The incredible shrinking Winnipeg Pride parade
MANITOBA / Winnipeggers wonder why route is cut short
Kaj Hasselriis / National / Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Share |

There won't be any queer pride at one of Canada's most famous intersections this summer. The Pride parade in Winnipeg is being dramatically shortened, and it means marchers won't pass by Portage and Main.

"That's the focal point of Winnipeg," says a frustrated Mike Law, organizer of a popular float that's pulling out of the June 6 parade because of the change. "It's a symbolic thing."

In years past, Winnipeg's Pride parade has lasted more than an hour and headed down several big downtown streets. This year, it's being chopped down to just one street, for a total of nine blocks. The march will start at the Manitoba Legislature, continue down Broadway, then end at the Forks for a concert and business fair.

"The decision is being universally panned," says Law. For evidence of dissent, just check out Winnipeg Pride's Facebook page. Ash Lund writes, "What's up with the new route? The whole point of the Pride march is to show our pride and by shortening the route it kinda makes me think they want to keep us off the busiest street of Winnipeg." Ashley Dawn Booth adds, "This is my fourth year at Pride and the best part of it was always the walk down the great street of Portage where everyone could see us loud and proud."

As soon as Law caught wind of the change, he fired off a letter to Pride that suggested an alternate route. He got a four-point response from Winnipeg Pride chair Barb Burkowski. Here's a summary:

1) There's a Winnipeg Goldeyes baseball game happening in the area at roughly the same time, causing potential traffic problems.

Mike Law (right) and the Goldenboys Volleyball League float at Winnipeg Pride 2009. Law is pulling the float from this year's parade because the route has been cut short.
2) The Pride committee wants to eliminate as many turns as possible in the parade route because, as Burkowski writes, "the safety of parade participants is in great jeopardy when we have more corners."

3) The new route forces all spectators to gather along one street, thus making it look like the parade has more support.

4) A shorter parade route means everyone will arrive at the festival sooner and see musical acts like pop diva Deborah Cox.

Law says he was told by a Pride committee member that the local baseball team tried to cut a deal with Pride about the start time of the game, but it couldn't be done. As for the safety reason, Law feels it's "bogus." He points out that every float is required to have four trained marshalls. "What parades don't have corners?" he says. "I don't think there's ever been an incident. It's a red herring to me."

In Burkowski's response to Law, she wrote, "The board debated the options which were challenged from many directions and came to the current decision after much discussion. The permits are submitted, the insurance is set up and all systems are go for the parade as we have planned it this year. There will be no changes."

Last year, the Pride parade attracted floats for about two dozen organizations, including Law's Goldenboys Volleyball League. This year, Law says it's not worth the $800 cost of renting a truck and speakers, decorating a float and putting it on the road.

"It's really disappointing," says Law. "I hope they learn from their mistake and do a better parade route next year."

The Winnipeg Pride committee didn't respond to interview requests for this article.

2010 PARADE ROUTE: BLUE; 2009 PARADE ROUTE: RED





THE PARADE ROUTE MAY BE SHORTER BUT...

Winnipeg Pride organizers are promising a bigger, better Pride festival this year, with a new venue — the city's centuries-old meeting place, the Forks. Several musicians are performing at the site's Scotiabank stage on June 6, including Deborah Cox. The gay-friendly pop diva will also be singing that night at the official Pride dance party.

Starting May 27, there are many other events leading up to Pride Day, including a softball tournament, a roller derby and a queer spelling bee. Everything is listed in the Pride committee's glossy 64-page Pride Guide.

Well, almost everything. When Stacy Clark asked for her June 6 dance party, Queer Pride, to be included in the guide, the Pride committee refused. It said Clark's event was in competition with the committee's annual dance party (the one where Cox is performing), which acts as a fundraiser for Pride itself.

"I'm disappointed and frustrated," says Clark. "Queer Pride caters to a completely different crowd." The Pride committee's party is widely known as 'the sweaty boys' social,' while Clark's party at Lo Pub is aiming for a more female, low-income crowd. (Her event costs just $5 to enter, versus $25 for the official Pride party.)

