Gay blood donor Kyle Freeman's PR war
LEGAL BLUES / Family and friends rally behind man challenging Canadian Blood Services' blood donation policy
Neil McKinnon / Ottawa / Wednesday, November 11, 2009
Share |

FREEMAN. Kyle's dad, husband and friends say he's "doing us a favour" by challenging the prohibition on gay blood donors.
(Neil McKinnon)
Kyle Freeman is cold, callous, and selfish — at least, that’s how he’s been portrayed by much of the mainstream media and the lawyers for Canadian Blood Services.
 
But interviews with Kyle’s family, friends and coworkers paint a different portrait: Freeman, 36, is boyishly charming, naive and cracks jokes when he’s nervous. He holds doors open for people. He lost over 40 pounds this year while on a health kick. He dresses up as Mrs Doubtfire every year for Halloween. 
 
Kyle is currently challenging a Canadian Blood Services blood donation policy he doesn’t agree with — a policy banning gay men from giving blood. 
 
During the Freeman vs Canadian Blood Services (CBS) court proceedings, Kyle posed for rushed photographers, walking in and out of the courthouse like an actor does for the glory of filmmaking. He did this for the same people who painted him with headlines that (incorrectly) proclaimed that he was using blood donation as a way to test himself for HIV.
 
In the end, Kyle’s only regret for being too candid in a lion’s den of hungry reporters was not being dressed in a suit when his photo was taken.
 
“I looked like a criminal,” says Freeman of an Ottawa Citizen photo of him leaving the Ottawa courthouse.  
 
“I don’t think I’m a hero or pioneer. It’s about believing in what’s right. Lawyers can argue the hell out of it. At the end of the day, there are people who need blood and there are healthy donors. There’s no rational basis, medical or scientific, to exclude gay men from giving blood,” says Kyle. 
 
Kyle is being sued for donating blood 18 times between 1990 and 1999, but the lawsuit focusses on four specific donations he made between 1998 and 2002. 
 
Since CBS served him in 2002, he’s garnered emotional support from his family, partner, friends and coworkers. He’s also got the support of his father, Robert Freiman, who was also a long-time blood donor. 
 
“I think [Kyle] is fighting for something right. [CBS and Health Canada] shouldn’t discriminate against gay men,” says Freiman. “He’s a fighter. He’s been that way since he was a child.”
 
Freiman isn’t the only one who’s supporting Kyle’s fight. Those around him — including friends who date back to university — are cheering him on from the sidelines. Didier Pomerleau has known Kyle for nearly 20 years.
 
“It’s about time somebody does something,” says Pomerleau of the blood ban. “It’s a bit like being friends with Rosa Parks in the 1950s.” 
 
“Kyle has 100 per cent of my support,” says another friend, Alex Kogan. “He’s doing us a favour. He’s got a lot of courage. If someone has the tenacity to do it, it’s Kyle.”
 
But the making of this activist didn’t happen overnight. 
 
Kyle was born Ayal Freiman, a middle child of middle-class parents on Nov. 28, 1972 in Israel. At age 13, his family immigrated to Canada to avoid Israel’s mandatory army draft. His parents didn’t want him and his brother killed. Then, before he finished high school at Newtonbrooke Secondary School in North York, he joined the Military Police reserves because, he says, he believes in public service. 
 
He dated girls and secretly played around with boys. In the army, it was made quite clear that gays were unwelcome. If found out, gays would fall victim to blanket parties — being tied inside a blanket and beaten. 
 
“Of course I was afraid of being beaten. What worried me most was not being one of the guys. I was afraid of not being accepted, not being passed off as ‘normal,’” says Kyle.
 
Slowly coming out in his late teens, Kyle travelled an hour on a subway nearly every day after school to go to the 519 Church Street Community Centre in Toronto — a popular gathering place for queer youth.
 
“[519] was a good place to meet people for friends, dating. . . in a welcoming and non-alcoholic environment,” says Kyle. 
 
Spending time at the 519 helped Kyle to come out to his family.
 
