The 1981 Toronto bathhouse riots
IN HINDSIGHT / Looking back on 30 years of gay liberation
Xtra staff / National / Friday, February 04, 2011
Share |

By Matt Mills - On Feb 5, 1981, 30 years ago, more than 150 Toronto police descended on that city’s gay bathhouses, arresting more than 300 innocent men. It was part of a deliberate and organized campaign by government and police to push gay baths and bars out of business, to silence the gay press and to remove gay voices from public discourse.

Gay people were not new to discrimination in 1975 when Montreal police raided that city’s Sauna Aquarius. But that is really where the story of the 1981 bathhouse riots starts. For at least the next six years, police in various cities across the country steadily increased their harassment of the gay press and gay men in gay spaces.

Gay people had, of course, previously fought police harassment, but the events in Toronto in the first half of 1981 were watershed for the liberation movement in Canada. The activist chops refined then equipped gay people across the country to fight censorship, win partnership and employment rights, demand reasonable treatment from government, face HIV/AIDS, fight homophobic violence and win marriage rights.

If gay people had run for the shadows in 1981, if the found-ins had pleaded guilty, if those who marched on that first cold February night had simply stayed home, Canada would be a very different place for gay people today.

We've assembled below a series of pieces – videos, audio clips, photos and printed stories – looking back on the bathhouse raids and riots. Among them I'd like especially to draw your attention to the reborn film Track Two. Watch the whole thing below.

Watch shorter clips featuring Margaret Atwood, June Callwood, John Burt, Ken Popert, John Sewell, Gerald Hannon, Chris Bearchell and many more.

I hope you enjoy...

The 1981 Toronto bathhouse riots: A city galvanized, our communities remade
By Gerald Hannon

Late on the evening of Thursday, Feb 5, 1981, scores of Toronto police conducted simultaneous raids on four of Toronto's most popular bathhouses, arresting more than 300 men. Conceived to send the city's newly visible gay community back to where it had come from, Operation Soap teetered on the edge of success. Fearing the worst but hoping for the best, activists who had shepherded their community's hesitant emergence as a political force called for a public protest the next evening at Yonge and Wellesley streets.

Writer Gerald Hannon was at the centre of it all and recorded what he witnessed in The Body Politic, the city's gay newsmagazine. Thirty years later, his words remain a vivid testament to a breaking storm of anger and courage that remade our communities.
 
 
Our communities remade: The Body Politic and the 1981 Toronto bathhouse riots
By Ken Popert

For many gay people The Body Politic was the only trusted source of news and information about the bathhouse raids and subsequent riots.

In February 2011, then-Body Politic Collective member and present-day Pink Triangle Press executive director, Ken Popert spoke about the role of the publication in the first half of 1981.

Read his notes for that talk.

This element added on 4 Mar, 2011.

 
A first-hand account of the riots
By Philip McLeod

'What on earth am I doing this for?’ I asked myself as I started on foot from Tranby. I haven’t marched since the end of WW II. I know homosexuality is something you ‘do in the dark,’ but I hadn’t expected myself to be marching in the middle of Yonge St in the middle of the night with about 2,000 others."
 

Read McLeod's account of the Feb 8 and 9, 1981 riots

This element added on 25 Apr, 2011.
A deliberate campaign against gay sexuality
By Peter Bochove

When Toronto police raided the city's bathhouses in 1981, Peter Bochove was one of the proprietors of The Richmond St Health Emporium..

Bochove struggled with city officials for years after the raids before winning a licence to build the Spa on Maitland. The 1981 raids and Bochove's subsequent fight established the legal legitimacy of gay bars and baths in law. He writes about his experiences.
A unique foundation for a young movement
By Tim McCaskell

An activist his whole life long, Tim McCaskell spoke at the rally against the 1978 raid of The Barracks by Toronto police. He spoke at the 1981 bathhouse raid demonstrations, too.