"If Pride is a community-based organization and the Pride Guide is a community service, then everyone should have fair and equal access," says Clark. Despite the snub, she and her small team of DJs are going on with the show. Clark is now putting up posters with this slogan: "The event the Winnipeg Pride society does not want you to know about!"




Share |


Reader Comments


 
parade route
the whole point of pride is the parade. It's about standing tall and saying who we are. The shortening of the route is the ultimate conservative gesture. Thbe festival at the forks means nothing... The justification of shortening the route due to the baseball game is just so sad. That is exactly the reason we marched... to disrupt something. I was going to come in again to march, not for the parties, but really, why bother?
calvin yarush, grandview manitoba
05/26/10 10:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
shut up and have fun
you should all just get over yourselves and get out there and have a good time, that's what its all about isn't it? so the parade rout is shorter - get a life and GET OVER IT ALREADY!!!!!
brandon, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/27/10 1:56 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Poison Kaj strikes again!
I'm guess I shouldn't be surprised that someone as toxic as this "Reporter" decided to focus entirely on the negative. The VOLUNTEER Pride Committee has worked extremely hard to make some exciting and fresh changes to 2010 Winnipeg Pride. Leafing thru this year's Pride Guide, I am amzaed at what this small band has been able to pull off. Shame on you for denigrating their efforts by speaking to a few sour grapes. No event is perfect, but I'm sure this one will be a close as possible. There are plenty of events for every segment of our community thruought the week long festivities. I for one am very proud of the festival and what it means for our community. The fact that you would try to tear it down by sensationalizing a few aspects really saddens me. I sure hope you're planning on staying home that day to have a good sulk.
Trevor, Winnipeg manitoba
05/27/10 2:20 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Shut up and have fun???
ok to the person who said shit up and have fun, you said get out there and have a good time, thats what its all about isn't it? Well to let you know thats not what its all about its about a political statement! Its about getting in peoples faces about it and showing your proud of who you are and that you are not scared to say so and your not going away even though they would like us to shut up and keep it to ourselves!!! So for your little statement of "get a life and GET OVER IT ALREADY" shows me you don't have a clue what pride is about and you need to educate yourself or let us educate you!!!
Kevin, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/27/10 2:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Winnipeg Pride Rocks!
As the main critic quoted in this article, while I do stand by all my remarks about the parade, I want to assure everyone that I think the pride committee has done an amazing job on absolutely every other aspect of Winnipeg Pride. While my group decided not to put in a float this year, for the reasons already stated in the article, I will be a participant in the parade and I will be a very enthusiastic attendee of the Deborah Cox-anchored festival.
Mike, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/27/10 3:53 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Stay home and sulk
kevin should def stay home and sulk on pride day he sounds VERY hostile and angry.
brandon, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/27/10 4:39 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Haha.
The corners reason makes me laugh. Nice that they are concerned for our safety and they don't want us to have to take as many turns, but you'd think they'd know as gay people we feel much more comfortable when we don't go straight.
Brett, Vancouver British Columbia
05/27/10 11:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Alternative route?
While I don't often agree with Mr. Hasselriis, I can't help but feel there is a lot of truth in this article. As a long time Pride attendant and more often than not very active participant, I do have some issues with the alternate route. First off, the baseball game...... who has HUGE personal interest in the team and stadium and who ultimately has the power to approve the parade route? Oh yes, you know who..... I wonder why the Pride committee chose Broadway? I've been on floats of all sizes, driven floats of all sizes and can honestly say that turning from 3 lanes onto 4 lanes is not really a hassle, or a "sharp" turn! If they really are so concerned about sharp turns (never been an issue in 23 years but I digress) the initial turn onto Broadway from the Legislature will be the worst as it will be very tight, with crowds of people and parked cars. And have they considered the right turn from Main onto York? TIGHT! How about going under the tracks onto Waterfront Drive? LOW! Hope there are not too many high floats. Years ago they changed the route to go through Osborne Village and down Stradbrook. Was this not an option? They could have gone straight through onto main and right into the forks! I used to love seeing all the people in the Village! FUN! And as for making it to see the musical act... I have had to take down many floats, return them to the rental place, part the vehicle and still made it in time for the musical act. The Parade should be about being out, loud, and visible, being seen by people who may otherwise not be exposed. It really won't do anything being hidden away on Broadway. So sorry Pride committee, I won't be putting in a float this year. Was going to be a first for my friends business, but we decided nine blocks of Broadway isn't worth our effort...... or the $150 registration fee.
