Spectrum offers space for queer youth to sparkle
NEWS / YSB's weekly group provides education and essentials
Bradley Turcotte / Ottawa / Tuesday, June 19, 2012
Share |

Since 1960, the Youth Services Bureau (YSB) has catered to Ottawa’s at-risk juveniles.

After conducting a comprehensive needs assessment of gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and questioning youth, the YSB launched the Spectrum Youth Group last month to address the specific issues modern queer kids are faced with.
 
Spectrum aims to dissect these issues like a prism, implementing educational tools that deal with everything from depression and substance abuse to coming to terms with sexual identity and social justice.

The group also offers several basic-needs services, such as laundry, access to showers and on-site counselling.
 
Spectrum is additionally integrated with the rainbow of services offered by YSB, such as emergency shelters, a drop-in centre, a transitional and long-term housing program and access to a health clinic.
 
A typical night at Spectrum includes the oppurtunity to use its services and take part in an icebreaker activity, an educational workshop or play board games. Previous workshop topics have included queer representation in comic books, heteronormativity and genderbending.
 
Spectrum volunteer Erica Butler, 21, says that since the group held its first meeting last month, it has evolved into a vital social outlet for many of the young participants.
Spectrum volunteers Rhonda Chamberlain (left) and Erica Butler shine through with smiles.
(Bradley Turcotte)

“You can already see there is a community developing. People are forming friendships and making lasting relationships,” Butler says.
 
Fellow volunteer Rhonda Chamberlain, 24, says it was important for her to get involved in Spectrum, as such services were nonexistent when she was in high school.
 
“I think seeing youth grow together and create a community is inspiring. It’s important for everybody to feel included,” she says.
 
Andrea Poncia, an HIV/AIDS educator who works directly with Spectrum, says the group is extremely fortunate to have volunteers such as Butler and Chamberlain leading the collective.
 
“All the youth volunteers bring many talents and experiences to their role,” Poncia says.

“We are fortunate to have a strong team of young people involved in our youth engagement program at the Youth Services Bureau with Spectrum.”

The group is currently seeking new volunteers to shine new light through their spectrum. Being queer is not a prerequisite, although a willingness to learn is, Chamberlain says.
 
“We’re looking for volunteers who will be accountable for their actions and are willing to be educated themselves. I think a big part of our team is that everyone should feel safe. Part of that is learning yourself, recognizing what other people’s needs are and thinking about how we can accommodate those needs,” Chamberlain says.
 
Spectrum Youth Group
Every Tuesday, 7-9pm
Open to youth aged 12-25
Youth Services Bureau
147 Besserer St


