Trans woman seeks refugee status in Canada
REFUGEE / 'I only ever felt strong enough to transition here,' says Tanya Bloomfield
Simon Thibault / National / Wednesday, August 04, 2010
Share |

Tanya Bloomfield got a handwritten note this week: "We do not want to lose you!"

This is why she is fighting to stay in Canada.

Bloomfield — born in Crawfordsburn, a small coastal village in Northern Ireland — is in bureaucratic limbo. Her application for residency has been denied. She has applied to stay as a refugee, fearing that if she were deported, she — as a trans woman — would face violence and abuse upon her return to Northern Ireland.

In October 2006, Bloomfield and her partner left Northern Ireland for Chester, a small town outside of Halifax. The couple married in Nova Scotia, and Bloomfield soon applied for spousal sponsorship for permanent residency in Canada. It was in Chester that Bloomfield found a chance to be herself.

"I only ever felt strong enough to transition here," she says. "I'd lived in the UK and Northern Ireland, but I'd never felt comfortable, except for here."

She says she felt truly accepted in the rural community when she first walked into her local liquor store, dressed as Tanya for the first time. She laughs as she tells the story. "I felt I needed to say something, and I said, 'This is who I really am. They said, 'Yeah we figured, that's cool.' At that point I knew it would be fine."

After splitting with her partner in early 2009, her spousal sponsorship application was terminated. Bloomfield was able to stay in the country on her current visitor's visa, but in August 2009, she missed the deadline to renew.

"I was working with Halifax Pride, and it was Pride week," she says. "I was so busy, I didn't know what day it was. I didn't realize until it was too late that I was no longer under visitor status." This gap in her visa was the beginning of her problems.

Tanya Bloomfield
Because of the gap, Bloomfield had to apply to restore the status of her visa. She also applied for a temporary residence. But she says those applications were somehow lost by Citizen and Immigration Canada. Worried at not hearing anything back, Bloomfield tried to get in contact with them.

"We rang, faxed, emailed them, and we got no response," recalls Bloomfield.

Frustrated by the lack of communication, Bloomfield filed a new application in March, asking for temporary residence as well as a work application. The missing paperwork, however, would prove to be a problem.

On July 29, Bloomfield and her lawyer, Lee Cohen, walked into the Halifax offices of Citizen and Immigration Canada. Television cameras and microphones were waiting outside for the pair as they emerged, where they told the media that Bloomfield's applications were denied, as she did not meet the criteria. She was also asked by Citizen and Immigration to sign a voluntary departure order, which would force her to leave the country by the end of August. She refused and applied to stay in the country as a refugee.

"People have sent me research and statistics, which are compelling, about abuse that queers deal with across Europe," she says.

Since moving to Canada in 2006, Bloomfield has forged connections to the Halifax queer community. She is on the Halifax Pride committee, and she works with trans youth at a local queer youth resource centre. She also runs her own business — a computer repair store.

Bloomfield says she has found not only a place to call home but a place that beckons for her to stay. She says that every day she receives phone calls, emails and personal visits from well-wishers, telling her they want to her stay and wondering why she would have to leave.

One card she received this week said, "I can only help by letting you know our thoughts are with you."