PJ, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/28/10 12:13 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Cry me a river
If you're GLBTTQ* and the biggest concern in your life is "the parade is too short" then WTF - must be a nice life! Be grateful people...
Chalie O, Winnipeg MB
05/28/10 3:53 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
"Get over it" ?
I wasnt going to weigh in on this, as for some, pride IS political, for some it's not. Yes the pride committee deserves credit for its hard work - noted. The route is an issue for some people, and they have their reasons - noted. I'm not getting into that. What I find offensive is the "get over it" responses. Never forget people paid for our freedom, some with their lives. We still live in a world where that freedom does not exist for many and even here there are people who cannot assimilate. I always hope that Pride lets someone who feels isolated know that there is a place for them where they can belong. That's MY reason, I try to respect others reasons. If for you Pride is a party, great. If for some though it has a deeper significance, try and respect that.
Trevor Thorkelson, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/29/10 4:37 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
useless excuse
That the former route had too many corners to navigate is pure unadulterated bullshit. Just look at the map of the new route, it conveniently ends at Main and York disregarding the two-three extra corners of very narrow streets it takes to get to the heart of the Forks (unless you're planning to hold the party in the parking lot), which is more corners than the former route. And as one commentator wrote what about the rail bridge at York? If you have a tall float you're screwed. Frankly I'm not surprised at the meekishness of the organizing committee. They like the Winnipeg community in general lack balls in anything to promote the community. Look at the abandonment of Happenings Social Club, the first and longest operating gay club of it's kind in North America, in favour of Desire, a straight-owned and predominately straight-staffed gay bar that was resoundingly homophobic.
former winnipegger, toronto ontario
05/31/10 11:53 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A Discreet But Deadly Comment
So being a person employed in the entertainment field that's heavily involved with Pride, I decided to stay anonymous due to fear of retaliation. And YES, as sad as it may be, retaliation is as common as hypocrisy in the community. I chose to finally pipe up & add my 2 cents because this is starting to look like a joke nowadays. Everyone is ready to point fingers, yet when the time comes, nobody steps up unless it involves taking credit for something. Instead of blaming people, why not try to help correct these things? I agree that the shortening of the parade is plain ol' bull. BUT instead of telling people of how bad of a job they are doing, why not step up and try to do better? Plain and simple people, stop making excuses and MAKE RESULTS!!!
Senor Mysterio, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/31/10 1:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Hypocrisy
Not to mention the constant bickering between the male and female factions of the gay community. Lesbians demanding female exclusive events BUT expect to be allowed to the male exclusive events. Makes me remember Miss Purdies & why it went bankrupt Hypocrisy!!!
Senor Mysterio, Winnipeg Manitoba
05/31/10 2:55 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
consider this too
If you don't think Pride is a social or political issue, then by all means you should be able to hold the hand of someone of the same sex and walk through downtown Winnipeg. When we no longer need a group around us to be safe to do this, we will no longer need the social statement of Pride.
Trevor Thorkelson, Winnipeg Manitoba
06/02/10 10:03 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The incredibly powerful Pride Parade
As someone who has marched in 15 Pride Parades in Winnipeg- I see this as another step forward in our history - not a shrinking. The parade is a statement of our presence in community and a declaration of voice. That has not changed. We do it for ourselves and each other. That has not changed. We come out in Pride to show our diversity. That has not changed. All that has changed is that now, people can actually see us in business that are open on a Sunday. We are now marching down a lovely tree lined boulevard..as opposed to a concrete jungle and we end up at one of the most historically significant ' meeting places' in our Province. Change can be hard, I know. Embracing change with an open mind, seems to be harder. This step forward will be seen in the future as a critical point of a powerful evolution in the Winnipeg Pride Parade.
Brad, Winnipeg Manitoba
06/07/10 5:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Incredible shrinking reporter
yah, so considering this was the biggest parade in history how funny is this story? FAIL
Never U. Mind, Jokesville Alabama
06/09/10 3:47 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.