Human Rights Vigil goes ahead
ACTIVISM / Capital Pride and Gay Men's Wellness Initiative partner together
Noreen Fagan / Ottawa / Wednesday, August 25, 2010
Share |

UPDATE 5:30pm AUG 25: In a media advisory sent by Bauer it was announced that Capital Pride and the Gay Men's Wellness Initiative are partnering together to celebrate the queer communities' achievements in human rights.

The human rights vigil will take place at the Human Rights Monument on Thursday, Aug 26 at 8pm.

Speakers will include David Hoe, first executive director of the AIDS Committee of Ottawa, Helen Kennedy, executive director, EGALE Canada and Jeremy Dias, director and founder, Jer's Vision.

UPDATE 3pm AUG 25: Ottawa police have withdrawn their speaker at tomorrow's human rights vigil, Staff Sargeant John Medeiros confirms.

Medeiros says that he and John Byers will spend tomorrow dealing with the RCMP after two men were arrested on terrorism charges in Ottawa today. The hate crimes unit needs to move into high gear to deal with possible Islamophobic reactions in Ottawa and to help the city's Muslim community deal with fallout, Medeiros said.

"It's rather serious and urgent," says Medeiros.

He says he regrets the appearance that the police's withdrawal is an 11th-hour backpedal ("It's not," he says) and that he and Byers hope to watch the vigil as spectators, although they might be late.

*


Organizers appeared locked in a stalemate on the eve of the city’s queer human rights vigil, planned for Thursday, Aug 26.

The vigil, organized by Capital Pride, is set to include Detective John Byers from the hate crimes unit as one of the guest speakers.

A number of community groups have been agitating to tone down the police’s presence at this year’s Capital Pride Week after queer, health and social services groups expressed concern over the handling of a high-profile HIV-nondisclosure case.

Byers is scheduled to speak at the vigil alongside Helen Kennedy, executive director of Egale Canada and David Hoe, a leader on HIV prevention by people living with HIV and the first executive director of the AIDS Committee of Ottawa — both of whom have refused to speak if Byers is allowed to address the crowd.

Brent Bauer of the Gay Men’s Wellness Initiative and Hoe have written letters to the Capital Pride Board expressing their concern over the inclusion of a member of the police at the vigil.

“I urge you to reconsider your position and demonstrate leadership by denouncing the policy and practices of the Ottawa Police Services in regards to HIV transmission, and its commitment to the use of discriminatory language and exposure, and to state your support for a health and human rights base in  responding to HIV - an epidemic in Ottawa still largely impacting gay men,” writes Hoe.

Pressure has been mounting for the police to open communication channels with Ottawa Public Health and affected communities for a health and human rights solution to future handling of HIV-nondisclosure cases. Although there have been internal debriefs on the police handling of the case, police chief Vern White, in his comments to the media on July 26, continues to support the police actions.

Last week, two of the three gay charities set to receive cash from a police Pride Week fundraiser announced that they would refuse the money, citing the HIV criminalization debacle.

Bauer has been a leading force in trying to get the police to open dialogue with the queer community. But, according to Lauryn Kronick, the media relations coordinator for Capital Pride, the vigil is about opening dialogue.

“We are just trying to open up a space for dialogue. That is why it is so difficult from our position to ask someone not to speak, because, in that way it is not allowing a space for dialogue, and it is not letting the police hear what the community has to say,” says Kronick. “We are actually really glad that this messaging is coming out because we want to create this dialogue and have the community and the police in the same space to talk about this.”

The Capital Pride Board was to have had an emergency board meeting on Monday, Aug 23 to discuss its position on the vigil. According to Kronick they were having another discussion on Wednesday. Kennedy, who is based in Toronto, is still waiting to hear back from Capital Pride.

In the meantime, a letter has been sent to various community groups in Ottawa urging them to come to an alternative vigil to be held at the Human Rights Monument on Thursday at 8pm. The letter asks communities to “make the vigil ours and show our stand on human rights.”

Bauer has also sent Capital Pride an alternative agenda that includes Jeremy Dias, director and founder, Jer’s Vision as one of the speakers in place of Byers.

Whatever decision Capital Pride makes, there will still be a vigil held at the Human Rights Monument — the question remains, will there be two?