The rallies against the 1981 raids helped equip Canada's gay activists to face HIV/AIDS. In fact, many of those who led the charge against cops and government in 1981 went on to found key community organizations. Read how.
Track Two
By Harry Sutherland

In 1980 Harry Sutherland, Jack Lemmon and Gordon Keith set out to make a documentary film about the gay liberation movement in the civic election in Toronto that year.

The project didn't go as planned and the men were wondering what to do next when they got word that Toronto police had raided the city's bathhouses. They grabbed their gear and took to the streets.

See a 2008 interview with Sutherland and watch the film in its entirety.
 
Joey Shulman: Found in a common bawdyhouse
As told to Matt Mills

Shulman was charged as a found-in at the Richmond Street Health Emporium.

Read and hear his story.
 

 
Duncan McLaren: Found in a common bawdyhouse
As told to Matt Mills

McLaren was charged after Toronto police raided The Barracks on Feb 5, 1981. He famously heard one police officer tell another that it was a shame the shower heads at the tubs weren't hooked up to gas. The charge lingered over McLaren's head for years, and when it finally came to trial, it was dismissed.

Read his story.
 
Bathhouse raid picture gallery


Check out a selection of images.
 



Share |


Reader Comments


 
Blast from the Past
Great Doc.... Brings back memories of Toronto in the early 80's pre-condo and captures alot of Toronto Gay History. Movie Star question though...at 50 minutes 28 seconds...is that Lorraine Segato?
pjr, Toronto ON
02/05/11 12:48 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
WTF
Same thing happened in Edmonton around the same time. Glad I went back to England, we weren't allowed baths, but having them and being arrested, oi.
Glen D Bibby, S.Surrey B.C.
02/05/11 5:24 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
everything happens for a reson
no one wanted this to happen the raids i mean but what would it be like if it didnt happen it might have been another 20 years before the gay community stated fighting back some people got hurt by this and commend the ones that fought back like mt title says things happen for a resone some times we dont like it but this time alot of good came of the events back in the 80 s we now have baths we can go to without being bothered we have gay bars that even so called straight guys go to now lol we have gay pride parads that thousands go to in many communities gays have the right to marry can collect there partners pentsions
jack, sarnia ontario
02/05/11 7:04 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Toronto Bath house raids
First of all, Thank You Squirt! for remembering this momentous date. I will never forget that fateful very, cold night. I was at the Richmond baths. I remember everything was as usual when all of a sudden the music stopped. The music never stopped. There was an eerie silence. Someone said the police were at the door. Not long after, I could hear guys running, yelling and things smashing all over the place. The noise of the banging was unbelievable. We were told to stay in our rooms until the police came to take us downstairs to the front lobby to be processed. I remember viewing all the damage on my way downstairs. The process took forever. A guy I had met there and myself, went back to his place once we were released. We walked to Yonge and Lawrence. Clearly we were in shock, we didn't even notice the cold. While waiting in my room, I heard someone say, the door to the roof was bolted shut from the outside. I guess the cops thought of everything. They clearly didn't want anyone getting away. The police chose the coldest night to simultaneously raid the bath houses. They figured it was too cold for the community to come out and support us. They sure got a shock when thousands showed up at 52 division a couple days later. The support we received from the community and the rest of Toronto was surprising and sure helped us cope with what had just happened. I remember Dick Smyth of Chum radio, doing a commentary on air. He said he visited the bath houses and saw the damage for himself. Even though the police denied doing extensive damage. Smyth called the police, and I quote, THE PIGS, for their heavy handed, bully boy tactics. The police demanded an apology from Chum Radio. The station refused an apology and assured the police they fully supported Smyth's comments. Little did we know then, how this would change our community in years to come. I guess it's true... IT GETS BETTER
Leonard Cloutier, Toronto Ontario
02/05/11 10:43 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Rage & Gratitude
Thanks to everyone who helped put this together. A fantastic resource!
Steven Maynard, Toronto Ontario
02/05/11 11:46 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
@Leonard
Hi Leonard, A little more on Dick Symth. He was called because he was pretty homophobic on his radio show. When I spoke to him he said he was no friend of the community. I told him that's exactly why he should come and see what was left of my bathhouse. He did and that's why he aired that piece. He was as disgusted by it as you or I.
