Can't we treat HIV like any other disease?
GUEST COLUMN
Michael Burtch / Ottawa / Friday, November 30, 2012
Share |

I’d like World AIDS Day 2012 to be about more than a discussion of criminalization or the complexities of dating with a communicable disease.
 
These are pressing issues for those of us grappling with HIV, but these examples tend to overshadow the far-reaching implications of a positive test result.

Instead, consider how it affects our relationships with family. What it’s like to have a two-year-old niece you’ve never met because your sister is afraid you’ll give her child AIDS. How it limits our job opportunities. How it can be more difficult to find a family doctor or a dentist. The humiliation of being loudly denied a tattoo in front of a shop full of strangers because of your status. The frustration of applying for the Ontario Trillium Drug Program by snail mail and scrambling to collect supporting documents when your medical coverage at your job runs out or fails to cover the full cost of your $1768.21 monthly bill for life-saving medication.
 
Think about how angry you’d feel if you had a secondary sexually transmitted infection and went for treatment at Public Health only to be given a hard time about your sexual practices and shamed for remaining sexually active after your diagnoses. This year, I want the conversation to be about all these kinds of individual slights, grievances and stresses that appear to be superfluous, superficial wounds, but viewed wholly, can show how some HIV-positive people slowly bleed to death.
 
On Dec 1, testing, HIV in a global context, and the hope for a vaccine will most likely dominate discussions, but not the pervasiveness of stigma in the lives of poz folks. And as we struggle with all the ways stigma affects our daily lives, how much credit will we be given on World AIDS Day recognizing our resiliency? And how accountable will HIV-negative men and women be for perpetuating stigma?
 
If you’ve ever used the word “clean,” for instance, to describe an HIV-negative person, congratulations: you’ve succeeded in making my life a little more difficult. You’ve quite frankly made having HIV that much more exhausting and depressing.
 
Faced with the conundrum of the chicken or the egg, doctors don’t know yet if HIV causes depression or having HIV makes you depressed. What we do know is that prevalence rates for depression in people living with HIV is estimated to be as high as 45 to 60 percent, with HIV-positive women twice as likely as men to be depressed.
 
Depression can mean oversleeping, overeating, problems concentrating, low sex drive, fatigue, loss of appetite, problems adhering to medication, feelings of hopelessness or guilt. For some, like my friend Christopher, it looked like him loitering on a bridge at 3am contemplating jumping.
 
At a point in time – now – when HIV is a treatable chronic condition, preferable to diabetes, how is it that the stigma surrounding this disease has remained so bad it’s driven some of us to take our own lives? The answer, of course, lies in how pervasive stigma is.
 
I don’t want our daily struggles as poz folks to be presented here simply as deterrents for contracting HIV. That’s not the point. Every situation I’ve mentioned could be abolished with easier access to treatment and education. That’s the point. Dealing with HIV could become just about focusing our energies on stomaching doctor appointments, blood tests, the side effects of medication, and opportunistic infections. You know, like any other disease.
 
  
Read More:


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Changing times
I can't say enough good things about you Michael, I think you have courage, make sense and speak well. I've had HIV now for well over 20 years. Is it easier now? Maybe in some ways yes, maybe not in others. I will say , how often disappointed I am in the HIV community. Yes , some of the issues you describe are real and are a problem. You know what else is a problem, the sense of entitlement that plagues the HIV community. Refusing to take responsibility of choices. You and I both know people who still party hard on drugs, that don't want to bother developing skills or even work. You and I both know that there toxic drama within certain OSA's and it is getting worse... not better. There are way too many HIV organizations in Canada, spread thin, all doing different things. I partied a lot at one time, did a lot of drugs and that's how I got infected. I was careless and irresponsible and for so long I told people that I was a victim. Things changed, now I have a good job, really good insurance, I don't party anymore, I don't stupid things anymore, I don't act like an ass thinking I can do whatever I want without consequences. Like you I was depressed, but I was just as depressed before my diagnosis, it got medicated by other means. the world of hiv is now part of the real world, where every man is for himself. We can turn a blind eye and pretend....we live with a chronic disease, some need more help then others, but we need to take responsibility.
pozreality, ottawa on
12/01/12 10:29 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks Michael
It should very much be like any other disease but it's NOT. The Supreme Court of Canada has made sure of that! We are now a persecuted minority, and criminalized! If every other communicable disease was equally criminalized then great, but it's not. After many years in the AIDS community it is my contention that a slow death is exactly what is being strived for as you so eloquently described it as "HIV-positive people slowly bleed to death". I beleive it is intentional and there are many people who are colluding with both the persecution and our slow death and they are hiding behind facade in plain view. Do you think that if all those working in the HIV industry are working for our benefit? If they were, do you suppose 30 years on we would have gone backwards rather than forward? Who do you think are REALLY promoting this persecution and stigma? Think about it.
whatever, hatetown isolation
12/02/12 8:10 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks
Michael Burtch, I just want to say thank you for such an insightful, personal and powerful article. You just enlightened me on some of the issues and for that I am grateful. I'm spreading the word!
Larkin, Kamloops BC
12/05/12 2:21 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
AIDS Inc. Continues to Alienate The Rest of Us
We, the HIV negative majority in the gay community continue to watch in astonishment as AIDS, Inc. and its motley collection of careerist ASO bleeding heart activist types do everything in their power to keep HIV infection rates high. Your political agenda is a nauseating mix of victim-baiting and alienating politics that drives away mainstream gays. Dude, get over the word "clean". It's been used in the medical context for years. ("The toxicology report came back clean", "Chest x-ray is clean", "The drug test is clean" etc. etc.) Deal with the fact that negative guys are not interested in you. Do I whine about personal ads that say "No one over 30!" No, I accept who I am, just as you need to get over it.
David, Montreal QC
12/20/12 11:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
An idea for an HIV-prevention campaign?
The column indicates that author needs to rely on government support to pay his monthly costs of $1768.21 for anti-HIV drugs. Perhaps that would make a good HIV prevention campaign: Stay HIV-negative or you'll be facing $2,000 per month in drug costs for the rest of your life.
Tim, Toronto ON
02/12/13 11:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.