Activists optimistic about ending gay blood ban
POLITICS / U of Sherbrooke students petition Health Canada
MJ Deschamps / National / Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Share |

YOUNG BLOOD. Queer students are leading the push to end Canada's gay blood and organ bans. In Feb 2008, students rallied on the Hill against the organ ban.
(Brent Creelman photo)
In the battle to lift the ban on gay male blood donors, queer student groups haven't landed a knockout punch, but it appears they will never accept defeat.

At a press conference at the University of Sherbrooke Jun 12, NDP candidate Cheryl Gosselin officially received a petition of more than 3,100 names, collected by the Association Gaie et Lesbienne de l'Université de Sherbrooke (AGLEBUS).

The petition has already been submitted to Health Canada.

The student group held the press conference to mark World Blood Donor Day on June 14, and presented the petition to bring attention to the frustrating fact that despite endless queer activism for decades, the Canadian government still has not budged on lifting the ban.

"We don't feel that there is any logical reason why gay men should be excluded from donating blood," says Mathieu Courchesne, vice president of communications for AGLEBUS.

"We know that things aren't going to change tomorrow, or probably even in a few years from now, but I know that someday they will — if we keep trying."

Matthew McLauchlin, co-president of the NDP-Quebec LGBTT Commisson says that there is no reason why the blood ban — which applies to men who had gay sex even once since 1977, and their female partners — should still be in place.

"More and more scientists are finding that a blanket ban on things like blood or organs is really unscientific, and is basically coming down to a matter of science versus prejudice," says McLauchlin.

AGLEBUS' petition contains the signatures of several doctors, including Mark Wainberg, director of the McGill AIDS Centre, and Réjean Hébert, dean of the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences at the University of Sherbrooke.

University students have taken leading roles in fighting the blood donor ban — and a similar ban that limits the ability of gay men to give organs. In 2006, McGill students banned Héma Québec from conducting drives in their student centre until the gay blood ban is lifted.

Organ donor rules prohibit sexually active gay men from donating organs for five years, other than by exceptional distribution rules. Since the rules were released in Dec 2007, groups at Carleton University in Ottawa and the University of Western Ontario in London have been holding demonstrations and petitioning the government to reverse the rules.

"Just by collecting signatures and talking with people on the street, we feel as though we are already making a difference," says Courchesne. "We already have support from the NDP, too, now all we need from the rest of the politicians is guts."

The ban will be reversed, as long as students continue to circulate petitions and information and doctors continue to support students' efforts, says McLauchlin.

"Many doctors had very strong views about the organ ban, and refused to obey it, so we are hoping that more vigorous responses from the medical community continue," says McLauchlin.

"We need a loud clear voice to let people know that these [bans] are based on old science, and need to be replaced with new understanding."


