The risks of being bisexual
NEWS / CAMH's Risk and Resilience study seeks bisexual participants
Bradley Turcotte / National / Saturday, July 28, 2012
Share |

In our community, gay and lesbian individuals sometimes forget there is a “B” in the blanket acronym used to describe queers. Many bisexuals say they are often marginalized by the notion that bisexuality doesn’t exist and is just a stopover on the route to gay-town.
 
With this in mind, the Risk and Resilience study has been launched by the Re:searching for LGBTQ Health team in conjunction with the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH).
 
The goal of this community-based research is to uncover how prevalent issues such as depression, addiction and anxiety are in the bisexual community; look at what support services exist for bisexuals; and explore what types of discrimination those who love both genders experience.
 
The Risk and Resilience study was born from pilot research compiled by Dr Lori Ross’s Re:searching for LGBTQ Health team. Ross’s study conducted semi-structured focus groups with 55 bisexuals around Ontario and highlighted the impact biphobia and monosexism (the belief that someone can be attracted to only one gender) have on mental health.
"Who wants to pay for an hour with a psychologist where 40 minutes of that is taken up trying to explain what bisexuality is?" Dr Margaret Robinson, project manager of the Risk and Resilience study, asks.

Ross’s study found that in addition to discrimination, people who identify as bisexual report that they often receive sub-standard care from health-service providers and that they are constantly told they are not actually bisexual.
 
“Someone might go to a counsellor for depression and get told that if they accepted that they were really gay or lesbian, and not bisexual, then their depression would go away,” Dr Margaret Robinson, project manager of the Risk and Resilience study, says. “Family members didn't always support bisexuality, even if they were gay-positive, and same-sex partners pressured us to identify as gay or lesbian.”
 
Robinson has helmed the Risk and Resilience project since 2010 and is bisexual herself. She says that people have accused her of being straight and pretending to be bisexual for attention.
 
“Having to fight constantly, just to be who you are, really wears you down,” she says.
 
Robinson brings years of queer experience to the project. She has previously facilitated the Bi Women of Toronto group and the Toronto Bisexual Network. In addition, she has coordinated the Dyke March and helped organize the ninth International BiCon, and she is a director of the Toronto Bisexuality Education Project.
 
“That experience helped me assemble a great advisory committee for this project. We've got 11 bisexuals from around Ontario whose experience and advice have guided the project through every stage,” she says.
 
One such member of the advisory committee is notable Ottawa drag performer Zelda Marshall. Marshall became involved with the Risk and Resilience study after completing and promoting the Trans Pulse Project survey and was then asked to join the advisory committee for the current study.
 
“When I am feeling particularly provocative, which is most of the time, I tell people in fact that I identify as a ‘GB’ -- greedy bitch. Yes, I want it all, including the freedom to love either sex,” Marshall says with a laugh. 

“Even today, I still have friends who swear me to secrecy when they come out to me as bi,” Marshall says. “Hopefully, this survey, and particularly awareness of the interest of the needs of bisexuals as being distinct from either heteros or homos, will reduce some of that stigma.”
 
Robinson admits that within the queer community a stigma exists against the CAMH. This negative opinion of her employer is something she says she frequently encounters when conversing with queers; however, the partnership with Re:searching has somewhat alleviated the presumption that the CAMH isn’t working for the benefit of the queer community.
 
“This isn't a case of outsiders coming in with a bunch of questions,” she explains. “This is insider research done by bisexuals, for bisexuals.”
 
There are still plenty of spots available in the Risk and Resilience study; however, to be included, you must know someone who has already taken part. Through this respondent-driven sampling, participants of the study can recruit up to 10 other bisexuals to join the study.
 
“It's like the shampoo commercial from the '80s,” Robinson explains. “I told two friends, and they told two friends, and so on. By tracking these chains of recruitment, we can weigh the data to compensate for the non-random sample. So our results should be true for bisexuals in Ontario generally, not just those who did the survey.”
 
Robinson points out that bisexual people aren’t as socially networked as the transgender community, and the recruitment chain has been slow to take off. There are 900 tickets in circulation, and Robinson encourages bisexuals who do want to participate to tell their friends they would like a ticket.
 
“Many of the people who experience the negative effects of biphobia don't identify as bisexual. So we've created a video to let pansexual, omnisexual, fluid, queer, questioning and unlabelled people know that if they're attracted to more than one gender, they can participate as well.”
 