Peter Bochove, Toronto Ontario
02/05/11 2:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
now known in BC
I just received this from Norman Taylor in Toronto with whom I reestablished friendship when he came to the reception for me at U.C. because I have endowed two scholarships at the Mark S. Bonham Centre for Sexual Diversity studies. Norman was a tenant at my friend PHil McLeod's who mounted "court watch" warning guys arrested to not plead guilty. Gerald Hannon who wrote a piece above and was one of the most active activists was a platonic roommate of mine at corner of Lowther and Brunswick. I was not a gay activist then though i went to meetings of CHAT , new all the Body Politic collective and George Hislop. I remember the murder of Don ? who ran for alderman. At the triaal of his murder when he was sentenced to ten years his mother got up and screamed "it was only a queer he killed"!! I had my own trial in the main courthouse on University in Nov. 1970 (preliminary hearing) and trial on Feb. 1st and 2nd, 1971. I pleaded not guilty to several charges including "counseling to commit an indecent act in a washroom at the Coliseum at the CNE. The arresting cops testified that I was circumsized but when my lawyer Clayton Ruby handed to the Jury 8 X 10 glossy photos of my uncut cock I had to be acquitted. At that time i was a Senior Education officer at the Ontario Science Centre where I finally finished my Ph.D. thesis in Zoology (in 1974) Out here on SaltSpring Island where I came in 1990 I guess I finally became an activist in my 60s, 70s, and 80s (83 next JUne). Around 1993 eight guys met and several years later joined with the much larger group of Lesbians to form GLOSSI GAYS AND LESBIANS OF SALT SPRING ISLAND. I was vice -Pres in 2005 the year we had our first Pride weekend in Sept. Ist two years, panel discussion at our theatre centreArtspring, 3rd year a reading of Lareme project . The pride weekend always include a dance and picnic. Last 2 years I was co-grand marshall of our 400= partricipants Pride Parade and about
Jack Hallam, Salt Spring Island BC
02/05/11 2:54 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Very Proud
Thank you to the editors who put this important piece of our history together. As much as it will make those of us who lived through those times proud of our community, it should make the younger generation aware of the value of their freedoms--and how those freedoms were won. Congratulations to Xtra! and to everyone involved with bringing this project to the public.
Michael Rowe, Toronto Ontario
02/05/11 3:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks for the memories
Thanks for the memories of this turning point in our fight to achieve our rights and freedoms. We've come so very far in 30 years. We should remind ourselves that there are many around the world who are still waiting for their time to come. I hope that our example and our achievements give them hope and make their struggle easier.
Peter Maloney, Waterloo Ontario
02/05/11 5:22 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
pink tiangle
Today, we live in a world as they say "dipped in lukewarm water" the true meaning of gay pride? unfortunately often answer will be "not important!" yes, we must remember we are here because the people who fought for us in the past, I particularly enjoyed the speech by Margaret Atwood "towards the end and I liked the ending with the flag of pink triangle, I think it is more appropriate for us than a rainbow
george hirano reid, montreal quebec
02/05/11 7:34 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
@Peter
Hi Peter, I know Smyth was no supporter of us. I didn't want to go into too deep, mostly cause of character limitation. That is why I was so surprised. I mean shocked at Smyth's commentary. I was only 24 back then and fairly new to the community. Thanks to your bathouse, I had a safe place to wxplore my sexuality. Apart from the raids, those were the good old day's. The St. Charles, The Manatee, The Quest, Buddy's, Stages and others. Thanks for doing your part Peter.
Leonard Cloutier, Toronto Ontario
02/05/11 8:43 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Happening Now
Funny, not to deny the progress that has happened in 30 years, with the raids then as the catalyst for change. But, in Hamilton, one of the seedier places to find gay cruising is the well known porn palace known as Show World. In the past few months, police have stepped up the raids of this place, collaring men who are doing nothing in the porn theaters, lining them up against walls, taking their names, and giving them 'warnings'. There have been some arrests. You would think the Hamilton police would have better things to do. The more things change, the more they stay the same.
MarcInHamilton, Hamilton ON
02/05/11 10:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thank you