Share |


Reader Comments


 
Flimsy and laughable
Ridiculous. Refugee status isn't about 'feeling comfortable.' I live in Oshawa, and it isn't always 'comfortable' as a queer person. As a resident of Northern Ireland (which I can imagine isn't a great place to be trans) she's a citizen of the United Kingdom and can apply for a passport which says "European Union" on it. Or am I missing something? Hell, I'm happy to have her here, it's not personal, but I really find this kind of sloppy abuse of refugee system undermines its credibility. There are opponents of our generous refugee policies seizing on this as we speak. Edinburgh? Fucking London? No? Did nobody ask her those questions? Give me a break. This is squarely milking the refugee system and undermining it. Just for being a stupid cow, she should be tossed out on her ass. How dim does she think we are? This is an insult to genuine refugees, who desperately need the system we have in place and don't need it undermined by someone who clearly hasn't done their homework. Bad 'sob story' journalism. Execrable.
Alain, Oshawa ON
08/04/10 7:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Is this a joke?
If one's life being free of transphobic violence and abuse - in the UK, no less - was dependent on getting some paperwork in on time, wouldn't you maybe afix a sticky note to the fridge that said "get paperwork in on time or face life of unimaginable transphobic violence"? I think you'd find a way to focus on the task at hand. Please don't hand the right fluff stories like this - they live for stuff like this.
Alex, Toronto ON
08/04/10 8:01 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
level presentation
This isn't any kind of 'sob story,' it's actually a very level presentation of the facts. Yes, you can criticize this woman for missing the renewal deadline (she should have been more careful) but obviously she is a productive member of society here so it seems like it wouldn't be that big of a deal to work something out in her case. I'm sure they make exceptions all the time.
Sav., Toronto ON
08/04/10 8:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Contribution? Huh!
This is the very dictionary definition of a sob story. Missed deadlines, sympathy seeking in the media, fuzzy thinking. Anyway, it's not the real issue (whether she'd be a productive member of society) although I'd even argue with you there, someone who can't remember to file a piece of paper while claiming their fucking life depends on that very claim the paper is related to is not going to make a valuable contribution to this society. Jesus H. Valuabe contribution. The real issue is whether she's a refugee, which is the basis of her claim. And it is a big deal if she's scamming the system or bringing it into disrepute (which I doubt will happen because she's be tosse out on her ass). It's a total sob story. A 'very level presentation of the facts' would have included asking the question: why not Glasgow or London or somewhere in the EU? It would have inquired into the patently false and alarmist idea that a wave of anti-queer violence is sweeping not just Northern Ireland but the entire European continent. She's telling us that she forgot! Was real busy, forgot. That just doesn't add up. This is barely a news item, never mind a refugee claim with an iota of credibility. She should get in line with other immigration applicants, those whose claim is based on making a contribution, and not try to undermine the credibility of a system that thousands of genuine refugees from violence depend on each year - whose lives actually do depend on getting safe sanctuary here as we are required to do under the Convention to which we are a signatory. Preposterous. Like Alec said it hands ammo to enemies of our refugee system. Let's not supply that to them on a silver platter.
Alain, Oshawa ON
08/04/10 9:11 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
There is more to the issue
There is more to the issue that is not always obvious. Some of it is outlined here: http://dentedbluemercedes.wordpress.com/2010/08/04/ns-advocate-seeks-refugee-status/ Hate crimes against trans people have been visibly rising in the past while, in a country that has a strong history of religious attitudes being enacted in violence (and in this case, both religions are in relative agreement). As for legal protections, the more we're finding out more about the ironically-titled "Equality Act," set to go into force in N. Ireland this October, the more we see that it actually entrenches trans people as a specified class, but one in which rights are deliberately removed by law through exemptions, clauses and rhetoric, rather than ensuring protections. (That legislation is written in such a way that someone only has to prove that they might lose clientele or that their clients would be uncomfortable having trans people present, in order to be legally justified in firing / not hiring them.) So is she in the kind of danger she would have been if she were from Uganda? No. Does she have a case? It's reasonable, and I hope so. Plus, if she can win her case, it would significantly help to bolster those of LGBT people seeking refuge here. So it's definitely worth supporting her.
Mercedes Allen, Calgary AB
08/05/10 12:00 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Here comes the loony left...