 


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Bradley Turcotte hates himself
"in the blanket acronym used to describe queers." Gays, lesbians and bisexuals are not "queers." Take your warped self-hating language, dressed up as faux activist lingo, and go back to 1990 where you came from. Even better, just go away.
David, Toronto Ontario
07/28/12 7:50 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Trans is not a Separate Sexuality!
Bradley your article seems to take the view that the Trans community is in itself a separate sexuality! It is not!! For the umpteenth time being Trans is about ‘Gender Identity’ and has nothing to do with sexual preference! Many in the Trans community are gay, lesbian, bi or straight, and the many of us who are bi don’t usually forget that part of our sexuality!
Davina Hader, Toronto Ontario
07/29/12 1:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Redefining risk
Let's call this article the risks of biphobia, ok?
Sally Goldner, Melbourne Victoria Australia
07/29/12 5:00 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Apologies
Regarding Davina Halder's comment: I apologize if anything I said implied that trans is a sexuality. That wasn't my intention. I refer to the Trans PULSE study several times because of the similarities in the study designs: we use the same recruitment method, and a similar community based approach. Greta Bauer, who was lead investigator on Trans PULSE is also on our research team. We even modelled our new video on the one done by the Trans PULSE team. Our bisexual community advisory committee includes trans people as well as cis people, all of whom also identify as bi, pan, fluid, queer, or two-spirited. And, or course, the Risk & Resilience study is open to trans participants provided they are attracted to more than one gender. If this describes you, I hope you'll participate.
Margaret Robinson, Toronto Ontario
07/29/12 7:49 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
questionable study with hidden motive?
if the goal is to try to prove that bisexuals have a higher rate of mental illnesses than their gay/lesbian counterparts, then i am not sure what this study is trying to prove. if CAMH is looking to lump bisexuals into their paraphilic fetishist category for which they place transwomen, then i find this study to be concerning.. find something better to do with your time, like convince governments to fund trans health without involving CAMH.
Jennifer McCreath, St. john's Newfoundland
07/29/12 10:41 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
CAMH is a big place
This study has absolutely nothing to do with the GIC. There are people at CAMH doing trans-positive and non-pathologizing research. See lgbtqhealth.ca
Ayden, London ON
08/06/12 10:19 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bi Discrimination - Ottawa
Some "GLBT" groups here in Ottawa blatantly discriminate against bisexual women.
Sally, Ottawa Ontario
08/14/12 4:03 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Re: bisexual
Yes there's A LOT of biphobia and bisexual erasure in the so called LGBT "community" and a lot of it comes from gay men and lesbians. Even Xtra this website only has news for Gays, lesbians, and Trans people but no news section for bisexuals and this article was lumped into the "gay" section. WHAT DOES BIPHOBIA LOOK LIKE? * Assuming that everyone you meet is either heterosexual or homosexual. * Supporting and understanding a bisexual identity for young people because you identified “that way” before you came to your “real” lesbian/gay/heterosexual identity. * Expecting a bisexual to identify as heterosexual when coupled with the so called different gender/sex. * Believing bisexual men spread AIDS/HIV to heterosexuals. * Thinking bisexual people haven’t made up their minds. * Assuming a bisexual person would want to fulfill your sexual fantasies or curiosities. * Assuming bisexuals would be willing to “pass” as anything other than bisexual. * Claiming that bisexuality in men and women is somehow rare or does not exist as a valid sexual orientation. * Assuming that bisexual men are usually or are always closeted gay men who haven’t come out, and that bisexual women are usually or are always closeted lesbians who have not accepted their sexuality. * Feeling that bisexual people are too outspoken and pushy about their visibility and rights. * Automatically assuming romantic couplings of two women are lesbian, or two men are gay, or a man and a woman are heterosexual. * Expecting bisexual people to get services, information, and education from heterosexual service agencies for their “heterosexual side” (sic) and then go to gay and/or lesbian service agencies for their “homosexual side” (sic). * Feeling bisexuals just want to have their cake and eat it too. * Believing that bisexual women spread AIDS/HIV to lesbians. * Using the terms “phase” or “stage” or “confused” or “fence-sitter” or “bisexual” or “AC/DC” or “switch-hitter” as slurs or in an acc
J., Toronto Ontario
08/16/12 5:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
biphobia
WHAT DOES BIPHOBIA LOOK LIKE? * Assuming that everyone you meet is either heterosexual or homosexual. * Supporting and understanding a bisexual identity for young people because you identified “that way” before you came to your “real” lesbian/gay/heterosexual identity. * Expecting a bisexual to identify as heterosexual when coupled with the so called different gender/sex. * Believing bisexual men spread AIDS/HIV to heterosexuals. * Thinking bisexual people haven’t made up their minds. * Assuming a bisexual person would want to fulfill your sexual fantasies or curiosities. * Assuming bisexuals would be willing to “pass” as anything other than bisexual. * Claiming that bisexuality in men and women is somehow rare or does not exist as a valid sexual orientation. * Assuming that bisexual men are usually or are always closeted gay men who haven’t come out, and that bisexual women are usually or are always closeted lesbians who have not accepted their sexuality. * Feeling that bisexual people are too outspoken and pushy about their visibility and rights. * Automatically assuming romantic couplings of two women are lesbian, or two men are gay, or a man and a woman are heterosexual. * Expecting bisexual people to get services, information, and education from heterosexual service agencies for their “heterosexual side” (sic) and then go to gay and/or lesbian service agencies for their “homosexual side” (sic). * Feeling bisexuals just want to have their cake and eat it too. * Believing that bisexual women spread AIDS/HIV to lesbians. * Using the terms “phase” or “stage” or “confused” or “fence-sitter” or “bisexual” or “AC/DC” or “switch-hitter” as slurs or in an accusatory way. * Thinking bisexuals only have committed relationships with so called different sex/gender partners. * Looking at a bisexual person and automatically thinking of their sexuality rather than seeing them as a whole, complete person. * Assuming that bisexuals, if given the choice, would prefer to be in an