Share |


Reader Comments


 
It is a shame
It is very much a shame the hypocrisy that is coming from the GLBTQ community in this matter. People are crying out that it is wrong to judge the HIV+ man before his trial, yet at the same time they judge the police on their actions before they even know the facts of the case. I encourage everyone to read my comments on the article "Is Pride isolating itself?". People seem to forget that the police department's hands are tied right now. The judicial process prevents them from publicly releasing more information to show the community what they knew when they made the decision to release his photo and name. Would this uproar still be there if the community found out that the suspect confessed that he was on a mission to infect every gay man in the city? What if the police knew he had contact with hundreds of those men and the suspect wasn't cooperating on identifying them all? I don't know what information the police had at the time, but I will wait until all of the facts are public before I judge the police force. I hope members of the GLBTQ community can turn themselves around and start to lead by example by demonstrating the very behaviour that they are asking from the Police.
Jason, Ottawa ON
08/25/10 5:06 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
a DAMN Shame!
I couldn't agree more with Jason. Boycotting events just because the police will be speaking only serves to show more division in our community. The Police liaison committee meetings are open to the public. If you have an issue, take it up with the people you're angry with. Don't let our community fall apart.
geo, Ottawa ON
08/25/10 8:51 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Disgusting
I'm so glad I'm not living in our Capital city any longer, now I live in the Conservative Oil driven Alberta with discriminatory legislation which allow Gay Family Status Charter Challenges to come from for GAY FAMILY RIGHTS IN CANADA. Case Management Fl01-01406 is precedent setting, guiding legislation on Sept. 2, 2010. Two Gay Men Family with child MUST be protected otherwise Canada gets thrown back years into regression with respect to GAY RIGHTS. Thanks to everyone who made this possible so far. It could not have been done without your unrelenting resolve to care for the BEST interests of our child and family. Help would be appreciated now, as I am self representing after over 4 years of 100% direct opposition with oil exec ex. Man, if I lived in Ottawa Glebe area still I'd be more than just starting precedent setting cases, I'd be raising holy hell...Good Luck Helen Kennedy and others. Good to see people sticking up for their Charter Rights and Equal/Fairness in system. love & respect for all, Proud Positive Papa
DH, Calgary Alberta
08/26/10 12:59 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Either have the cake or eat it.
Intentionally spreading HIV is a public health issue, it’s wrong, and it’s criminal. Those who do it should be held accountable and the police are just doing their job. The members of the ACO will undoubtedly use the Detective’s withdrawal from the event to slam the police, but I wonder who they will call if they ever are the victims of a crime or assault. You can’t have it both ways, my friends.
Rick Mybals, Ottawa ON
08/26/10 11:10 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Hmmn?...
Syphilis, HEP-C and other std's that virtually guarantee death should also be included in manslaughter cases. These people should be arrested and jailed immediately.
Tom, Toronto Ontario
08/26/10 12:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
re: Tom
Hi Tom, I agree with your statement fully, although I suspect there was an air of sarcasm in your comment. My point is not limited to HIV. If any person with a deadly or debilitating disease that is transmitted sexually knowingly deceives a someone to having sex with them, than that person has committed a crime. No person has the right to put another human being intentionally into a dangerous situation without that person fully knowing what the situation is and consenting to being put into that position.
Jason, Ottawa ON
08/26/10 6:27 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Hypocrits
Where have the blowhards from ACO, etc. been when all of the heterosexuals have been processed for the same crimes? The ACO is not there just to protect Gay Men's Rights. If this man was consciously having sex with people without disclosing his HIV status, he committed a crime. Deal with it. Ottawa police should let the community know that there are people out there prepared to selfishly infect you with a terrible disease. Period. Never mind your self-obsessed nonsense. If what they allege is true, he had unprotected sex with an 18 year old,(and others). From what we've heard, this kid got romanced into giving it up raw for a handsome guy that said he was clean. Justifying this selfishness takes us back decades. We're not back in 1980 people. We're living lifetimes with this disease, but there is a thing called personal responsibility. If you're gonna be a douchebag liar just to feel the skin of a twink - be prepared to deal with the consequences of your selfishness. No homoactivist is going to convince this fag that it's cool to fuck a kid when I know that I could have a serious impact on the rest of his life. If I had my choice, I'd never wear a condom again. Whether I'm POS or not, I'd never make that decision for someone else by coersion. If it's true, he's worthy of all the shit that has come his way and I hope he has many years with a target on his back for his stupid decisions. But it is him alone that is responsible for them. Not the police for beating him at his game. If this teaches POSguys out there to be more responsible, even better. But for those Mary's that think that this is an assault on someone's personal rights - I'm sorry. You give up those rights when you infringe on someone's elses. The evenagalists must be having fun with this one.
OttawaMo, Ottawa Ontario
09/01/10 12:02 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.