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Are you kidding me?
I think that this is ridiculous. The way that this article is presented. It is showing that spectrum is the only queer youth group in Ottawa when in reality it is not. Yes the YSB has shower and laundry on site I get that and it can be really useful. Spectrum was created is a way that has divided the queer youth in Ottawa. Most of the youth that go to spectrum are youth that would go to PTY. The people that need to do their laundry and take a shower will go to the YSB but that does not mean that they need a youth group there. This group was created out of spite and they really need to get of their high horses and grow up.
Anonymous, Ottawa ON
06/20/12 11:03 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
be nice or leave
It is always a good idea to have more rather than less services for our young queers.
butchie, montreal qc
06/20/12 4:27 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
There are plenty of safe spaces
I think that with this though the YSB is trying to do to much. Spectrum is supposed to be a safe space but with my experience with it I didn't feel as though it was safe. Firstly, Spectrum is held in an open area of the YSB where basically anyone can walk so if someone were under the influence of something then it would violate the safe space rule. Secondly if you are sharing something that is personal and someone randomly walks in then I would feel that my space was invaded. Thirdly, the way that the YSB does things doesn't necessarily work for spectrum because the groups that are supposed to be anonymous but when you first start there they make you sign a form that has your name,an emergency contact and some distinguishing features in case they need to find you but in reality this is in violation of the privacy act.
Anonymous, Ottawa ON
06/21/12 12:45 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pleased to offer options
YSB is dedicated to helping youth in Ottawa. Spectrum grew from conversations with queer youth who informed us what they needed. PTY has provided great services for many many years and YSB is pleased to continue to work with PTY and learn and grow together. We would invite people to visit our website to learn more about the crucial proghrams and services YSB offers.
Joanne Lowe, Ottawa Ontario
06/21/12 5:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
PTS continues its downward spiral into oblivion!
It's obvious to me that the folks at PTS and PTY are running a sinking ship. Snarky comments on articles like this; inciting 'turf wars' over who owns programs for queer youth; not to mention libellous Facebook posts by employees (endorsed whole-heartedly by their executive director) only prove that they're only concerned with organizational self-preservation. If PTS was truly looking out for queer youth (and not only themselves) they'd welcome the addition of services and outlets for our youth rather than cry foul because someone else saw a genuine community need and responded. Congratulations to Joanne, YSB and the Spectrum volunteers.
A concerned queer, Ottawa Ontario
06/22/12 12:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A concerned queer
It's great to hear hypocritical, unsubstantiated statements alleging a 'turf war', and this 'turf war' being encouraged by insinuating its presence when it is not there. PTS/PTY is not the only organization/group which thinks YSB may be taking on too much, and their staff, though making comments about Spectrum, are keeping their arguments about the groups and the organization, not toward the people who run them (unlike one of the comments above) Your choice to remain anonymous when making such bold statements only further proves you've got an axe to grind against PTS, but that you're too cowardly to associate yourself with it. In order to look out for queer youth (as it has proven it does), PTS has to look out for itself. If it does not, then it would not be able to provide the tremendous services it does. If it does not, it would have gone down years ago when it went through a multitude of challenges. But it definitely did not, and it definitely will not, stop providing essential services, not only to queer youth, but to and for the queer community in general. Keep your allegations to yourself, unless you've got facts to back it up. Cowardly behaviours are not becoming of someone who is trying to discourage drama.
Jean Yves, Montreal QC
06/22/12 3:08 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Cyber bullying
Concerned queer: your attack on the persons responsible for the agency with the longest running queer youth drop in is the kind of cyber bullying that chips away at conversation. Not only are you questioning the ethical integrity of the executive director (who is responsible for having brought the agency back from chaos), you are also insulting the staff of that same agency: staff who work long hours to provide services to countless people, and who on top of that have to take these kinds of personal attacks, and go back to work the next day. How do you think YOUR actions are affecting the services to queer youth? I think some self reflection is needed on your part. What seems to be so obvious to you is clearly not obvious to others, as the staff team at PTS is growing, as is their volunteer base, and their client base (not to mention programming). You've turned an article (which was being discussed critically in the comments) into a turf war. PTY was mentioned once in the comments, and you took it upon yourself to single handedly undermine and silence the commentators of the community, who are the people you allege PTS is not working for. There is no need for your kind of behaviour in public forum: it is not positive and it is not productive: only destructive.
An actually concerned queer, Ottawa ON
06/22/12 3:39 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
“Options” or “spin messaging”?