J., Toronto Ontario
08/16/12 5:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
biphobia
* Assuming that bisexuals, if given the choice, would prefer to be in an different gender/sex coupling to reap the social benefits of a so-called “heterosexual” pairing [sic]. * Not confronting a biphobic remark or joke for fear of being identified as bisexual. * Assuming bisexual means “available.” * Thinking that bisexual people will have their rights when lesbian and gay people win theirs. * Being gay or lesbian and asking your bisexual friend about their lover or whom they are dating only when that person is the “same” sex/gender. * Believing bisexuals are confused about their sexuality. * Feeling that you can’t trust a bisexual because they aren’t really gay or lesbian, or aren’t really heterosexual. * Expecting a bisexual to identify as gay or lesbian when coupled with the “same” sex/gender. * Expecting bisexual activists and organizers to minimize bisexual issues (i.e. HIV/AIDS, violence, basic civil rights, fighting the Right, military, same-sex marriage, child custody, adoption, etc.) and to prioritize the visibility of so called “lesbian and/or gay” issues. * Claiming that bisexuals somehow undermine the rights of gays/lesbians, or are not for gay/lesbian rights politically. * Avoid mentioning to friends that you are involved with a bisexual or working with a bisexual group because you are afraid they will think you are a bisexual. * Calling a relationship or marriage between two people of the same gender a gay/lesbian relationship or gay/lesbian marriage.
J, Toronto Ontario
08/16/12 5:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
bi bi blow hard
Another infuriating thing about those nasty bisexuals is that they are SO WORDY!!! Going on and on and on with their whining.
icky shmertz, Monosexualville Ontario
08/16/12 6:08 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
biphobia
Biphobia is just as bad if not worse than homophobia. I view biphobic people as being just as bad as homophobes even if they're gay and/or lesbian.
Matt, Toronto Ontario
08/16/12 11:30 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
more evidence of bi entitlement
Matt, worse? Why play oppression olympics? Another reason to find bisexuals annoying and whiney.
icky shmertz, Toronto Ontario
08/17/12 7:31 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Get it right
Thank you for this article but I can't help but be frustrated every time I read an Xtra article with false information. Aren't journalist supposed to know how to do research? It's called the Centre for Addiction & Mental Health, not the Canadian Centre for Addiction & Mental Health. It's CAMH, not THE CAMH. Further, Trans PULSE is not a CAMH project. Both of these studies however are funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research. Here are some websites you should look at to clear things up: www.lgbtqhealth.ca = Re:searching for LGBTQ Health, a team at CAMH who does LGBTQ health research in collaboration with community partners www.bisexualhealth.com = More on the bi pilot study and the bi anti-stigma campaign wwww.transpulseproject.ca = The Trans PULSE Project is a community-based research project that is investigating the impact of social exclusion and discrimination on the health of trans people in Ontario, Canada. Also, wow, I cannot believe the biphobia in the comments. Evidence that this study is needed!
N/A, Toronto Ontario
08/28/12 10:29 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Study closing soon
As you may know, the data collection period for the Risk & Resilience Study of Bisexual Mental Health is coming to a close. If you have been invited to take the survey but haven't done so yet... If you have started the survey but haven't completed it yet... If you have tickets but haven't passed them on yet... ...now is the time! This is our chance to get data about our community, and our health. Do the survey, pass it on. For more information check out the Risk & Resilience video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEJFKjDlOeo, and the Re:searching for LGBTQ Health Team's website, www.lgbtqhealth.ca. Please share this notice with your friends, networks, organizations and communities.
Margaret Robinson, Toronto Ontario
10/08/12 8:35 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The LGBTQ Health Team
The LGBTQ Health Team at http://www.lgbtqhealth.ca/team/ are mostly female. As a gay man, I prefer to deal with health care professionals who are gay men. For example, a gay man who takes my blood at a lab doesn't appear to be uncomfortable or judgmental, while women do (especially older women and immigrant women - who often remark that I must get my blood taken a lot). Similarly, I feel comfortable talking to my doctor, who is a gay man. I couldn't tell a woman the things I tell him, especially sexual matters.
Bill, Toronto ON
10/08/12 9:05 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Men in Research
I understand why you prefer to get your health care from other gay men, Bill. Especially given the homophobic experiences you describe. Like you, I've had some negative health care experiences, and wish there was more choice in providers. The Re:searching for LGBTQ Health Team doesn't provide care; we only do research. Our team changes often since research work is contract, rather than permanent. The Risk & Resilience project includes bi men on our advisory committees and our research team so that the design and the data analysis include male perspectives. I encourage any men interested in LGBTQ health research to apply for contract openings with the team, and those who are students to consider doing their practicum placements with us. Those over 16 can also volunteer for research experience.
Margaret Robinson, Toronto Ontario
10/09/12 7:36 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.