Share |


Reader Comments


 
Some misinforming the public!
Once again knee-jerk activist queer groups demonstarte a complete inability to grasp medical policies. There is no organ ban and there never was. It's funny how they keep using that term even when newspapers and HC long since discussed its inaccuracy. HC has been looking into changing the blood ban for some time. Petitions do nothing to change medical policies because those are based on evidence. It's sad that activist groups refuse to actually learnfacts and resposibly commuicate information in order to further their goals.
Chris Damdar, Toronto Ontario
06/17/08 9:20 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yes, there are typos!
Sorry for the typos.
Chris Damdar, To on
06/17/08 9:21 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
please donate your organs
Everyone already knows there is no ban on gay men and donating organs. Why are ppl saying othewise? Also, Health Canada has been collecting data for a while to change the blood ban. It's not because of activists that that change is taking place. Same with organ policies: data collection and preventitive measure are being taken to change it, independent of activist groups. These activists groups have no medical support whatsoever. Even the doctors they quote do not endorse their views.
Shuya Nayahara, Ottawa Ontario
06/17/08 10:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Banned blood drives?
Shame on McGill for banning blood drives. It's funny that they say medical policies lead to more deaths by lowering blood donations, but then they have no problem causing even more deaths by banning blood drives.
Cecile Giroux, Montreal ON
06/20/08 10:00 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Dr. Levy wrote this for the Globe...no organ ban!
As the Medical Director of Canada's largest multi-organ transplant program, I see people when they are at their most vulnerable. I am told stories of tragedy and triumph by patients and their families. I celebrate their successes and console them when things go wrong. This past week I have heard more heartrending stories and seen men break down and cry but it isn't because they need an organ transplant. It is because they believe that society has judged them - again - and labeled them as 'undesirable'. I'm speaking about the recent controversy with regard to the ability of gay men to become organ donors. I write, to set the record straight, as far as I am able and to tell everyone that health care professionals who work in the field of transplantation are deeply concerned about the pain that members of the gay community are experiencing and about the impact that this pain and the misconceptions of recent legislation may have on organ donation in Canada. I want to clearly state that the program I lead at University Health Network has never adopted a policy of banning the use of organs from homosexual men or women. All donors -- regardless of their sexual orientation -- are screened by blood tests for any potential known infectious diseases and this information forms part of our decision-making process. All donors - regardless of their sexual orientation - are asked questions about their sexual history, intravenous drug use, tattooing and piercing practices, and other behaviours which might contribute to the risk of acquiring a blood borne infection. Any potential donor who has a number of sexual partners in the past five years - be those partners male or female - would be considered at higher risk for acquiring any number of infectious diseases. We need this information because a donor organ from an individual with an infection could compromise the health of the recipient at a time when the recipient will be at their lowest ebb in terms of resistance to dis
chris damdar, to on
07/15/08 2:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
part 2
disease. People's sexual orientation or their sexual practices are only our business as they relate to the potential for the transmission of infectious diseases. Transplantation of any organ carries significant risk from the process alone, without an added burden of disease from the transplanted organ. The legislation currently in place allows for the use of organs from individuals who have engaged in 'high risk'behaviours provided the potential recipient is informed about those risks. We talk to the potential recipient about the risks, as we know them, from the donated organs, and a decision is made based on as much information as we have and can give. The legislation, as currently worded, does specifically identify the sexual practices of gay men and women. It should be amended to refer to the relative risk of sexual practices and frequency of all men and women. If you engage in unprotected sex with multiple partners, you are at higher risk for acquiring an infection. If you add anal sex to the mix, there is an increase in the risk. We know that some men and women, no matter their sexual orientation, engage in anal sex. Depending on where you are in the world, the practice may be more common than it is here in Canada. It is our program's responsibility to identify all risk factors and give potential recipients the choice about assuming those risks. Organ donation represents the gift of hope and life. This controversy has the potential to hurt a significant part of our community and derail some organ donations. We will continue to practice as before the introduction of the present legislation and I encourage you and all Ontarians to register to donate organs and tissues to help individuals who would die without this gift of life. I, and our program, will work tirelessly to correct any misconceptions that this legislation implies and will work with all communities and interest groups to this end. Gary A Levy MD FRCP (C)
cd, to on
07/15/08 2:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
don't judge a book by its cover!!!
as far as i am concerned...gay and lesbian people also have rights too. people should just stop judging them for what they are. in the religions they say do not judge others for we are all gods children and that everyone has the right to live there life the way they choose. its not up to the public to judge them. love your neighbors and respect the people for what the are...make peace in this world and if you don't like what you see just turn around. I'm a straight woman and if gay people want to donate there organs they have the right too, for they are only human and also gods children like us all.
DE, OTTAWA ONT
07/27/08 2:42 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Another great article
Here's another great Globe article entitled "New organ donation rules don't exclude gay men": http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080110.wlorgan10/BNStory/specialScienceandHealth/home Once again, regardless of your orientation, PLEASE DONATE YOUR ORGANS. You are not banned.
chris damdar, to on
08/08/08 5:15 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.