Here comes the loony left to defend this queer non-refugee. This is not a refugee in any sense of the word. Go back to Ireland and get behind all the thousands of Irish that have applied to immigrate to Canada and wait you turn. Same goes to all the Mexicans, Gypsies, Filipinos and every other bogus refugee that is trying to play us. Deport! Deport! Deport!
ron, Vancouver Bc
08/05/10 12:47 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bullshit, bullshit, bullshit.
It doesn't bolster other lgbt people seeking refuge here because she doesn't have a case. End of story. Amsterdam and other European cities are nearby and if there was any merit to it she would have sought refuge nearby. Let's call this what it is. She wants to move to Canada. She didn't get her act together, on the flimsiest of excuses and now she's inventing a refugee claim. It's an insult to kids from Sierra Leone who have had their hands cut off, or escapees from Liberia or Rwanda, or Kosovars who faced mass killings of men and boys, or even people fleeing drug violence in Mexico. It's utter bullshit, and though I'm not surprised, I'm disgusted that people are supporting this charlatan.
Ahmed, Toronto ON
08/05/10 8:25 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
This is a country of immigrants.
Ron, I wish you'd go back to wherever you came from. It's far too easy for idiots to forget that no one other than the First Nations has been in Canada for more than a little over 400 years, and even the First Nations came from somewhere else. What makes you think you're any more entitled to this land than anyone else? It's rather telling that you use the term "Gypsies", an ethnic slur, in your list of people who, according to you, have no legitimate claim at refugee status. Are you really that ignorant?
Scott, Fredericton NB
08/05/10 11:38 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wow, such hate.
Alain: Tanya has contributed greatly to our country and because of this, it is our responsibility to step up and ensure we support her in her time of need. No one forced her to run barefoot across the bridge to raise money for the LGBT community, or start a business and hire local people in support of our community in Chester. She did her part, and now, Canada, we need to do ours. Otherwise well end up stuck with selfish jerks who sit around not contributing anything BUT they can fill in a stupid bureaucratic form on time. Bigotry is not welcome in MY Canada.
ryan, chester ns
08/05/10 1:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yup, here come the accusations of bigotry.
Ryan, she might indeed make a great immigrant, and as such, she should apply through immigration channels - as I did. Having run in bare feet doesn't make her a refugee. Being a nice person doesn't make her a refugee. Preferring a nice town with fresh seafood doesn't make her a refugee. Her attempt - and yours - to subvert the refugee system is disgusting and even worse is the sloppy thinking and accusations of bigotry by people like you, just because we don't want a valuable refugee system undermined by people who invent violence after the fact to make up for their own incompetence. This isn't about bigotry - I have trans-people in my family. It is about lies and blatant attempts to subvert a system that brings thousands of deserving folks into this country every year. Homos and trans people from Uganda - yes. Homos and trans people from fucking United Kingdom? No, no, no no and no. No. Never.
Alain, Oshawa ON
08/05/10 1:38 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Offensive, Ryan. Really offensive.
Ryan says "Otherwise well end up stuck with selfish jerks who sit around not contributing anything BUT they can fill in a stupid bureaucratic form on time." So that's the two choices? Tanya the Saint or selfish jerks? That's your campaign strategy? Wow. You don't think much of Canada's immigrants, huh? Despite being able to fill out forms, my parents arrived poor and worked hard to provide for their family after moving here. They aren't selfish jerks. My mom does PFLAG stuff and my dad provides dental care to needy families in Canada's north and teaches environmental education in his spare time. So your categorization of them is offensive. That's called a false choice, Ryan. You guys are going to have to do better than what we've seen so far. The arguments in favour have been weak on the verge of obscenity. Don't insult my family and accuse others of 'bigotry' you fucking asshole.
Cato, Hamilton ON
08/05/10 1:48 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yes, contributions!
Alain, before you claim that Tanya Bloomfield will contribute nothing to our country, step back and look at what she's already done since she came here in 2006. Many Canadian citizens have done far less (probably yourself included), and I for one am honoured to have Tanya in my province. We need more people like Tanya, people who are willing to give their time to our community, whether it's as an organizer of Halifax Pride, as a facilitator of what is probably the only support group for trans youth in the Maritimes, or running a marathon barefoot to raise money for MCC Safe Harbour's work with the LGBT community. To those of you who think trans women don't face persecution in Ireland? Your privilege is showing.
Pat, Halifax NS
08/05/10 1:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Come on now