Thank you for making this video available, it was great to see it. I was 11 years old in 1981 and didn't pay any attention to the news but I remember hearing my parents talking about the angry homosexuals in Toronto, it was my first indication that I wasn't alone, it was like a light turned on in my head when I heard them talking about it, it meant an awful lot to me to know I wasn't the only one. I grew up on the outskirts of Kitchener and Toronto might as well have been on another planet as far as I was concerned at the time, but they had homosexuals there, angry ones, I was very excited. Thank you to everyone who stood up for the community and protested and to those who organized and lead the way. We have full legal equality today thanks to the efforts of those who were willing to fight for it, we've come a long way in 30 years and its great to have this movie document that period in the community's history. The only problem I had with the movie was that the audio was out of sync with the video and it got worse as the movie went on. I don't know if that was just a problem with my internet connection or if there was a problem with the file encoding. I'll watch parts of it again later to see if its my connection or the encoding, if its the encoding hopefully they'll put out a corrected version. If possible I would like to buy a hard copy of the movie. Is it being sold somewhere or is it only on YouTube?
Rich, Toronto Ontario
02/06/11 4:11 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
An interesting consequence of the 1981 raids
The 1981 police raids on Toronto bathhouses galvanized and politicized the local gay community. As a consequence, the outrage over the raids may have prevented Ontario and Toronto public health authorities from taking any action against Toronto bathhouses a few years later during the AIDS epidemic. In contrast, public health authorities in other North American cities later shut down, or imposed restrictions on, gay bathhouses in hopes of reducing the spread of AIDS. For example, in 1985, the New York City Health Department ordered that the city's gay bathhouses be closed.
Randy, Toronto Ontario
02/06/11 10:24 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Toronto No-go Zone For Gays
Proves Toronto is a filthy homohobic place not yet on the world's tourism radar.
H. Hewitt, Montreal Quebec
02/06/11 10:41 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
What?
@Hewitt - Proves nothing of the kind. 30 years have passed. @Randy - Toronto Public Health never moved against the bathhouses that remained and always saw the opportunity to work with us. Their proactive approach worked a whole lot better than the knee jerk closing of the baths in New York and California ever did.
Peter Bochove, Toronto Ontario
02/06/11 12:27 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
False Conviction
In 1960 the police in North York detained me for 11 hours denying me access to a phone call and getting me to sign their statement before letting me go to the washroom.Although my students told the court nothing improper had happened the judge went on the police coerced statement and I lost my teaching certificate which was not returned by the Ministry of Education until 1989.Thus laws had to be changed for gay liberation.
Eugene Stasiuk, Toronto ON
02/06/11 1:03 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
What Riots ?
Ok, "rioting" gays makes good headlines but it wasn't so. One of the things that was so remarkable to those of us participating in all the demonstrations and the political work behind the protests was the lack of violence. We went to great trouble to make sure there was no "rioting". Safety Committees, Safety Monitors, specialized training, lots and lots of planning, all made sure we didn't "riot" or get the crap beaten out of us by homophobic thugs or homophobic police. Yes, there were several exceptions, but those few incidents involved isolated attacks on individuals perpetrated by uniformed and undercover police. Though "provocation" was clearly an offical police stragedy for dealing with demonstrations, we never took the bait. I doubt we would have seen the community wide involvement had there been "riots". Had there been "riots" the support from outside communities would have evaporated. Our great acheivment was to channel our very justifiable rage into very sophisticated and productive actions. It was that success that turned the Raids into a pivitol moment for gay rights in Canada, from which there has been no turning back. Words are important.
Elan Rosenquist, San Francisco CA
02/06/11 4:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thank You
Thank you Ken Popert for resurrecting this film and restoring it. Thank you Xtra for giving it back to us. At the 50 minute mark in the video I saw myself, 31 with a full head of hair. Angry at being considered a potential criminal,exhilarated by the unfolding events of that night and so very happy that we were finally a community that could not be turned back. I was also deeply saddened a I saw faces that would disappear over 15 years that followed. The big shout that went up on the night of Feb. 6 was NO MORE SHIT! That's for sure! I'm well into my 62nd year, a survivor of HIV and and very grateful for the foundation of support that was started on Feb.6 1981
