Ottawa gays 'betrayed' by Bank St process
OUR VILLAGE / Community urged to take a stand at Tues meeting
Gareth Kirkby / Ottawa / Friday, March 14, 2008
Share |

The gay community has been taken for a ride by city hall's planning process for Bank Street's redevelopment this spring, charge community representatives. And they say now's the time for the gay community to come out and insist on getting respect from city hall.

Plans for the spring 2008 redevelopment of Bank St between Laurier St and Somerset will be presented at a city Open House on Mar 18. But Capital Xtra has learned that the plans fail to include recognition of the gay community's longstanding identification of Bank Street as the gay village.

Starting with a Feb 2006 Open House that was attended by an estimated 100 gays and lesbians, the community has called for recognition of a portion of Bank St as the city's gay village. At that meeting, people called for signage, rainbow flags, banners and historic plaques to be incorporated into the infrastructure when Bank St is redecorated after a major dig to replace century old sewage lines.

Since then, a Facebook group of more than 500 members has formed. And Glenn Crawford and Rick Barnes (representing Pink Triangle Services) sat on a committee tasked with designing the new look for Bank St. Supporters of a village marched in the 2007 Pride Parade and more than 300 people have participated in a survey that asked about the boundaries of a village and what amenities people wanted to denote it.

There will be no such amenities under the plan to be shown to the public for comment on Tuesday.

"Nothing specific like that has been incorporated," says Luke Foley, a city staffer and project manager. There are no plans for drop-down signs saying The Village. Or rainbow flags. Or banners. Or plaques. Or anything else that suggests that this is the gay village of Ottawa.

"I guess the comments and info we're given, we look at the overall picture and ask if it's for everyone," says Foley.

The gay community's ideas put forward by Crawford and Barnes had been carefully selected to ensure they would be inclusive and not create discomfort for non-gay residents and business owners.

Foley says that the plans include new banner holders on the street poles, but the Bank St BIA (the group representing the street merchants) has control over what banners or flags are raised. That "provides an opportunity" for the gay community to pressure the BIA into flying the rainbow flag, he says.

Foley also points to 90 bike racks that will be placed between Laurier and the Queensway. Some 30 designs by artists will accompany bike racks, so the gay community also has an opportunity to lobby for gay-positive art, says Foley.

Barnes and Crawford are both livid and disappointed by the results. Crawford attended three meetings of the design group at the encouragement of city hall, as well as meeting with the design consultants. He and Barnes say that at every step they were encouraged by representatives of other interest groups to believe that recognition of the gay community's special relationship to Bank St was positive and inevitable.

"It's a betrayal," says Barnes, "leading us on to believe we had their support.

"We sat around the table with people who nodded at our ideas, giving us their support."

Crawford points to positive language in both the consultant's report and the report of the design committee that recognized the gay community's relationship with Bank St and the need for signs and banners that made that clear.

"What's the point of jumping through their hoops and giving our input if they're not giving us a thing?" he asks. Is the hold-up at city hall or is the Bank St Business Improvement Area, representing merchants on the street, vetoing any proposed acknowledgment of the gay community, he wonders.

Crawford is designing a form for people to fill in at the Open House so that the community can demand that the design process go back to the drawing board and incorporate recognition of the gay village. He expects a heavy turnout of people demanding to be heard, especially after the promises that were made to the gay community at the Feb 2006 Open House.

And for those with an activist bent, Barnes is considering planning a small demonstration outside the meeting.

This city has to recognize that Bank St has a special connection to the gay community, says Barnes. "Our businesses are here, our groups. We live downtown." It's where we live and work and play.

"They can't keep on disrespecting us," he says.


Open House.
Tue, Mar 18. 5-8pm.
Centretown Community Health Centre.
420 Cooper St, room 208.


***


Gay-owned and gay-friendly businesses and community groups in downtown Ottawa:
  • Use the + and - buttons on the upper left side to zoom in and out.


