Censor sex, censor community
HEALTH / Transman blasts health centre's decision
Jen Lahey / Ottawa / Thursday, November 08, 2007
Share |

NOT ACCEPTING NO. 'We're very proud of our sexuality,' says Peter Dunnigan.
(Karen Rodgers)
A local trans man says that a recent decision by a community health centre to limit its display of trans-specific sexual health literature is just another blow to him and his community.

According to Peter Dunnigan, the Centretown Community Health Centre sent a strong message when it decided not to display 'Primed: The Back Pocket Guide for Transmen & the Men who Dig Them' in public areas of their facility. The guide offers information and frank advice about safer sex for gay trans men. The centre, whose representative declined to be interviewed for this report, previously told Capital Xtra that the images in the guide, including the pair of naked bums on the cover, were simply too racy.

However, in a recent letter to Capital Xtra, CCHC executive director Simone Thibault wrote that "CCHC staff have been informed of the availability of this resource. We have posted several posters throughout the centre explaining that the guide is available at our reception desk and on the website queertransmen.org."

That means anyone who wants to get their hands on the guide onsite must still approach a stranger and ask for it, an experience which may intimidate or embarrass some.

"In terms of this brochure, what insults me is that it's not just about my ass," says Dunnigan. "It's about saying to the gay and lesbian community and the transgendered community, 'We accept you, but it comes with conditions.' "

Dunnigan adds that he feels like he is being told that he, and other transgendered people, somehow make others uncomfortable.

"Part of the gay and lesbian transgendered community is very sexual, it's part of our being, we're very proud of our sexuality. So when you put a condition on our sexuality you're actually putting a condition on us."

Dunnigan says that one reason he feels so strongly is that the creation of a sexual health guide for trans men is a huge step for a community whose members he says often feel invisible and ignored.

"This is the first time that trans men have ever, ever been acknowledged in Canadian history. Think of it, on this level: this is huge. This is not minor, this is huge. That means my community has an opportunity to get information to have safe sex. We have arrived, only to be insulted. For arriving? There's something wrong with that."

Sexually frank messaging has been a touchstone of AIDS prevention work in the gay male community for 20 years. From the outset, gay men have insisted that safe sex material reach audiences "where they're at" — no matter who it made uncomfortable.

And transgendered people need access to solid sexual health information, because, like other groups, they're at risk for sexually transmitted infections such as HIV, says Adam Graham, the gay men's prevention coordinator at the AIDS Committee of Ottawa.

One reason for this risk is the lack of access to safe, affordable sexual reassignment surgery for those who want it. Additionally, safer sex equipment such as condoms are not adaptable for the needs of the trans community, which leaves trans men with less choice for protecting themselves in risky situations.

"We know that there are certain medical facilities that are a little bit more friendly for the lesbian, gay and bisexual communities," says Graham. "But when a trans person goes in there and drops their pants and wants to have a test, then where's the guarantee that the medical personnel who are working there are going to understand the situation and be friendly to that situation? We have no idea."

"There's not a real push to train some health practitioners on some of the things that socially determine our health. Definitely trans-friendly services are not even on the menu at this point, which is really unfortunate because we know that not offering those services has a direct correlation with increased rates of HIV and other STIs."

But with scant research into trans men's health, it's hard to say for certain just how at-risk trans men are. But Graham says that there is a flurry of socioeconomic factors that affect the trans community in greater proportion, which in turn likely increases the risk of HIV/AIDS.

