Toronto police stumped in Skinner and Magill murders
CRIME / 'Investigations very much alive,' says Blair
James Dubro / Toronto / Thursday, May 20, 2010
Share |

More than 1,000 people marched from Church and Wellesley to Adelaide and Victoria streets on October 25 in memory of Chris Skinner. Skinner was murdered on October 18. Police say they have no leads.
(Matt Mills)
Toronto Police chief Bill Blair told a crowd at a community meeting on May 4 that police have no new leads in two unsolved gay murders.

Chris Skinner was beaten to the ground and crushed to death under the wheels of an SUV at the corner of Victoria and Adelaide streets in the early hours of October 18, 2009. Despite several eyewitness accounts and a series of CCTV pictures taken of Skinner and the suspect vehicle in the moments before the attack, the assailants have not been identified.

Speaking at a town hall event at the 519 Church Street Community Centre, Blair sombrely noted that the more than $100,000 of reward money offered by police and the Skinner family has not turned up any new leads so far.

“Sometimes you just need one call, which might break the case wide open,” said Blair.

Blair acknowledged that Skinner “may have been killed because he was a gay man.” It’s an important acknowledgment. Amid suggestions that Skinner may have been targeted because he was gay, lead homicide investigator Stacy Gallant told the media in October that Skinner could have provoked the attack after he came in contact with the SUV as it sped past him in a construction zone.

“There was a lot of construction on Adelaide,” Gallant said. “[Skinner] may have been walking in the roadway and bumped into the car and they may have taken offence to that.”

Gallant subsequently released CCTV of the moment Skinner was supposed to have come in contact with the SUV, but nothing in the video suggests that is what happened.

Blair did not raise the somewhat bizarre traffic-dispute motivation, which many gay people found unbelievable. But he did add quickly that Skinner’s sexuality was only one possible motive.

Blair says police are also stumped by the July 14, 2008, stabbing death of 64-year-old interior designer Ross Magill. Magill was attacked in the doorway of his apartment near St Clair Ave and Yonge St.

Blair said progress has been made in the Magill investigation, that “some suspects have been identified,” but that police do not yet have enough hard evidence to charge the suspects.

There has so far been no reward offered for information leading to Magill’s killer. But, Blair revealed, he has not received a request from homicide investigators to offer one. Blair said if the “homicide investigators thought this would be a useful investigative tool,” he would almost certainly grant the request. 

Blair said that both the Skinner and Magill murder investigations are “very much alive.”


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Justice for Chris Skinner
Toronto's homicide squad is pretty incompetent. Granted they don't get much practice compared to their colleagues in comparable U.S. cities (but they sure get paid as much!). There's been enough time for them to go door-to-door to the owners of every black SUV in the province by now.
Paul, Toronto ON
05/20/10 5:03 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Lots of unsolved murders of older gay men
The Skinner and Magill cases are just the tip of the iceberg. I understand that, over the years, there have been a large number of unsolved murders of homosexual men. The victims are usually older men who had habit of picking up hustlers or people on the street. Most of the deceased were found dead in their apartment after being beaten to death. There is usually evidence of robbery at the murder scene. Although neighbours will tell police that they often saw young, scruffy men going to (and coming from) the victim's apartment, they didn't see anyone on the date of the murder. If the apartment building had security cameras, the police can't identify any suspects from the tapes. Although the media may run a story when the victim's corpse is discovered, they rarely follow up. The police file ends up being a "cold case" and the murderers are never brought to justice. A gay investigative journalist should do a story listing all the unsolved murders of homosexual men in Toronto in the last 30 years. If a crime show wanted to make episodes dramatizing each murder, they would have a lot of episodes to air.
Doug, Toronto Ontario
05/20/10 8:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Open season and we are the game.
The murders of gay men in Toronto (or any large city) is a sadly under-reported crime, unless there is some kind of tardy sexual angle, real or persieved. The older man who frequents sex trade or the young stud out clubbing are not all that different in their bloody ends. If the media can somehow make their sexuality a contributor to their deaths, then the "storey's got legs", if not well then it's just another murder in this aging city. Some of us find resonance in these murders beyond simple numbers. We might have known the victims if only in passing, by sight. We know the addresses, we lived there or had friends that did or still do. We go to the same gyms, clubs and resturaunts, share a doctor or stylists. We have seen the victims and they are us! So forgive us if we greive a little longer, hold out hope or just appear too brought down by yet another murdered man after another and another. It's always 'open season' folks, no license required and there are plenty of game, like fish in a barrel pick you target and gently squeese the trigger, pull the knife or aim you car. We need more rally's, more vigles, more public grieving to show people our sadness and out rage! We will not be held down or held in our place. We will scream and cry in the faces of those who might kill us or those who just don't care. We will chant the names of our friends who go before us in the hopes we do not follow. We will pump up and stand up for ourselves and our little ones just comming of age. We can't let the next generation see this as normal, it is not normal it is outrage and murder. This situation is never acceptable, never the norm. We will not go quietly into that deep night bur kicking and screaming all the way until justice is done and seen to be done. So grab hands and butts and tango down yonge street and onto the front pages. We deserve the attention, we need the attention to see what is right, done. there is no peace in the ghetto tonight and there should
Stephen D. Buckle, Hamilton ON
05/22/10 6:55 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Did TO police check their own vehicles?
Did TO Police check their own undercover SUVs at the time of this murder? Likely not.
Ben D, Dover On
05/24/10 6:42 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
........
@ Paul "There's been enough time for them to go door-to-door to the owners of every black SUV in the province by now." Do you suggest they do this (use up valuable manpower)for every crime victim? @ Doug "The victims are usually older men who had habit of picking up hustlers or people on the street. Most of the deceased were found dead in their apartment after being beaten to death." It would appear there is a problem with homosexuals killing other homosexuals. Do homosexuals have a higher propensity for violence? @ Stephen "The murders of gay men in Toronto (or any large city) is a sadly under-reported crime, unless there is some kind of tardy sexual angle, real or persieved." Any proof to substantiate this? If they weren't murdered because of their sexuality, then why should it be reported any differently? "If the media can somehow make their sexuality a contributor to their deaths, then the "storey's got legs"," When you are killed by a homosexual prostitute that you picked up on a street corner, bar etc. then yes your sexuality is a contributor to your demise. You earlier complained that it goes unreported, now you complain when sexuality is mentioned and relevant? "if not well then it's just another murder in this aging city." Are you suggesting that the murder of gays are not as investigated as any other? I'm sure the black murder victims would disagree. "It's always 'open season' folks, no license required and there are plenty of game, like fish in a barrel pick you target and gently squeese the trigger, pull the knife or aim you car. We need more rally's, more vigles, more public grieving to show people our sadness and out rage!" Is the out rage because you think it's heterosexuals that are the suspects? Would you still feel this outrage if you find out that most of the killers are homosexual? I'm curious, how it was
StraightPride, Toronto Ontario
06/05/10 7:09 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
.......continued
I'm curious, how it was concluded that his sexuality played a role in his unfortunate death, when by all appearances this seems to be a brief, random encounter?
StraightPride, Toronto Ontario
06/05/10 7:16 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.