Suggesting this is about options for youth is a great defense, but nothing more than smoke and mirrors once the truth is uncovered. Spectrum did not grow out of conversations with youth. It grew out of spite against PTS. In January, despite many previous attempts to resolve issues, PTS suspended the partnership with YSB because of concerns with how they were providing counselling. It was clear that without pressure, there was no hope to resolve the matter. Unfortunately, instead of resolving the issues, YSB elected to move on stating that “it wasn’t the right time to continue the partnership”. This message was relayed in mid-January -- long before any “comprehensive needs assessment” was conducted. In fact, a needs assessment wasn’t circulated until some time in April, and to further the evidence of spite, this needs assessment wasn’t circulated with PTS or with clients attending PTY (other than those who are connected with Spectrum facilitators through social media). It should also be noted that the Spectrum facilitators are also former PTY facilitators. YSB's decision to create this group, under these circumstances, has only fractured the queer youth community. The number of friendships that have been sacrificed and the frustration expressed by so many clients and volunteers at PTY is overwhelming and surely doesn't reflect a decision made in the best interest of queer youth. It is clear by the manner in which YSB has conducted itself through the development of this program that working with PTS now (or in the near future) is unlikely. It is unquestionable that the majority of services offered at YSB are essential to youth in Ottawa, but there is no reason to duplicate a service that already exists and to do it in a way that is arguably unsafe and unhealthy.
Claudia Van den Heuvel, Ottawa ON
06/22/12 5:22 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks for your concern
Thanks "An actually concerned queer" and "Jean Yves" for your rebuttals. Perhaps my earlier post was a little inflammatory - I'll concede that with the 20/20 benefit of hindsight. But it did incite your responses, which makes for a richer conversation. I guess I'm just calling it like I see it. For all we know, you might have been dispatched by the folks at PTS to help extinguish what seems like a number of fires that are burning over there. I'm a fan of queer drama, but I'd rather see it on TV than in organizations that serve our community. You don't think it's a little bit funny that the first comment on the story is one poo-pooing the program? Check the Xtra archives. I'm sure the comments are riddled with PTS-backed poo-pooing.
A concerned queer, Ottawa Ontario
06/22/12 5:27 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Calling it like it is
If all this can be chucked up to calling it like you see it, then I guess we're both just contributing to a conversation. Except that now, you're also undermining my comments based on speculation. I would like to see where you get your bias from, insinuating other people are just commenting in the defense of an organization. I'm sure this works great for your TV drama, but there's no need for it here. I don't see how your contribution was a productive one. But again, we're getting away from the point. The point here is that there is a new program. Were it not for you, there would have been no derailment of this conversation from the topic. Congratulations, you've successfully led the downfall of this comment section.
Jean Yves, Montreal QC
06/22/12 9:07 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
more, not less support for youth
I think the more support for queer youth, the better. Making this into some sort of rivalry is pointless and does not help anyone, and it is immature to bicker back and forth about which group is "best". Support each other and your shared desires and concerns, or just keep to yourselves and not get involved with what the others are doing. This was a great article sharing a new, promising, and useful youth service and there is no need to scare away your target audience by criticizing the group in question.
Christine, Ottawa Ontario
06/23/12 12:17 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I don't really have a title for this
I would just like to say that I am one of the facilitators for PTY and I just wanted to and in my two cents. As Claudia had said about friendships being sacrificed, Personally I have lost a good chunk of friends due to the creation of spectrum. When the spectrum facilitators left PTY they took a lot of people with them which makes me really sad because I miss them. Personally I am all for more youth groups but when you are making the youth choose which friends they are going to hang out with then that is just isn't fair to the youth.
Alex MacDonald, Ottawa ON
06/23/12 3:01 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
none
I think it is ridiculous that people on here are wasting their time talking about duplicating services and having more than one queer youth group. I am going to state this up front so you can take me as an educated commentor..I have no association with either YSB or PTS. I think instead of arguing about which program youth decide to attend (which is THEIR choice) everyone should be glad they are accessing a service! Both PTS and YSB have long standing reputations in the community of providing excellent service, and even though people like to instigate their ideas out of drama, I doubt either organization would go through the trouble, buraucracy and cost of starting a program out of spite. Taking a step back from the situation, if you think an organization is acting that way, you probably have a personal foot in one of the doors. Instead of leaping to defend an organization or critiquing another, remember that the ultimate goal is for queer youth to have somewhere to go. Obviously if youth go to PTS it's because they like it and feel safe. If a youth goes to Spectrum, it is for the same reason. Ottawa does not have the strongest queer community and I think that arguments like this contribute more energy into creating a negative environment instead of a positive one. We all have the same thing in common...wanting to have spaces to belong to.
