Harper's new Senate appointment says being gay is a choice - Latest News Roundup
Monday, December 20, 2010

Harper's new Senate appointment says being gay is a choice

One of the two new senators announced by Stephen Harper on Dec 20 told Xtra in a 2008 interview he thinks being gay is a choice.

Rev Don Meredith, of the GTA Faith Alliance, and Larry Smith, a former CFL commissioner, will fill two vacancies in the Senate, giving the Conservatives an outright majority in the unelected body.


(Jenna Wakani)

Back in early 2008, Rev Meredith spoke to Xtra during his by-election run for the Toronto-Centre seat vacated by long-time Liberal MP Bill Graham. 

To a question about his personal position on same-sex marriage, the Conservative candidate replied, "It's the right of individuals to choose their orientation," and when asked if he thinks being gay is a choice he answered, "Individuals have chosen."

He also answered questions on the age of consent for anal sex, funding AIDS vaccine research and was asked if he thought homosexuality is a sin. Rev Meredith ducks the sin question, though he concedes, "We do the same physiological things — we need to eat, we need to sleep, we need food, we need shelter, we need good healthcare — that's the crucial thing."

Read the whole interview here.

Rev Meredith lost the by-election with only 12.5 percent of the vote.


Bookmark and Share


Comments

Monday, December 20, 2010 5:45 PM

I'll never understand why some heteros think they know more about being LGBT than actual LGBT people. The only choice anyone has is to live in the closet or openly and honestly as their real selves.

Rich ca


Monday, December 20, 2010 7:11 PM

I agree with him 100%.

Harry98 ca


Monday, December 20, 2010 8:24 PM

Wow!Don Meredith, does have twisted views but he has the right to freedom of speech and expression. Don Meredith, is no different from the QuAIA or Xtra's twisted politics. In the name of freedom of expression and freedom of speech lets invite him to Pride. Of course Xtra is not defending a freedom of speech or expression issue.

James ca


Monday, December 20, 2010 11:07 PM

"Being gay is a choice." Wonder why people in the middle east and Uganda are so stupid that they CHOOSE to be gay when they know that it would lead to their execution. I wish the Rev, would guide this idiots and may be give them some tips of how he himself chose to be straight. I am sure he woulod love to help people out and cure homosexuality.

sparklincyanide ca


Tuesday, December 21, 2010 1:48 AM

So Don Meredith has a personal opinion. What is YOUR point here???

Rob C ca


Tuesday, December 21, 2010 9:23 AM

"Of all the teachings of history the clearest is this: that those who seek to realize ideal aims by force of law are always unscrupulous and always cruel."--Lord Eustace Percy, JOHN KNOX.

Conventional Christianity is actually Babylon wearing the clothes of Jesus.

St. Paul, in his writings, makes it clear that to force the imposition of one part of the Old Testament Law is to force the whole of it. If Don Meredith does not know this, he's a poor preacher. If he does, he is a demagogue.

Ditto Stephen Harper.

Paul also adds, "I am convinced that nothing is a sin save to him to whom it is a sin."

Peter, says of The Law, "Why burden them with that which neither we nor the fathers could bear?"

Are Stephen Harper and Don Meredith able to bear what Peter and the Fathers could not?

We have only the right to point the way. Once we use the power of the law of the land to force others to walk it we become the enemy.

By the way, The Scripture goes, "All men are sinners." That includes Don Merdedith and Stephen Harper.

The word sin means "to miss the mark." That is all that it means.As we practice we get perfect.


Reg Hartt ca


Tuesday, December 21, 2010 10:13 AM

What amazes me is that people like this are actually saying that as a free human - you do not have the right to choose your own adult sexuality and the other adults you choose to share it with.

While I do not believe it is a choice, if it were I would fight for that freedom to choose - and freedom from others making private decisions for me.

RJP3 us


Tuesday, December 21, 2010 1:16 PM

Damn, the right wing fools are really out in force today... Did Harper ask his homophobic friends to stop in at Xtra and respond to articles?

Ex-Torontonian us


Tuesday, December 21, 2010 7:19 PM

Being on the downlow is a choice, bro ! Talk to the brothers in the hood and get back to 2011.

Louis ca


Wednesday, December 22, 2010 4:57 PM

are people being hired to just write about QuAIA. If Xtra had a recipe section, they'd find a way to write in more shit about how hard done they are with QuAIA in the world and all the threats against their lives...poor, poor, poor folk. In the end all I can do is laugh at them. Maybe Don will pray for them too.

wicked ca


Thursday, December 23, 2010 6:48 AM

How come it's only heterosexuals that say being gay is a choice? That must mean they "chose" to be straight. Does it mean that if they meet the right person of the same sex then they'd "choose" to be gay?? Sexuality is not a choice. That is a fact.

Curt us


Friday, December 24, 2010 7:34 AM

DEFEND FREE SPEECH!
(I'm a Gay man I do not agree with views but will defend the right for him to say it.)

I think it is a fair to compare the opinions of the QuAIA and Xtra's twisted politics with James comment. Like the the QuAIA, Rev Don Meredith has the right to freedom of Speech and expression, so why can Rev Don Meredith have that right either? In a democracy he does have the right to have his views like anyone else. Rev Don Meredith does have twisted views but I do defend his right to say or think this way if he chooses because the Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows it.

Peter From Toronto ca


Friday, December 24, 2010 7:28 AM

Just a note to Peter.
You share James' opinion and his IP address.

Justin Stayshyn ca


Friday, December 24, 2010 10:00 PM

Freedom of speech doesn't include the right to spread slander & defamation against an entire segment of humanity.Opposition to homosexuality based on verses in the Bible are untouchable, of course. Such opposition is covered by freedom of religion, as we all know. The problem lies in the fact that the religious right have the mistaken idea that religious liberty includes the right to deny, diminish, or eliminate; the rights of others. Before I forget.....Merry Christmas to you all, & best wishes for 2011. And I mean that.
I'd also like to pass this item along from my personal endeavors. For a number of years now, I have kept an eye on the religious right websites, & if I saw something that I knew to be erroneous; I'd send a comment explaining the errors. I never argued with religious belief, never used inappropriate language, was sure about my facts, &, I think; was acceptably articulate. Well , folks, I have arrived!! I just received the most complimentary holiday gift ever. My email address has been banned from Lifesite News. Deo gratias.

Hugh (Bart) Vincelette ca


Sunday, December 26, 2010 6:27 PM

Come next federal election, of course I will choose anyone but hypocritical, senate-stacking Stephen Harper to vote for. But the writer of this piece has dwarfed that issue with one of his own making. After coming upon Justin Stayshyn's petty exposé of a shared IP address for commenters Peter/James, above, I may also choo-choo-choose not to trust Xtra as an above-board entity. Xtra threatens to derail its own gravy train by condoning such a nasty, juvenile "choice" of action, not to mention jumping to such a hasty assumption: What if Peter and James shared the same computer? Xtra shows contempt for its readers by using hidden data to shame commenters for comments it doesn't like. I have my own mind, and I don't need to be fed Xtra's "secret" information in order to judge the substantiveness of the comments I read, thank you.

Salvatore Mineo ca


Monday, December 27, 2010 1:42 AM

I’ve been in search of and search for facts and info relating to this for pretty some time now. Many because of the helpful insight.

Damien Antista us



Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

The Roundup

Xtra.ca's Roundup
blog is your source
for news and
analysis that has
queer people
talking.

The Roundup is
written by Xtra's
staff reporters:

Andrea Houston
andrea.houston@xtra.ca

Natasha Barsotti
natasha.barsotti@xtra.ca

 


Log in
Feed Subscribe