Who is behind the anti-gay Tamil radio ad? (UPDATE) - Latest News Roundup
Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Who is behind the anti-gay Tamil radio ad? (UPDATE)

UPDATE

(Oct 27): In a phone interview with xtra.ca on Tuesday, CTBC program manager Thumi Siva countered claims made by Miracle Family Temple’s lead pastor.

Siva said Pastor David Loganathan is "100 percent responsible for the ad.... He's personally responsible for it,” he said. “We don't have anything against George Smitherman or Rob Ford, as we stay neutral." Since the Miracle Family Temple is a long-time customer of the station, Siva said that station staff didn't review the advertisement before airing it.

In a follow-up call to Pastor Loganathan, he said, "the Church has nothing to do with it. I have nothing to say to you," before abruptly hanging up.

Immediately following Ford's win on Monday Pastor Loganathan expressed his support for the new mayor via Twitter: "God Bless Rob Ford new Toronto mayor. He is an answer to our prayers. Many Christians have prayed and voted for this landslide victory."  

 

_____________________________________________

With only hours until Toronto voters decide who will become their new mayor, an already heated campaign took a twisted turn this weekend as some in the Smitherman campaign accused the Rob Ford camp of backing an anti-gay ad broadcast on Tamil Radio station CTBC- Canadian Tamil Broadcasting Corporation.

Here's a translation of the ad, along with the ad itself (via vijaysappani.com):

Man #1: Mani anna (elder brother), who are you going to vote for?
Man#2: [snickering dismissively] What a question… we are Tamil… we have a religion, a culture... Take Rob Ford… he is married to a woman.. also, he promises to lower transfer and other fees.
Man#1: So... immigration?
Man#2:
[snickering dismissively again] That’s a federal matter.. probably to get the whiteman’s vote [term for white man used here colloquially with racist undertones].
Man#1
: I am also voting for Rob Ford.
** This is a paid advertisement* 

The ad has since been pulled by the station. Since the ad had been played during a show produced by the Miracle Family Temple, a Christian-Tamil organization, some suspected the Temple itself had paid for the ad, but in an interview with xtra.ca, senior pastor David Loganatha of the Miracle Family Temple "categorically" denied any involvement with the ad. "Maybe it was played during our program, but we had nothing to do with it," said Loganatha.

Adrienne Batra, head of communications for the Rob Ford campaign, says the Ford campaign itself is not responsible for the ad. Batra says the campaign is "appalled" by it and compared the reference to Smitherman's homosexuality to disparaging comments made about Ford's weight. "We have no idea where this ad came from. They're alluding to his lifestyle choices, and no one feels ill-feelings for his choice." UPDATE: @RobFordTeam (the official Twitter account of the Rob Ford campaign) wrote: "I do not condone the recent Tamil Radio ad. I support diversity & have no issue with others' lifestyle choices. #voteTO" 

Sivakaran Gunaratnam, a queer Tamil in Toronto, calls the ads "pretty disturbing" and an "attack" on queer Tamils like himself. "It plays on preconceived notions of what being Tamil means — implying there are no queer Tamils. Regardless of who paid for the ads, it's insulting to say there are no queer Tamils." He points to the success of programs and services for queer Tamils like Snehithan and ASAAP as indications of a thriving queer Tamil community. 

At this time, calls to CTBC have gone unanswered. 

Just last week Rob Ford skipped a planned 519 mayoral debate on local and LGBT issues citing previous commitments.  

Bookmark and Share


Comments

Sunday, October 24, 2010 3:00 PM

It's a sad comment on the state of these elections that one could as easily suspect someone supporting Smitherman (or even another candidate) of being responsible for these ads as someone supporting Ford.

David D. ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 3:57 PM

Rob Ford's weight is a 'lifestyle choice', Smitherman's sexuality isn't.

John ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 4:24 PM

See the threat that third world immigration poses? Do you finally see it now, libs?

ron ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 6:11 PM

I hate that people might think these views are representative of the Tamil community because a church or some partisan group bought some ad time on a community station.

I don't profess to speak for all Tamils but I can say that I was never raised to be homophobic and I didn't see much in the way of homophobia within the community growing up.

I do note that I'm straight, an LGBT Tamil person's insights would be useful.

Anyway, I really don't think homosexuality is even remotely a wedge issue in the Tamil community. Immigration and the political situation in Sri Lanka are really the two big issues. I don't know why these people chose to focus on Smitherman's marriage, except that it must be funded by a group holding those views.

tamil person ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 7:35 PM

Ron, I'd be curious to know who you are voting for tomorrow?

Because I can't help but think that the one candidate who most closely aligns with your anti-immigrant views is probably Rob Ford. And Rob Ford seems the most likely suspect of who made this anti-queer trash ad.

Sav ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 8:38 PM

Ford has no issue, huh? I guess as long as those "lifestyle choice" people do not marry.

CJ ca


Sunday, October 24, 2010 9:52 PM

For whatever it is worth, a "straight" Tamil's opinion. Whatever George chose to do in his personal life is his own choice and I fully respect that like most Tamil people I know. In fact, the Tamil community respects George more than most other provincial politicians and most of them are aware of his marriage. They respect and like him for his character and courage. If him being gay had anything do with those qualities, then kudos to being gay. This radio needs to be sued to closure if they cannot point to the source of this ad.

Isai ca


Monday, October 25, 2010 2:06 PM

canadian tamil broadcasting audio corporation. The number is 416-429-2822 or 416-429-2374. Address: 86 Laird Drive suite 01 Toronto

ravi ca


Monday, October 25, 2010 6:08 PM

I am a Tamil. I am strongly condemning this ad. This is a shame for Tamils.

Rathan ca


Tuesday, October 26, 2010 9:39 AM

I am a Tamil and I am disgusted with this radio ad. I will admit that certain segment of our community is backward (especially the religious folks, both Christian and Hindu), but as a community at large, we are not intolerant. I have never encountered hateful attitude in our community against gays.

JV ca


Tuesday, October 26, 2010 11:41 AM

This ad not only portrays all Tamils as homophobic but also tars all ‘white men’ as racist by insinuating that Ford’s anti-immigrant rhetoric will attract ‘white’ votes. It deserves to be condemned vehemently. As a Tamil, I am saddened and ashamed.

Dushy G ca


Tuesday, October 26, 2010 2:12 PM

Preposterous. Tamil culture and music are blatantly queer-friendly: This Tamil song seems to even contain the lyric, "I love you inside, Ed."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZA1NoOOoaNw

BenL. ca


Tuesday, October 26, 2010 6:16 PM

I suspect that this ad wasn't actually aimed at Tamils. It was a plant to get a reaction from the mainstream press so that politically apathetic semi-illiterate homophobes of all backgrounds that don't normally bother voting might clue-in that Smitherman was queer and activate them on election day to vote like zombies for Ford.

It's weird now how many people suddenly think Tamil culture is somehow particularly homophobic, what nonsense!

Shenanigans notwithstanding, Ford would not have got in without disproportionate voter apathy. Shame on you who did not vote. Shame!

Leif Harmsen ca


Tuesday, October 26, 2010 8:18 PM

shame on you CTBC... juz shame on us. Please don't see this as a representation of Tamils as a whole.

K. Kiruthikan ca



Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

The Roundup

Xtra.ca's Roundup
blog is your source
for news and
analysis that has
queer people
talking.

The Roundup is
written by Xtra's
staff reporters:

Andrea Houston
andrea.houston@xtra.ca

Natasha Barsotti
natasha.barsotti@xtra.ca

 


Log in
Feed Subscribe