That's not privilege Pat. It's logic. Refugee status isn't about contributions, it's about the need to escape violence. Your fuzzy thinking is showing. "People have sent me research and statistics, which are compelling, about abuse that queers deal with across Europe," she says. This would make a great story, Xtra. Ask Tanya to share this with you and let's get on it. It's Germany 1933 all over again! If we need to start avoiding Paris, Amsterdam, Berlin and Barcelona to avoid violence, you should be getting the word out. Queer get bashed here too and just last year Xtra had some whining transexual refugee talking about how awful Canada is so it is no nirvana. I don't see bigotry Ryan (okay, maybe Ron!) just a lot of anger over being asked to believe this big steaming mound of bullshit. I don't like bigots either but let's not give them ammo. If we're going to make exceptions for people let's make them for those who come close but fall a little short. Not for those who don't have a leg to stand on.
Ellena, Toronto ON
08/05/10 2:04 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Three questions for Pat.
Pat says "Many Canadian citizens have done far less (probably yourself included). Three questions 1) how would you know? 2) Even if true (which it isn't) how is that relevant? 3) Really? That's your campaign? Is this the best you can muster, mocking and taunting people who ask legitimate questions about the veracity of a claimant? Do the work. Don't plant a story in our media and expect that's all it takes. Make some compelling arguments about the violence and why Canada is her only or best option for a European national.
Alain, Oshawa ON
08/05/10 2:10 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ignorance is bliss?
Alain, if you're that ignorant of the violence trans people face, I feel sorry for the trans people in your family. They certainly do not have an ally in someone as ignorant as you. Also, before you accuse Tanya of lying and inventing violence to justify her claim, consider that a) you have no proof of this and your comments qualify as defamation of character and b) you don't know what violence Tanya has already faced in Ireland.
Pat, Halifax NS
08/05/10 2:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Missed the point
Ellena, you totally missed the point. Trans women face far more violence than gays and lesbians, yet those who are not trans have the privilege of not having to be aware of this. If you're such a fan of logic, read what I wrote and respond to what I said instead of warping it to mean something else.
Pat, Halifax NS
08/05/10 2:18 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Answers
1. I don't know, nor do I claim to. Of course, you know next to nothing about Tanya Bloomfield, but unfortunately, that doesn't stop you from making unfounded accusations about her. 2. If Tanya's contributions to Canada are irrelevant, why claim that she will make none? Do you have some interest in attacking her character? 3. What are you even talking about? I'm not planting stories in the media, I had nothing to do with getting this article published, and this is not my campaign.
Pat, Halifax NS
08/05/10 2:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pathetic
This whole campaign is sadly misguided. If you want your friend to get Canadian immigrant status do your work. Don't try to abuse our refugee system and insult us when we ask some needed questions. This isn't going to work, seriously give it up it's pathetic.
Cato, Hamilton ON
08/05/10 2:33 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
What makes someone worthy of being a citizen?
I was lucky enough to be born here. If someone like Tanya is willing to work very hard to prove her loyalty to our country and misses filling in a form by a few days, we should cut her some slack. Maybe she didnt miss anything and the people at canada immigration are really just discriminating. I have no idea. All I know is, filling in a form by a certain date is a stupid qualifier for citizenship. If a person comes here, demonstrates a commitment to the betterment of our nation, they deserve every chance we can give them to stay. We are here, in a nation that controls a totally disproportionate percentage of the worlds weath. WE are not entitled to what we have here, we just have it due to good fortune. We need to treat people like Tanya with respect as guests and if they want to stay, extend them a welcome. If it makes you feel good to be a jerk to Tanya on this board because someone peed in your cornflakes...well F U. Im a Canadian citizen and I have every right to come here and support my friend.
ryan, Chester ns
08/05/10 9:27 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
That's it. I've had it with you lot.
For the love of god, This isn't about worthiness to be a citizen. That's called IMMIGRATION. Time after time you people are too thick to get that. Fucking learn to read! It's about her NOT BEING A REFUGEE. She's a FIRST WORLD REFUGEE CLAIMANT! A bogus one! A liar! If you're a refugee, you don't need to be a good citizen - you just need refuge. From violence! If you're an actual refugee, you aren't rambling on about walking around in bare feet - you're talking about the violence that drove you from your home. This entire little campaign is riven with dishonesty and reflects badly on all who are participating in it. There isn't a bit of honesty in any of this. And you know what, if you want to move to my country, expect to do some paperwork. That's not much to ask. I'm going to write to the minister and ask him to deport her pronto. Normally I wouldn't have given a shit, but this is beyond the pale and you people are pissing me off. I'm going to make that my MP knows that this little tantrum is not being waged IN MY NAME. Not in my fucking name. Oh, and she's a mentor? That's real scary. Just for that, I'm writing the letter tonight. And I'm telling everyone I know to do the same. That's your comeuppance for being snivelling little bitches.
