Meet writer and activist Sarah Schulman
IDEAS / How an expert on homophobia became a QuAIA supporter
Chris Dupuis / National / Friday, June 10, 2011
Share |

Celebrated writer and academic Sarah Schulman has penned novels, plays and essays; cofounded the New York Queer Experimental Film Festival; and organized the city’s first Dyke March. She is a prominent queer and AIDS activist and a distinguished professor of the humanities at City University of New York. On Wednesday, June 22, Schulman will speak in Toronto at a Queers Against Israeli Apartheid (QuAIA) event. When I ask how the invitation came about, she takes me back to 2009.
 
Sarah Schulman
“It all started after I published ‘Ties That Bind,’ a book on homophobia in the family,” she says on the phone from New York. “That led to an invitation to give a lecture at Tel Aviv University on the subject. At first I was delighted because homophobia in the Jewish family is a subject that is very close to me.”
 
But then a friend advised her about the ongoing boycott of Israeli universities, initiated by a community of international academics, including some from Israel, in the hopes of forcing the country to change its approach to the Palestinian community. 
 
“This began a complete life transformation,” she says. “I hadn’t heard about the boycott before, and so I began researching it. I realized that if I accepted the invitation it would be like crossing a picket line of people whose rights are being oppressed.”
 
Being the academic that is, Schulman’s research process consisted of considerably more than a simple Google search; it comprised an intensive two months of speaking to academics and activists (including Elle Flanders of QuAIA and Canadian filmmaker John Greyson) about the realities of Palestinian life under Israeli occupation.
 
“Both Elle and John encouraged me to decline the invite but to go on a journey of solidarity,” she says. “At the time I had no connections or history with Israel at all.” 
 
Schulman went to visit Tel Aviv, Ramallah and Haifa, meeting with local activists and seeing the day-to-day realities of life in the country firsthand. Following her return, she organized a six-city speaking tour in the US for queer Palestinian activists.
 
“It was an astoundingly successful experience,” she says.  “They were funny, sexy, human and complex. They really resonated with audiences. In New York alone we turned away over 200 people.”
 
But a week later the backlash began.  Well-known gay porn director Michael Lucas took issue with a pro-Palestinian group being hosted by the New York LGBT Center. He spearheaded a campaign, and within eight hours the centre's leadership decided to ban the group. 
 
“This was the first time in 25 years a group had been banned from using the centre,” Schulman says. “This was stunning to me. The last group that was banned was NAMBLA [the North American Man-Boy Love Association]. The leadership claimed they were doing this to protect Jews, but there were no Jews among the leadership. It’s an example of the new kind of anti-Semitism that says that Jews are monolithic and only have one point of view. This is why I am coming to Toronto to speak.”
 
Not surprisingly, Schulman has been following the struggles of QuAIA. But her support of the group isn’t just about a common set of politics. 
 
“There’s also the meta-issue of the corporatization of our community,” she says.  “That an LGBT organization would become so dependent on government funding that they would let the government tell them how to run things is hugely problematic.”
 
“The queer community being dependent on government funding is a recent phenomenon,” she adds.  “If we’ve come to the point where governments are telling us that we have to exclude people to get funding, that means the relationship of dependency has become destructive. We have to ask ourselves what is more important, the integrity of our community or the approval of the government.”

UPDATE 23 JUN 2011 - Xtra's Elvira Kurt caught up with Schulman during her Toronto visit.
 


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Entirely the wrong approach
'“This began a complete life transformation,” she says. “I hadn’t heard about the boycott before and so I began researching it. I realized that if I accepted the invitation it would be like crossing a picket line of people whose rights are being oppressed.”' I have to say, I think that this reasoning is like swiss cheese. Ultimately, "the realities of Palestinian life under Israeli occupation" shouldn't be brought to bear on a decision about whether to speak IN Israel (at a public institution of LEARNING no less), to an audience of people who potentially disagree with you (and whom, ideally, you're trying to win over)!! God... This is the kind of US vs. THEM thinking that is *most* unhelpful in resolving protracted conflicts of any kind... These realities should be brought to bear on other things, but of this I am sure: a thinking activist does not turn down an invitation to speak at a University and to change minds about the issues of importance to them because of a blockheaded misidentification of that University (and the people at it) with the State in which it resides. Period. The only real exception would be if the University in question were actively discriminating against viewpoints... Because the institutions themselves are publically-funded (by the government of Israel, ideally in a corruption-free manner. heh.), this is a concern worth noting. However, as I alluded to above, there's absolutely no nucleus of reason to be found in this highly emotionally-charged piece: were that EVEN the case, wouldn't she WANT to visit such an institution even still? Why turn down an invitation to the lion's den, so to speak?
Derek Rodgers, Halifax Nova Scotia
06/10/11 3:30 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I liked Schulman's attacks on "Rent"
Although I am no fan of QuAIA, I have enjoyed Sarah Schulman's attacks on the AIDS musical "Rent". It's neat when she told gays, AIDS activists and other social progressives that they were fawning over a play that was actually quite socially regressive. See http://www.slate.com/id/2131017/
Randy, Toronto Ontario
06/11/11 12:00 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Of course Homophobia
As this women points out "homophobia in the Jewish family is a subject that is very close to me" and no doubt it was the homophobia in her own family directed at her that so affected her that her reasoning is now sickened and perverse. I suspect this is the route cause of the all the self hating jewish anti-Semites that belong to hate groups such as QuAIA. Hate begets hate and she is yet another victim and perpetrator of this sick needles hate.
Queero, Toronto Ontario
06/11/11 8:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
cool
Loved reading this, can't wait to meet Sarah in Toronto. She sounds like a thoughtful woman and an amazing activist!
queer love, Toronto ON
06/11/11 11:12 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
anti-semitic, hah
I always find it funny, that the automatic criticism Zionists have of Jews who choose to boycott Israel is that they must be anti-semitic, self-loathing. Just one thing - not all Jews are Israelis, and not all Jews are Zionists! There was a serious debate among the international Jewish community at the time of the foundation of Israel as to whether this was a good idea - culminating, I suppose, in the debate between using Yiddish or Hebrew. Critiquing a nation state that commits serious human rights abuses isn't anti-semitic!
Michael, Belleville ON
06/12/11 10:13 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Human Rights? the Gay left is a joke !
I'm guessing the people of Syria and at current counts the death toll is around 1700 civilians more then in Gaza and all kill by their own government does not count since it's not Israel, Right? All they want it freedom and the right to vote and pick their leaders. The Western Left and Human Rights Activists still remind rather quiet on this issue I wonder why? Also maybe the QuAIA could answer this: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jun/10/tel-aviv-gay-pride-parade Pinkwashing? I'm guessing Xtra does not even care about the people of Syria since the all they can do is attack Israel. Well this guy who does not even believe in God explains it way better and speaks the truth when it comes to the left and Israel http://youtu.be/G4FpTvp0tgs and http://youtu.be/eIesXORjBps since Xtra and the QuAIA and the Gay left does fall under everything he says.
Ben, Toronto ON
06/12/11 12:30 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.