anoynmous, Ottawa ON
06/27/12 12:09 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
WOW
That last comment struck a nerve. Nadia said something pretty telling. When addressing Claudia, she said "You should be setting a better example for your youth." YOUR YOUTH??? WTF is that? Are the young people of our community seen as assets to you people? Get a grip people. I've been away for quite awhile, (thankfully), but this whole community has gone for a big dump and no one seems to care. But Nadia - in your comment to Claudia, you made clearer what was a blurry image. Shame. The youth of our community are at stake.
Robin, Ottawa On
07/12/12 11:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
last comment
Hi Robin, I in no way meant to imply ownership over youth or that they are assets. I'm sorry if that is how it came off but that is definitely not how I feel. I really am upset over this rift. I did a student placement at PTS and volunteered. Now working at YSB it's hard to not feel torn in the middle when the ED is publicly declaring your counselling practices questionable. Surely you can understand that as a YSB counsellor this is upsetting? The organization that helped train me and that I've been passionate about supporting for years is battling it with my current place of employment. When I wrote my first comment I was upset but I don't want to get into a war or words. People can pick through this post and find something they don't like and blow it out of proportion and that's their perogative. This is simply a statement of how this rift has personally affected me. Take care, Nadia
Nadia, Ottawa Ontario
07/13/12 12:53 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Buuuuuuuuull
For the sake of full disclosure, I have been a volunteer with PTS for going on ten years in a wide array of positions, and I was employed with PTS for part of that time. During part of that time, I was also a volunteer with YSB, for about five or so years. That being said, my allegiance has, and always will be, on the side of high quality services for the client, regardless of who they are. I would like to point out the two people who made this about a fight between PTS and YSB are people branding their disdain toward PTS as concern with services for queer youth, and yet are the ones accusing PTS of slinging mud. They are also the ones who are calling into question PTS' contribution to the queer community, and the value of PTS' executive director. Claudia is the only one who has used fact in her argument, as opposed to throwing below the belt hits aimed at individuals or even YSB. What happened to the original intention of this article: to bring to light a new service. Why are people so hell bent on creating friction and drama where there need not be any, and derailing the conversation from what could be a positive conversation to one about libel and integrity? Shame.
Jean Yves Benard, Montreal QC
07/13/12 1:10 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Dear Nadia & Robin
Thank you for commenting and over simplifying a very complex situation. Unfortunately you're estimations are a little off. Claudia simply told the truth about the situation because they are a lot of rumours floating around perpetuated by people who either know nothing of the situation or by people who are satisfied with only hearing one side of the situation without hearing the "other side" out, like you seem to be. Claudia never said Spectrum group or the counselling provide at Spectrum is unsafe or unhealthy. The point she is making is the process in which the group came about was unhealthy. As someone (one out of many someones) who has lost very good friends (The Spectrum leaders and some of the staff at YSB) because of this entire situation, it has had an enormous negative impact on my mental and emotional health. If that is not unhealthy I don't know what is. How could Claudia comment on the services provided at Spectrum if she's never experienced it first hand? If other people have attended wanted to comment on their feelings about it that's their business. Claudia also has documented proof for the quotes she provided in her comment. PTS has a counselling policy which the Board of Directors put together which is in line with many other counselling organizations in the city, social work governing bodies and the law. YSB wasn't meeting all the criteria in accordance with the policy at the time so we suspended their involvement and asked for a formal agreement (which is an absolutely appropriate request, especially for something like counselling. It's called due diligence). YSB decided they didn't want to be involved any more so they left. The "mud slinging" you are referring to are just the facts of what happened. You may not like it but it doesn't change the truth of what happened. The only reason Claudia said is because people started making unfounded assumptions that we're just trying to cause trouble for no reason on this
Kayla Miller, Ottawa ON
07/13/12 2:56 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ummmm Okay?!?
First of all Kayla - I think you should read my comment again. I don't know how it came across as me being critical of Claudia. I don't know her well, but have met her a few times, have great respect for what she dose and know well the troubles of the organization she represents. If those of you who are working in this environment are overwhelmed with the tribulations that have occurred, I suggest taking some time off and figuring your own stuff out. How in the world can the youth of our community find their way forward if the people there to help them are this distraught. At this point, it should not matter how you feel or how Claudia feels or who comes out on top. While you're all caught up in this pissing contest, the only losers are the people you're there to influence. While you're not curing cancer. You're trying to help young people in our community navigate their way through their lives. It's an important role. Everyone needs to step back, get a grasp of that picture and figure their way forward together. If you can't do that - then you should all be doing something different.