Alain, Oshawa ON
08/05/10 9:44 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Not 2 convincing 'n 2 bad about that
Guess them clovers ain't so lucky. SOme of the commence seems a bit harsh but theres no real evidince here and she did apply for regufie status after she tried every thing else so it kind of looks sneaky and not very believalbe. sorry but thats true. Too bad. Maybe she can try to be an imigrant. It worked for millionso f Irish people before, what's one more, but yeh I think you should only use the refugie system if your a refugie. My church helps refugies and they kind of stand out as needingthe help but Tanya i think just wants to move to Cnada. Totally u nderstandable cause itz a gr8 country but sometimes you have to go through the steps Tanya lot of hurting people in this world your white and you live in a rich country thins aint that badd come on babe! Chin up. Appy again because you can totally apply again after a perid of time of wating. Best, Dom.
Dominic, Woodbridge ON
08/05/10 10:35 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Alain??
Dude, I get your POV that you disagree with her case, that's fine although I sit on the other side of the issue... but where is all that bitter anger coming from? I get that you think there should be no exceptions to the rules (although I would emphasize... the immigration authorities bend the rules all the time, it is nothing that special), but you sound downright hateful about it. You don't really believe this little story in Xtra is going to have any significant impact on Canadian national immigration policy, do you? Because if you do, you're really overestimating the importance of this story or how much people are going to pay attention to it. If they bend the rules for her, she stays, we'll never hear about it again. If they don't bend the rules, she'll be off to Ireland, unhappy and disappointed for sure (and though fault of her own, I acknowledge), but again we'll never hear of it again. It doesn't even affect you... the idea of getting so worked up about at it as to actually invest emotions into it and invest work into undermining her case suggests a lack of anything better to do in your life. The rest of us are standing up for her just out of a common identity... true that not everything should be determined by identity, but at least we have a rational self-interest in standing up for her... I am a trans woman and I would hope that others would do the same for me under similar circumstances. But you have no rational self-interest in working against her... you're just acting out from some weird bitterness you have built up about immigration policy, or trans people or the writers of this story or something, I'm not sure what.
Sav., Toronto ON
08/05/10 11:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Don't be patronizing
The rest of us are standing up for her just out of a common identity... " Thanks, Sav. Finally someone told the truth. Please don't be patronizing. That is the oldest trick in the book - suggesting that someone's point of view is the manifestation of mental illness or discord. It isn't. It is a problem when someone plants a story and then expect the rest of the community to just get on board. Hey, didn't you recently have people trying to deny your right to self expression? I don't recall accusing your heterodox views as being the result of 'mental illness'. Do me the honour of not deleting my agency by calling it bitterness. I don't get out much - AIDS will do that to you. I don't need anyone else questioning my mental faculties. I have social workers for that. Why don't you just engage with my points and leave my mental health diagnosis to those who can deal with it? And since when is asking for evidence hateful? Dude?
Sav?????, Oshawa ON
08/06/10 12:07 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Nah no wayh
I've met that bitch she's agianst the Jews. fuck her. Her is a fuk,in bithc I hate her the biths fukr fukr furkr
Tam, Toronto ON
08/06/10 2:15 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
patronizing??
Alain (I assume that is you), if you're going to start hurling around insults and degrading language, you really aren't in a very strong position to complain when someone makes the mildest of responses. Let's compare some of what you wrote... "Fucking learn to read! It's about her NOT BEING A REFUGEE. She's a FIRST WORLD REFUGEE CLAIMANT! A bogus one! A liar! ... Not in my fucking name. Oh, and she's a mentor? That's real scary... That's your comeuppance for being snivelling little bitches." with what I wrote: "the idea of getting so worked up about at it as to actually invest emotions into it and invest work into undermining her case suggests a lack of anything better to do in your life." So you go around calling people you disagree with liars and "sniveling little bitches" and you attack this woman's personal character, and yet when someone makes the very _mild_ comment that you might try to find something better to do with your time, you act so wounded. Whatever dude, I have no way of knowing your personal health status... if you don't want to deal with questions about your personal character, then I suggest you refrain from making far more egregious attacks on the character of others.