View Larger Map


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Unbelievable
Once again, we see that the City of Ottawa has no resect for the Gay Community of Ottawa. We remain the largest city in Canada to NOT have a proper Gay community. I simply can't understand why they bothered to ask for the imput of the Gay community if they had no intention of including any of our suggestions? I do hope they will go back and change the plans to include us in their plans. We are an imortant part of this community, isn't it time they treated us as such?
Denis Levesque, Ottawa Ontario
03/14/08 6:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wow!
What a slap to the face of all members of the Ottawa GLBT community. Shame on you City Hall!
Nick Fraser, Ottawa Ontario
03/14/08 11:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Unacceptable
Let our community come together and insist that we have a gay village!! We need to be pro-active in our stand against city hall that we are an impotant voice in the this matter.
Rehaad Ali, Ottawa On
03/15/08 12:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Organic is better
I don't understand why we can't just call it a Queer Village anyway? Can't each store owner just put up a rainbow ally sticker and make efforts to actually be queer positive? The very first gay pride demonstrations certainly weren't sanctioned or supported by cities (and many would argue that Ottawa's parade isn't now) so why can't we just take up space in that same tradition and make the streets ours? That's what's happening all over the city as little enclaves of GLBTQ folks find parts of neighbourhoods that are comfy and welcoming. At one point, there were at least 5 dyke housholds on my short street in Centretown and more moved in after word spread that it was a dyke-friendly street. No city flags marked the occasion. If you really want Bank St to be a queer Mecca, then my vote is for rallying some anarcho queers to paint that pink stripe back on Bank St on the first warm day of spring. Activism and solidarity creates a village -- mayoral decrees don't.
Caro, Ottawa ON
03/17/08 5:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wake Up!
Having worked a short stint at Capital Xtra I came face-to-face with the hesitance and dismissal of Bank Street merchants. The three BIAs I contacted (repeatedly) to support our Pride issue NEVER returned phone calls. They include the Bank St., Somerset St., and Biward Market BIAS. Gays and Lesbians naively assume that because Somerset has Centretown Pub, and that Bank St. has Wildes, After Stonewall, and 1 in 10 that they live in a progressive village like Montreal. These businesses do not run city council nor do they have ANY influence over city council. Let`s face it: If Alex Munter had been elected mayor ( and not homophobically railroaded by the scandal-ridden mayor) this situation would be a non-issue.
Donald Theoret, Ottawa Ontario
03/17/08 8:06 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Planning is more than just public meetings
The city's corporate services and economic development committee approve the citizen appointees to Ottawa's urban BIA boards of management. The appointees will serve for nearly four years, until the current session of council expires Nov. 30, 2010. The nominees, submitted by the various BIAs, "represent the diversity of businesses in the various BIAs and will be actively involved in the business community." Bank Street BIA Members include: Mel Hartman, Orleans Fresh Fruit Bill Joe, Cathay Restaurant Steven Tanner, Staples Business Depot Jacie Levinson, Comvesco Levinson Viner Ken Ginn, Ginn Photographic Brian Roberts, Regional Realty Group Rock Falardeau, Scotiabank What GLBT business volunteered to sit on the Board? Why is the GLBT community not represented if the BIA membership is to reflect diversity? What lobbying has the GLBT community committee done with each of the Board members to garner their support? What pressure can the GLBT community place on the BIA member businesses to demonstrate our influence in the Village?
Bruce Bursey, Ottawa ON
03/18/08 6:50 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Capital City
My understanding was that having a gay village would somehow reflect negatively on Ottawa's image as the national capital has anyone else heard about this? Not sure how or if this is even true but its one excuse I heard.
Ross Craig-Browne, Ottawa Ontario
03/18/08 1:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
What Gay Village?
If this part of Bank street really was a gay village, which I dont think it is, it would be self evident. The argument is that this part of Bank is where we supposedly "live, work and play"...I don't think that's true, if you look at the map above that shows all the gay owned and gay friendly business' and community groups it does look like a lot, but you have to keep in mind that that map is basically all of downtown, is the entire downtown core of Ottawa the gay village? If people want to have a village fine but you can't create community by putting up rainbow flags or with a by-law, that's not how it works. Does anyone remember the banners that were up on Rideau street a few years ago? "Rideau, Ottawa's Arts & Theatre District". Rideau St. has never been Ottawa's Arts & Theatre district, it wasn't before they put those banners up, and putting them up didn't make it happen, they eventually took them all down. If you want a gay village in Ottawa fine, then make it happen, you can decorate it with rainbows after it's established not the other way around.
Adam Hodgins, Ottawa ON
03/19/08 10:39 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Bank is clearly the gay village
We're too modest in Ottawa. In Vancouver, when the rainbow flags went up on Davie St, there were only four gay businesses with storefronts more or less on Davie — three gay bars and a gay bookstore. In Ottawa, there are four gay businesses right on the street and another four just off the street. When the flags went up on Davie, it was amazing how people's spirits lifted when they walked along, the sun shining through the rainbow colours. And guess what? People who no longer lived in the neighbourhood came to visit Davie and socialize and meet new and old friends and spend money. And Davie Village was transformed. And even some of the merchants who had been opposed to it became strong supporters as they saw the foot traffic, and their profits, increase. And a few more gay businesses located to it. But the straight businesses will always outnumber the gay businesses — they do in every gay neighbourhood from Montreal to San Fran. In Ottawa, gays live and work and play along Bank St. The neighbourhood has tons of us living in it. And our gay community organizations are almost all located here. And in the last decade, most gay businesses have relocated to here. So, all three of these things — residents, organizations and businesses — are now all here at the same time. So it's the perfect time to formalize that with banners and signs. And for us to think bigger and more positively about what we have, and are, and can be. And to proudly claim our place on the geography of this city.
Gareth Kirkby, Ottawa Ontario
03/20/08 5:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
AWESOME
The Village is there already. My own experiance in Vancouver was the same. Many of us lived in the westend, and soon with the banners up it lifted your spirits on days when it was dull out and on sunny days too. It made me feel good as it did for many others as well. Seeing the flags helped establish that we were proud of who we were and did not need to hide. Many people coming out of the closet that i helped would often comment on the effect it had on them to see such a public display. I also saw marginal businesses improve and change to become part of our neighbourhood. It was good for gay and straight business.
Ricky Barnes, Ottawa Ontario
03/21/08 1:59 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Freedom of expression and Right to equality
As far as I'm concerned the Gay Community is asking a small favour. If we were to put up an official "gay community", where is the harm? While it does designate, for them, a certain area of the city, it also seperates them from the straight community. If straights can have the rest of the city, gays should have an area they want. It's not as if it's imposing on the rest of the community, just giving them a place to go and be themselves. I'm saying this as a straight woman, they deserve to maintain their lifestyles WITH style and pride. Give them their section, they vote, they work, and they pay their taxes. They are no less entitled to acceptance and acknowledgement. The city will sanction neighbourhoods according to heritage and culture. Gay is a culture, and they stand by that stronger than many Canadian's now stand by the heritage of their ancestors. It is more relevent. Society is changing, the nation's capital should have been the first to realise and embrace that.
Alex MacDonald, Ottawa ON
03/26/08 12:54 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.