Doug Robinson, Toronto Ontario
02/06/11 5:24 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Toronto No-go Zone For Gays? Try Montreal!
@Hewitt - have you not heard of the Sex Garage raids in Montreal in July 1990? Those raids, an escalation of well known police harassment, were extremely violent: e.g. police toting semi-automatic weapons to clear out gay bars, cops removing their name tags and beating the shit out of the queers on the night of the raids, and subsequently at protests in the following days. That was just over 20 years ago - by your warped logic, Montreal should still be someplace to avoid.
Dan, Toronto ON
02/07/11 8:16 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
excellently researched historical written and vide
I shall never forget 30 years ago this week when Toronto cops violently raided the main gay steambaths & arrested 100's of gays (As Margaret Atwood quipped she was surprised the cops were against cleanliness). I was working as a producer & researcher at "the 5th estate" but even with a "respectable" job at risk (I worked on crime and policing stories and had to work with police on researching many stories and they did not work well at all with open homosexuals) , I angrily with 1000's of others marched in the streets that week for the 1st time since anti-war & gay lib protests of 1969/70's. Thanks "xtra" for all of the well researched written and video accounts and reflections online at xtra.ca on the momentous events of February 1981 which was a seminal moment in gay activist organization in Toronto as well as a new low in police/LGBT community relations. With a lot of work by both sides over the past 30 years there is today a much more healthy and often mutually beneficial relationship between the cops and the LGBT community--an openly gay police /LGBT LIaison officer, a LGBT committee which regularly meets & works with police and a annual Police Chief's party in the LGBT community to celebrate "Gay Pride." But as we saw all too graphically last July with the very emotional demonstration at the Police Chief's Pride reception at the 519, this is still a tenuous, fragile onging work in progress. some of the very bad policing at the G20 showed that Toronto cops could still be very insensitive to the LGBT community as well as to other people excercising their democratic right to protest on the streets of Toronto. We still have a long way to go to improve LGBT community/Toronto police relations, but at least bathhouses are no longer subject to violent police raids and onging harassment. To that extent we have earned the police's respect through years of acti
james dubro, toronto ontario
02/07/11 12:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Goodbye Seventies
God, I wish I was around from 78-81!! ...and Harry Sutherland - whoa, what a hottie!! :D
J Roman, Toronto ON
02/07/11 2:45 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ed's note
Hi Rich: We're in the process of figuring out a way to include a direct download link so you can download and burn your own copy. Will keep you posted.
Matt Mills, Toronto Ont
02/07/11 6:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
How To Download
I downloaded mine using a You Tube downloader. It is available as free ware at http://www.dvdvideosoft.com/ as well as free ware tools that will allow you to burn to DVD. This is open source software. Everyone should have a copy of Track Two.
Peter Bochove, Toronto Ontario
02/07/11 6:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thanks!
Thanks Peter! I was able to download a copy for myself using the software you suggested. Thankfully the downloaded copy has its audio in sync with the video, I had thought it was a streaming issue but its good to know for sure. Seeing this video has made me want to go visit the LGBT archives, I'd love to be able to read some old issues of the Body Politic and early Xtra as well and to learn more about the LGBT community before the raids. Its hard to believe so much was going on back when I thought I was the only one attracted to other guys, I had thought that hearing about the raids and the following protests was the first time I realized I wasn't the only guy attracted to other guys but upon further reflection I recalled that I had seen the character Jody on Soap previous to hearing about the angry homosexuals in Toronto. I have always had a soft spot for Billy Crystal for playing a gay character, Jody, back then, I loved and was devoted to that show because of him. Still hearing about the angry homosexuals in Toronto was also a very enlightening experience for me, they were real and not just make believe characters on TV, I remember being very excited to find out that there were other gay guys in Toronto. Thankfully for young LGBT folks today they have the internet and with changes in society its very unlikely any more young gay guys are left thinking they're the only ones though I'm sure its still extremely difficult, especially for young LGBT folks in the smaller and more isolated communities.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