Robin, Ottawa On
07/15/12 12:08 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Clarification
Robin - I'm sorry my previous comments made it seem as though my issue was in large part to anything you said. My comments were in large part directed at Nadia. Sorry if it seemed like I was coming down on you for the comments you made. I do, however, think it was important to refer to both of you in the title because understanding the history of how we got to this point is important. In theory I am inclined to agree with you that being able to take time off of work to work through tough feelings would be awesome, but sometimes it's just not possible. We have to work through our stuff while making sure services are still being provided and running at the maximum quality we're able to provide. We moved on, this story was almost a month ago and this whole scenario happened back in January and February. We were more than happy to move on so it's perplexing and somewhat infuriating that someone would bring it back up again to contribute nothing constructive to the conversation.
Kayla Miller, Ottawa ON
07/16/12 2:02 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Good Enough Kayla...but...
We do terrible things to each other in the service of our community. It's a tough world out there. I've watched PTS grow to it's most powerful moments and seen it's fall. Claudia has done an admirable job picking up the pieces from a few years of WTF. I don't know the whole story, but it seems to me there are people making decisions more based on personal interest than on the interest of clients. From what I've read, it's pretty clear who those people are. They should be careful. The youth of this community are the most important component in this whole sorry state of affairs. It's not about who's more well endowed. It should be about recognizing where each agency can best help and spreading resources so that every angle is taken care of. Even if this happened a few months ago and people have moved on, it's disturbing that it happened in the first place. Did PTS do something wrong? Did YSB do something wrong? Someone should be pushing to find out and make certain that this is corrected. If it's not - It'll happen again. I'm making a few phonecalls tomorrow.
Robin, Ottawa On
07/16/12 11:02 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Trying to follow this
I really do not see how individuals who will not fully indentify themselves can pretend to be engaged in what they think is a professional e-exchange regarding services for youth in Ottawa. True journalism, scholarship and professionalism requires that we all know who the participants are. Only 4 people here have posted their full names. I consider all other postings to be trivial as those writing them cannot be bothered to sign them appropriately.
Ann-Marie Miller, Ottawa Ontario
07/16/12 11:37 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Some responses.
I admit, my history has been mixed in between YSB and PTS. These two service providers offer different opportunities for Queer people in Ottawa. I've hesitated to comment because, well, one doesn't like to stick one's nose in. Nevertheless, these comments... Service providers are allowed to collect information under the Personal Health Information Protection Act. Anonymity and confidentiality are completely different things, and we should all keep in mind that with our community, and our suicide rates, an emergency contact might be a lifeline that is far more real and far more necessary than in other groups. Bottom line: does PTS engage in provocative behaviour? Yes. With the Volunteer Coordinator (Kayla Miller) publishing a post in late April accusing YSB staff of misconduct on Facebook, the statement being supported by the ED, provocateering is difficult to challenge. Is there competetion? Yes. Funds are short. Also, there is dispute about what serves youth best. PTY has been around for over 20 years, and it's served a generation, including myself, very well, thank-you-very-much. Is there room for other services? Let's see. I'm curious what happens when there are options for youth growing up Queer--and I think choice for youth is a meaningful and helpful opportunity for growth. To Jean: anonymity is a funny thing. It allows people to survive blowback when they may not professionally be able to speak to a topic. In some circumstances, a person may hide their identity to prevent serious consequences for the disclosure of their opinions. I'm sure we've all seen this happen. To Claudia: "there is no reason to duplicate a service that already exists and to do it in a way that is arguably unsafe and unhealthy"? As PTS's Executive Director, you are far from unbiased. As a community leader, how dare you suggest that pluralism is "unsafe and unhealthy"? If you could act in an objective manner and cut the politics, perhaps the communi
Stas, Ottawa ON
07/17/12 11:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Continued responses
If you could act in an objective manner and cut the politics, perhaps the community could benefit from leadership, rather than suffer from sectarianism, at PTS. "Cyber-bullying": Garbage. From one end of the post to the other, garbage. It isn't bullying, it's editorial comment; and it does nothing to services for youth in Ottawa except perpetuate a discussion. How lovely that you'd like to shut it down in favour of a uniform set of opinions. Kayla: Really? The Board of Directors put the counselling policy together? That's interesting. Very interesting. I remember writing it. Odd, right? I'm sure I'm misunderstanding.
Stas, Ottawa ON
07/17/12 11:39 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.