Sav., Toronto ON
08/06/10 3:13 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Actual refugees live through hell
http://www.refugeestories.org/stories/
Gendra Hallachic, Stoney Creek ON
08/07/10 12:17 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
oppression olympic victim whiner winner
Oh Jersuz frickin' Keerist! Is this a joke? Do "trans" people really think anyone is buying their bullshit any more? The whining wiging victim self-obsessives are a crashing bore. But they are all being murdered as we speak. We ALL are these days fuckheads. Get a bloody grip!!! Send her to Dublin and watch her end up in chains.
boo the fucking hoo, toronto ON
08/07/10 1:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Facts
@ Tam, Thats defamation I hope Xtra shares Tanya's lawyers your IP address. @ the hate speakers, wow so much hatred, so much lack of respect, a queer magazine with readership like you they do not need. You say Tanya hasn't experienced violence or been at risk in N,Ireland. Tanya has survived an assasination attempt of her and her family by the IRA, Tanya was raped by an ex employer, Tanya was also attacked and hospitialised, left with a badly broken nose and head injuries. This is only a small piece of the life Tanya has had. There is alot more.. So you hate speakers, wise the fuck up and support a member of YOUR community.
Fluffy Bunny, Halifax NS
08/08/10 5:21 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
the end of queer
Trans people are not MY community. You are your own community. You have played the victim olympic trump card too many times. You've lost your "allies" with your bullshit. Good luck on your own. You are correct about Xtra -- as a Queer Trans publication it should censor and silence any gay or lesbian people who critique the Queer Trans Tyranny.
not my community, toronto ON
08/08/10 10:55 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Option for Tanya (an attempt to be helpful)
This comment isn't in response to any of the above comments it is directed at Tanya who I hope will read this. I'm originally from Halifax but haven't had the pleasure of meeting you. It looks like you've done a great deal for the trans community in NS and wonderful work with Halifax Pride. I would like to tell you about Transgender Equality Network Ireland. They are based in Dublin and they are currently hiring for a position which from the article I think you might be perfect for. It pays up to 50,000 Euros which is approx. $68,000 canadian dollars. The posting is here http://www.activelink.ie/node/2991 or http://www.teni.ie/ The deadline for application is Aug. 20th. I realize you want to stay in NS however, if you are unsuccessful at least you could help to make a difference in the Irish trans community. As you know Northern Ireland and Ireland (the republic of Ireland) are quite different. My partner and I recently just spent our anniversary at Dublin pride and were impressed by the friendly welcoming community. Also one of the SPARs on Granville St. in Dublin serves Tim Horton's coffee which was nice since we've been away from Canada for a year. As someone on a UK visa I understand the importance of meeting renewal deadlines. I must renew in 1 year and 2 months or I will need to return to Canada to reapply. I personally don't agree with your use of the refugee application process as you do have the right to reside anywhere in the UK and EU. Transphobia/homophobia are present in Europe however, transphobia/homophobia are still present in Canada as well. If you are required to leave Canada and reapply from the UK/EU this might be a wonderful opportunity for you to continue working with the trans community. I wish you all the best. I'm not trying to tell you to "go back to Ireland." I just wanted to make you aware that your expertise & experience could provide you with the opportunity to help fight transphobia in the UK/EU until
Canadian on visa in UK, Bangor UK
08/08/10 1:59 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Enough
not my community: As you are not MY community. You were never allies to begin with. I have seen more hate for transpeople from gays and lesbians than from all the straight people in the world combined. We would be (and would have been) far, far better off without you. In short: fuck you.
Juniper, Laputa Ontario
08/08/10 2:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
*sigh*
Sadly, this is exactly what the heterosexual, cisgender world wants us to do. Turn on each other... the greater the anger and bitterness, the better for them, as it makes us easier to control.
Sav., Toronto ON
08/09/10 10:01 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
leave us and go -- please!
Jupiter -- good -- dump the fags and dykes who hate you and move forward without us. What's the problem???
sick of trans victim's homophobia, toronto ON
08/09/10 9:55 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Gladly
No problem with me, but it's a big job convincing everyone else. I wish they'd listen. Hopefully listening to you rant will change some minds.