02/07/11 9:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
History will set you free and make you stronger
Thank you so much for the producers and directors of this documentary, this was an emotional journey for the period of time I first visited Toronto. A lot has since then changed in Canada for gay rights and human rights. Knowledge of history is essential to protect and maintain rights obtained to a political struggle. It is important to the new generation to empower themselves with knowledge so that the clock can not be set back in time. The freedoms enjoyed today can easily be turned back if the guard on them are let down. Power to the people, freedom and human rights.
Mark Kedrick, Toronto Ontario
02/11/11 6:01 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Thank you
I was in the Romans that night, and I have to say thank you for all the material that has been posted. I was afraid the 30th anniversary would be forgotten. That night is seared in my memory, and changed my life. I was working at Old City Hall and 52 Division for the Old City Hall Bail Project. The next day we had a workshop downtown, so I did not go home and checked into the Romance II. I was in my room with the cutest Jewish boy, hell we were all boys back then, and we heard loud noises. I commented that it sounded like the Romans was waking up. Someone banged on the door and said "Open up or we will break the door down". I opened the door and the nightmare began. We were rounded up, in our towels, into the 2nd floor weights area. I tried to counsel a very scared guy by rubbing his butt through his towel. Hey, it was as steambath. Anyway I had no ID on me, and was one of the last processed. I was taken to 52 and then, because of the crowds there, a few of us went to 55 in Regent Park. I could go on about the Susan Hayward impression, from one very creative American, "I want to live" is best heard behind bars, and the other big lug who let me sit between his legs in the lock up at Old City Hall. Thanks for letting me reminisce, however I am waiting for an apology and reparations. Bob
Bob Webster, Ottawa Ontario
02/18/11 3:58 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
great doc, where's the analysis?
Thank you to xtra and all those involved in this great documentary, which should be compulsory viewing in all high school curricula. That it can’t be is testament to how far we still have to go in the fight for sexual liberation. As important as it is to celebrate all our accomplishments, we only have to recall McGuinty’s recent capitulation to the forces of religion over the new sex education curriculum, to realize that the war is far from over. Though I enjoyed the historical presentation, I was struck by the absence of any current analysis of what it all means in historical context and up to the present: whither sexual liberation today in the battle for civil rights and the assimilationism of our community? I was hoping for a thoughtful essay or two -- Mr. Hannon for one could have written a brilliant essay here. That said, it is so very fortunate that Harry Sutherland was on the scene to document these revolutionary events. I was literally moved to tears to see these nostalgic images, of the earnestness and courage of those that came before us.
Derek Norman, Toronto Ontario
02/21/11 4:08 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Post-raid legal support
Many of you would never know that the man, Dennis Findlay, who guided many "found-ins" through the legal process and who was describing their success in the courts so far (one year later I believe) near the end of the film was a pastry chef by profession. He became the legal coordinator of the Right to Privacy Committee and developed legal chops during this experience that many a lawyer would envy.
Brian Waite, Vancouver BC
02/25/11 10:45 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Pigs on Horses
I should add that confronting the police in front of 52 Division HQ was extremely empowering (I still say Fuck you 52 for carrying on that tradition during the G20), the agents provocateur and plain clothes cops kept dashing out of their lines to grab and "arrest" some of us near the front of the crowd. Thanks to good marshalling from old pioneers from the anti-war and women's movements, such as Chris Bearchell, we were able to maintain enough order so that the cops on horses whom we learned were waiting in the garage area of city hall were not called into action, saving many of us a morning headache beyond the hangover we may have suffered in celebrating our victory in the streets. God (one of the Greek ones) bless us everyone.
Brian Waite, Vancouver BC
02/26/11 10:48 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.