“I was very close to my parents. I couldn’t be straight. I felt like I was hiding a big part of me. I was socialized not to talk about the details of my sex life,” says Kyle.
 
Nowadays, Kyle is married to Vince Freeman, who he lives with in Thornhill, and he manages his own pet care company. 
 
“I’m very proud of him,” says Vince Freeman. “He’s always out to do good. He’s following through on fighting for gay people to have the right to give blood.”
 
But this fall, it’s a waiting game. Freeman’s case has adjourned for now, and he’s optimistic about the results, which will be released sometime after the trial ends in Jan 2010. 
 
“I think Health Canada and CBS are afraid to take a leap. Neither of them wants to make the decision to change the current questionnaire. I trust this case will be based on fact. People might appeal it, but I think the government and CBS want to do the right thing,” says Kyle.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Good
Hopefully Kyle's case will help get the ridiculous rules changed. It shouldn't be about who you are, but about what risks you've taken, and what's actually in your blood. A blanket ban on gay men donating blood if they've even had sex once, puts the whole community in a negative light, and denies valuable blood products to everyone who needs them. I'm a universal donor, and I know my blood is good, but I haven't donated a single drop because of this stupid policy, even during shortages. Kyle challenges the ban by donating. I challenge the ban by publicly not donating. Someone, somewhere, has got to see the failure this policy is, and get it fixed.
Randy, Windsor Ontario
11/11/09 8:26 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Are you kidding me?
Likening him and his 'crusade' for gays to Rosa Parks is not only ridiculous, but insulting to visible minorities everywhere. He's not Robin Hood, he's not Ghandi, hell, he's not even in the same league as Harvey Milk. Quit crying Kyle - you're doing more harm than good right now. You want to do some good? Try volunteering, encourage people to donate on your behalf. But to lie, potentially put people's lives at risk, and then go to court and not expect to get painted as a villan is not only irresponsible, but short-sighted, selfish, and detrimental to gay people everywhere. And seriously - Xtra is nothing more than a tabloid not even worth lining my bird's cage with.
John Updyck, Toronto Ontario
11/12/09 9:39 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Blood... it's in someone else to give.
So let me get this straight (hah!): CBS spends a metric ton of money on radio, newspaper, and other mixed-media ads to remind me, over and over: BLOOD - IT'S IN YOU TO GIVE! Their plaintive cries for blood are unending. "Your donation could save three lives." Apparently not. Depending on who you choose to sleep with, your blood is useless to them - not based on any scientific fact, but based instead on the fears of a generation gone by. There are those out there who engage in risky sexual practices. Those people can be gay, straight, bi-sexual, pan-sexual - whatever. Denying citizens the opportunity to provide blood (when it's so desperately needed) is painfully stupid. CBS needs to get its act together and make some changes that reflect both their need and the reality of the safety of the situation.
Graham Williams, New Westminster BC
11/12/09 1:49 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A Flawed Policy
Just to underline how faulty the policy is, I am not permitted to give blood because my husband had sexual relations with a man over 7 years ago. I suppose I could refrain from sleeping with him for a year, but I think CBS is just going to be down another a pair of donors. People also really need to be assessed on behaviours and actual illnesses, not demographics.
Kerry, Ottawa Ontario
11/14/09 8:00 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Biased
Now how is it acceptable in todays day and age for this to happen? Are the CBS not testing every donation of blood submitted? Are they just taking people's word that "No I have not had sex with another man"? Of course, we all know that no man has ever lied about sex, never told his wife that " Of course I'm straight". That could never happen! Now I am precluded from donating blood and just as importantly, from donating an ORGAN to save a family member's life. Something that I will get to live with for the rest of my life if/when she dies. He may not be going about it the "right" way, but clearly it is the right way for him. Someone has to make a stand and for that, I applaud him!
Russ, Hamilton Ontario
11/16/09 10:40 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Hey, John Updyck
Question: If "Xtra is nothing more than a tabloid not even worth lining my bird's cage with." then what are you doing at this website? Just curious. :)
SM, Vancouver BC
12/28/09 6:22 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.