get over it or continue to victimize ourselves. Take some personal accountability, be a contributing member of society and it will be much easier to change things, people will accept you if you. That's not PC enough for todays activists but it's the best answer if we as queer people want to get things done and be successful.
George, Barrie Ontario
12/08/10 6:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Organizatons against the Opressors
Well congrats to you all for making your statements public. No doubt this public media forum is part of the populace pressure that the Police Service is facing as it has now invited the OPP to investigate within. This is always good! This means Change will happen. This means your organizations are the fruit of this change. This also means need to go online and find your websites because other than Agitate and the Pro Choice Coalition, as an Ottawa of 50+ years I had never heard of your groups before. But Kudos to you all, and because we are a free society, mind you define true freedom you find kaos....as a free society you can oppose the opressors, call for reviews, etc...and do so knowing you are protected under the laws. Hopefully not every believes every police officer out there is unhinged, tainted, vile, and coersive and a power hungry fascist. They aren't. But we certainly have some misguided employess of this service that need to be weeded out and well...charged if you ask me. So kudos to you all...I love you all for your youth, your compassion and for your strive, to make Ottawa the better city that it is, and will become.
Sylvia Martin, Ottawa Ont
12/09/10 9:27 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
For George in Barrie
Hi George, just to be clear, the OPS were in Toronto for the G20, along with many other police forces from across Canada. So, just to be clear, you're saying that victims of sexism, racism, homophobia and transphobia should suck it up and "get over it"? Maybe you need to look up the history of Stonewall and the gay rights movement, and/or educate yourself on the history of police states. Nice to benefit from the struggles of others, eh? My own suggestion is that we, citizens and ratepayers, need to demand that "our representatives" start cutting police budgets, now. In order to keep the possibility of civilian control over policing (which increasingly looks like a myth to me and many others), we need to break down the compact that presently exists between Police Services Boards and Shitty Councils, and a common sense, broad-based demand like this provides a pragmatic way forward. To Sylvia, I wish I shared your optimism about "a few rotten apples" but what I'd like to know, in light of recent events in Ottawa and coming out of the G20 in Toronto, why the supposedly "good apples" maintain their code of silence. I simply don't see the cops as an honourable profession, frankly, as they don't serve or protect us, just their political and corporate bosses.
John in Ottawa, Ottawa Ontario
12/09/10 1:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
What about the others?
How about getting some other names on here and not just this inter-related circle of groups that work together? There are certainly a lot more organizations that should have been approached and would add their names to this list, but I see this list being incredibly limited.
CF, Ottawa Ontario
12/09/10 2:43 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
re: What about the others?
I think this is a great statement but I do agree that outreach needs to be made with other sections of the community, such as organized labour - like the taxi drivers union - and community associations. I hope I am wrong in my assumptions and this effort has indeed been made. The civil rights lawyer Clayton Ruby has said in response to what happened at the G20 that police budgets should be curtailed. Perhaps this is the sort of campaign that could pull together more community and labour groups especially when cutbacks are likely coming on libraries, arts and other non-police, non-business areas of the city.
bob, kingston ontario
12/09/10 7:52 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Great letter!
This letter makes me really proud of Ottawa's activists. Stay strong, and speak loudly!
Caro M, Toronto, formerly Ottawa ON
12/10/10 9:08 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
more than one side
this kind of truth conveniently leaves out any other versions of the story. I 100 percent agree that many police officers in Ottawa are corrupt, and there are many bad seeds. But to say they are all corrupt is called STEREOTYPING. And that is something i thought my community, the queer community, was sensitive to. That banner off the highway? It was a dangerous act. The cop at the airport? Sounds like both motorists were egging each other on (but the violence was clearly out of line). Anyway, so many sides here folks. I think Noreen is putting this out there without context, without other viewpoints. That’s what good journalists are supposed to do... give a balanced perspective of the ideas floating out there.
H, ottawa on
12/14/10 1:54 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.