Juniper, Laputa Ontario
08/09/10 10:54 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Good luck
I wish her the very best but I must agree, as I did when the news was reported here in the UK, that this is not an asylum claim. The fact that she is from Nothern Ireland doesn't mean she has to live in Northern Ireland. She is entitled to live anywhere in the UK - as well as anywhere in the EU. I do hope she can get her situation sorted and manage to remain in Canada if that's where her life is, but I'm against people abusing the term "asylum". There are people who really live in terrible conditions: they are the ones the asylum system is for.
Val, London UK
08/11/10 12:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Not asylum case by any means.
Sav, I talked to a representative of the 'cisgender' heteronormative community the other day and they confirmed, and I quote, "we don't give a fuck." Opposition to the abuse of the refugee system is based in transphobia in the same way that criticism of Israel is always based in anti-Semitism. In other words, not necessarily, and appeal to the good nature of most people by crying discrimination eventually becomes crying wolf. Val above has captured my sentiments exactly. She could move to fucking London. What's stopping her?
Chris P., Toronto ON
08/13/10 2:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I get it
Chris P, let me emphasize my last comment above had nothing to do with the asylum case per se, I just find it disturbing that people are willing to tear each other to shreds over this, talk about divorcing the LGBT community etc. over this stupid case. Again, I repeat I can understand if someone disagrees with this case... but please do it without calling each other names and talking it up like it's the end of the world for this woman to get asylum. I happen to stand with her just because I want others to stand with me in similar circumstances. But that having been said, this case is not incredibly important. I acknowledge that. It's not the end of the world one way or the other. So whoever disagrees with me, go ahead, just please do it without the fucking name-calling (towards the woman, myself or otherwise).
Sav., Toronto ON
08/13/10 2:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Good thread
Alain et al. - you rock Send me your pic. You sound hot. "Canadian on visa in UK" - hahahaha
Jim, Toronto Ontario
08/13/10 9:41 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Jim?
Jim, General Delivery, Canada? Seriously? Come one! I am hot but that's not the point. Or is it? Thanks for the laugh!
Alain, Toronto ON
08/19/10 2:54 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
the children's hour
this is exactly what the heterosexual, cisgender world wants us to do NOT! Are you 15 and living in your parents' basement listening to goth music and reading conspiracy novels??? Those het cis world people are everybody in your fucking life idiot! There is no giant Us and Them except in your paranoid trans mind. Grow up! Accept the fact that trans ranting has so vilified gay men that most of us have responded with a fuck you! Live on your hormone island of victimization and get drunk on your whine whine whine.
so over it, toronto ON
08/19/10 8:51 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Hotel Canada
This is not a refugee as would be recognized by the UN conventions pertaining to refugees. Certainly no EU country would recognize a refugee claim from this person. This is simply someone who likes the neighborhood in Nova Scotia where they are residing and is attempting to immigrate through the back door with a bogus claim that they face discrimination in the UK because they are a trans person. In fact the UK is one of the easiest places in the world to get SRS covered by medicare and its big cities are quite trans friendly. Canada and especially Ontario have a long history of persecuting trannies both directly and indirectly and treating them as potential sex offenders. A trans person from Canada and especially from Ontario would be able to get refugee status in the UK and certain other countries based on the systemic discrimination which they face here. This is basically just another opportunistic person who wants to check into Hotel Canada courtesy of the local taxpayers. They should be repatriated to their homeland ASAP. Also, there is the little issue of who exactly is a true transsexual. Clothes do not a woman make. A large number of trannies are actually autogynephiles who are basically otherwise normal straight guys who just like to wear women's clothing and affect a female body image while otherwise living a straight man's life completely equipped with the usual male jewelry. This person certainly seems to be basically an advanced cross-dresser. I have an idea. Anyone who wants to claim refugee status in Canada on the basis of their alleged transsexuality should first be assessed by the wonderful sympathetic friendly folks at the CAMH Gender Identity Clinic in Toronto and if they are found to be less than trans then they should be promptly deported. Alternatively perhaps Tanya should return to the UK and get SRS and lose his litte male jewels) and thus prove his/her transsexuality and then return to claim refugee status.
Yours Truly, Toronto Ontario
08/31/10 3:04 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.