New head of human rights museum sparks controversy
WINNIPEG / Long-time Tory has voted against gay rights
Kaj Hasselriis / National / Friday, September 18, 2009
Share |

IT'S WHAT'S INSIDE THAT COUNTS. The $265-million Canadian Museum for Human Rights is being built in Winnipeg, where it is slated to open in 2012.
(artist's rendering, humanrightsmuseum.ca)
Stephen Harper's pick for CEO of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights is a long-time Conservative politician with a history of voting against gay and lesbian rights.

This week's announcement that Stuart Murray, former leader of Manitoba's Progressive Conservative Party, will head up Canada's newest national museum has sparked cries of protest across the country.

"I'm outraged," says Daniel Voth, a political science student at the University of British Columbia. Voth sent an email to academics, politicians and friends urging them to take action against Murray's appointment. "I hope people make a stink."

"His voting record concerns me," says Jennifer Breakspear, the executive director of Vancouver's queer resource centre, Qmunity. She is also a member of the museum's content advisory committee, which is conducting public roundtables across Canada. "I look forward to meeting him and asking him about his record and where he stands now."

Murray was leader of Manitoba's official opposition from 2000 to 2006, when the NDP government introduced legislation to extend pension and adoption rights to same-sex couples. He opposed both measures.

Murray answered questions about his political record during an interview with a CBC Radio show in Winnipeg. When asked about his party's stand against same-sex adoption, he said, "That was a caucus decision that we made. I don't have an issue with that personally." But he refused to say whether, if given a second chance, he would vote the same way.

Asked whether he agrees that same-sex couples should be entitled to equal pension rights, he answered, "As a private citizen, I do."

Murray recently served as CEO of a hospital foundation in Winnipeg. Prior to entering politics, he was CEO of Domo Gas.

The $265-million Canadian Museum for Human Rights is being built in Winnipeg, where it is slated to open in 2012. Following the outburst over Murray's appointment, the museum issued a statement declaring that he would "welcome the opportunity to meet with representatives from the LGBT community to a meeting at their earliest convenience."

Helen Kennedy, executive director of queer lobby group Egale Canada, says she has already been in touch with the museum to schedule an appointment. Egale is part of a group called Friends of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, along with several other rights organizations across Canada.

Kennedy says Murray's appointment "came as a big shock" and says she's "very disappointed" to hear of his voting record. But she looks forward to meeting him.

"We have some serious questions that need to be addressed," she says. "We agree with the concept and the initiative [of the museum] but only if LGBT rights are going to be included."

Lorri Millan, one of the lesbian mothers who fought for same-sex adoption rights in Manitoba, says she's "baffled" by Murray's appointment.

"There's no merit," she says. "He was a marginal leader during his time and he doesn't reflect any diversity. He's not a curator and he's not a director. I can't see it as anything other than a cushy appointment for a long-time Tory."

Millan points out that Manitoba's NDP government doesn't deserve much praise for its role in the same-sex adoption debate, either. She and several other couples had to sue the government before it introduced a bill in the Legislature.

"No one came out smelling rosy in that situation," she says. "Everyone played hot potato with the issue."

Breakspear believes that Murray's political past is a concern. However, she adds, "we all grow and change and learn and that is why I'm holding back on being more critical."

She is convinced that the history of queer rights will be represented in the museum, and doesn't feel that Murray's appointment will do anything to change that. "It does nothing to shake my conviction and passion in this museum and what we're working for," she says.

This weekend, the museum's second-in-command, chief operating officer Patrick O'Reilly, will be the keynote speaker at a fundraiser for the Vancouver resource centre run by Breakspear.

During his interview with CBC Radio, Murray also said, "I want to introduce myself to the LGBT community. I want them to get to know me. I want to get to know them." He and O'Reilly have agreed to sit down for an interview with Xtra.ca next week. (READ THAT INTERVIEW HERE)

The Canadian Museum for Human Rights is holding a series of public consultations across Canada. For a schedule, visit humanrightsmuseum.ca.

At a press conference announcing Stuart Murray's appointment, the Winnipeg Free Press asked the former PC leader about his gay rights record. Watch the video below:




Share |


Reader Comments


 
Human Rights vs. Stuart Murray
when asked about himself Stuart Murray says "..what you see is what you get". I looked and listened and I don't see much of a human being there, don't hear much about human rights, and beyond bafflegab there's not much substance to what he says, so I guess if 'what you see is what you get' in Stuart Murray we are not getting much of anything at all, and nothing pertaining to human rights. With all his talk about differences of opinion, one wonders if he understands the basic concept of HUMAN RIGHTS? Appointing Stuart Murray to this position is just wrong.
irene miller, toronto on
09/19/09 10:51 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Stuart Murray-I was following orders.
As a gay male of 61 I am surprised that a museum that declares itself tobe one on the struggle of human rights would have as its head Stuart Murray. Would any survivor of the Nazi concentration camp Jew or Gay accept Murray's explanation for his behaviour. "He said Friday —that at the time, he was following the wishes of his caucus and his constituents." I thought that the Nuremberg Trials disallowed "I was only following orders." defence. The appointment of Stuart Murray should be the concern of any supporter of the Human Rights struggle. Lets hope saner rational minds we appoint a truly valued individual who has a history of supporting human rights. Will the Canadian Museum of Human Rights with the appointment of Murray turn the museum into an mockery.
Graham Brown, Vancouver BC
09/19/09 4:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Just another damn Tory....
Tory is as tory does. I've said it before, and I'll keep saying it. The Tories cannot be trusted to run this country, and to appoint a hard-line Tory to run a human rights museum is like getting the Klan to run the Diversity Project. Every person of good conscience should send the message to Harper: We don't want a bigot running the human rights museum! Better yet, support the Liberals and NDP in the next election!!
Kieran Earles, Mount Pearl Newfoundland
09/19/09 7:53 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Human Rights
I'm certainly gratified to see that the trustee for the museum felt the need to clarify that human rights can be subject to the whims of your constituants.....let's all vote to put men with comb overs in concentration camps....a comb over is a choice BTW....a bad one but still a choice....LOL
Tom Attwood, Vancouver BC
09/19/09 11:34 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Never forget or doubt it
As someone who has been asked to share my story with the Museum this is a most interesting development. People can change I'll give anyone that but I am still suspect to this appointment. My ex used to say "i love you" never forget or doubt it. I figured to say afterwards....that he meant no matter what I try to do to you in the future, how much i lie about you or how much I attack you or try to ruin you and steal what is rightfully yours. My claim here is that gay rights are just too damn important to let the helm be driven by someone who has failed to prove himself worthy to date. Let's see, who has the deepest pockets to keep this guy in power?
Mr.H, cal ab
09/21/09 7:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.