"We know that stigma and discrimination lead to higher rates of things like drug use, mental illness, depression, all that kind of stuff. So we know that when people are in a situation like that, they may take greater risks, which might mean not using a condom, that might mean all sorts of things," Graham says.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
ACO has failed the trans community
why is ACO speaking for the trans community. I've asked for 6 1/2 years why they have no services for the community. I've been given no adequate answer. you can't represent those you don't understand or provide any services for. this is not about transman. it's about the community of transman and women who are not represented by the tax payers dollars. that is a crime-shame on ottawa
Peter Dunnigan, gatineau Quebec
11/08/07 9:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Our Leaders Need a Leason In Equality
Transgendered citizens have the same equality rights under the Ontario Human Rights Code and the Charter as any other minority groups. There is no such thing as a hierarchy of minority groups. Yet from my observation they have no services and are disregarded even by other minority rights groups. I don't get this. I recommend that members of this community complain directly to the boards of these program and then to the city department that funds them if the discrimination contiues. And if this does not resolve the issue then file a human rights complaint or a charter challenge.
Jane Scharf, Ottawa Ontario
11/09/07 8:27 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
the crushing weight of seeming indifference
I want to congratulate Peter Dunnigan for coming forward to speak to CapX about this important issue, and to congratulate CapX for showing leadership in challenging CCHC on its suppression of this very important, groundbreaking information resource for trans men and their lovers. I also want to commend Adam Graham of ACO for his contributions to the matter via his comments in the CapX story. My own sense is that ACO is now getting quite earnestly up to speed on and engaged with trans sexual health issues. I am currently trying to generate some interest on two local trans lists in favour of organizing a protest and lobby/pressure actions to resolve this unacceptable behaviour by CCHC, and if need be, the filing of a human rights complaint. Response at this point is utterly, crushingly, very disappointingly...silent (save for my partner and I.) Where is the outrage amongst trans people on this issue? WTF?
Shannon Blatt, Ottawa Ontario
11/09/07 6:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
where are all the transman and the community
where are all the transman in the city? I know they exist because I seen many on gay sites here. I've met many in the community. Silence kills guys!As far as the rest of the community. well, that is why we don't have any services and toronto is thriving!maybe, I'm in the wrong city? to shannon - thank you! I will support you on this issue and any others to come. you can e-mail me at crowfeather60@hotmail.com I invite anyone who shows an interest to e mail also. cheers
Peter Dunnigan, gatineau Quebec
11/09/07 10:43 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Representation
I agree with Peter's comment that it is a complete injustice that there are no adequate health services available in Ottawa that reflect the needs of trans men in our community. Furthermore, I absolutely agree that ACO has failed and is currently failing to provide appropriate services to the trans community. We have started a consultative process in order to draft a set of policy points on how to start the process of making our services and social environment accessible on the basis of gender identity and expression. Again, this is a new process for ACO and I sincerely apologize if my comments in the Capital Xtra article were read as speaking on behalf of the trans men's community. Indeed, I work in public health and HIV / AIDS so when I speak of health outcomes related to any population, my comments are always related to epidemiological evidence that affects a certain population. There is dangerously little research both on the pure epidemiology of HIV and STI transmission amongst trans men as well as the social situations that determine trans men's health. I agree with Peter that this is very much related to our various governments' (federal, provincial and municipal) complete inaction on trans health research and service provision. That is criminal - and we know people suffer poor health outcomes because of it. That said, there is a growing body of research on trans health coming out of the Ontario HIV Treatment Network (www.ohtn.on.ca). Their research conference is happening this week and it might be worthwhile checking out some of the presentations when they're available online. ACO is only starting a formal process of ensuring a physical, social and policy environment that is respectful and affirming for trans sexual and trans gender people in Ottawa in full consultation with members of those communities. We have a great deal of work to do to make our services genuinely accessible and we invite the community to continually challenge us in that
Adam Graham, Ottawa Ontario
11/16/07 11:42 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
THANK YOU ADAM GRAHAM
To Adam Graham (ACO) Thank you for your honesty, integrity and sincere acknowledgement of the lack of services for transman but also the transgender community. If we added up all the people who died from HIV/AIDS from this community in over 25 years then you can see my need for care to just be care not gender specific.this virus has no boundaries and yet in terms of funding it has!My question is why do we need to focus on gender/sexuality because HIV/AIDS doesn't.May GOD bless those individual that died without the support and care needed just because they were who they were. To me that is humanity failing humanity.YOU CAN'T CHANGE YOUR BEHAVIOUR UNTIL YOU CHANGE YOUR BELIEFS.When we will understand that we are a family of the universe and we need to take care of our brothers and sisters.your honesty opens the door for dialogue and resolution. thank you Adam
Peter Dunnigan, gatineau Quebec
11/16/07 10:06 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.