Friday, May 28, 2010

Alan Li rejects appointment as Pride Toronto grand marshal

Pride Toronto's choice for grand marshal of the 2010 Pride parade has refused his appointment, citing the organization's censorship of Queers Against Israeli Apartheid (QuAIA).

Dr Alan Li says he was flattered to be chosen, but "after serious reflection" he decided to decline the title. QuAIA has distributed Li's letter to the Pride Toronto board, which you can read in full here (PDF). An excerpt:

"Pride's recent decision to ban the term 'Israeli Apartheid' and thus prohibit the participation of the group Queers Against Israeli Apartheid from participating in Pride celebrations this year is a slap in the face to our history of diverse voices. Pride's hoice to take preemptive step to censor our own communities' voices and concerns in response to political and corporate pressure shows a lack of backbone to stand up or principles of inclusiveness and anti-oppression. It also allowed Toronto City Council and other levels of government to evade their responsibility to engage in public debate to promote awareness and understanding on this critical human rights issue."

More on Li, from the Canadian Lesbian and Gay Archives:

"Dr Alan Li, an immigrant from Hong Kong, is a Toronto-based physician, community organizer and human rights activist. Since the early 1980s, he has been the driving force behind Gay Asians Toronto. He co-founded Hong Kong 10% Club, the first registered gay community organization in Hong Kong. He was also the founder of the Asian Community AIDS Services, and the multicultural Coalition against Homophobia. He was the first openly gay National President of the Chinese Canadian National Council, an advocacy organization with 30 chapters across Canada. As a physician, he has served many people with HIV/AIDS at Casey House Hospice as well as marginalized populations at Regent Park Community Health Centre."

Read more:

 

Bookmark and Share


Comments

Friday, May 28, 2010 6:58 PM

a courageous and very good man--very worthy of the honour but even even more so for having turned it down for reasons he cites. The current Pride Board should be ashamed of the further devisiveness they have created by trying to impose censorship of placards or groups marching on pretty flimsy grounds.

james dubro ca


Friday, May 28, 2010 7:08 PM

Good for him! at this point I don't much feel like there's anything to celebrate at this year's Pride, censorship is nothing to be proud of. I'm sure there will be many there just for the party and some celebrating the censorship of QuAIA but seeing what this has done to the community just doesn't make me feel like celebrating. Too bad Gladstone couldn't have left well enough alone without imposing his beliefs on everyone at Pride.

Rich ca


Friday, May 28, 2010 7:49 PM

I think this year I'll be attending my home town of Kitchener's Pride celebration instead, I've always wanted to but never got around to it, this would be a good year to do so, maybe everyone opposed to censorship should attend their hometown's Pride instead too, or if Toronto is your home town then go experience Pride elsewhere for a change.

Rich ca


Friday, May 28, 2010 9:17 PM

Dr Li! Thank you for your integrity. I'm proud to have you as a queer Asian role model.

Elisha Lim ca


Saturday, May 29, 2010 12:05 AM

I am profoundly relieved (and proud!) to hear that Alan Li has turned down the appointment as grand marshal. Pride Toronto's attitudes and actions have become increasingly distasteful to me over the last few years. In the last year or so, what was once enthusiasm and then irritated neutrality has become outright fury and disgust. "Pride is not political", indeed! If the GAY PRIDE MARCH isn't political in essence and concept, WHY DID IT BEGIN IN THE FIRST PLACE?! Is Pride Toronto saying that queers have conquered homophobia? That the right to marry is the be-all and end-all of equality? That trans issues are unimportant to queers in general and Pride Toronto specifically? If Pride really "isn't political", then that IS what they're saying...and if Pride IS political, then any group has the right to march, unless they're promoting hate crimes. Queers Against Israeli Apartheid are hardly promoting hate crimes; they don't speak against the Israeli people, but against the actions of the Israeli state.
I personally am boycotting Pride this year, and all subsequent years until Pride is officially "political" again. I don't see the point of attending a Gay Pride Parade that sees itself solely as a cross between a giant advertisement for all its corporate sponsors and a tourist pull of epic proportions.

Meg Inwood ca


Saturday, May 29, 2010 1:10 AM

Alan

Thank you so much for show as always your integrity and courageous.

You are and example for many ppl in Canada and the world.

Gabriel Gutierrez Garcia mx


Saturday, May 29, 2010 3:58 AM

Well done Dr. Li. Your gesture is an important signal to the community that we must peacefully reassert the core values of Pride - our right to free expression should never be for sale. Shame on the Board of Directors and the executive of Pride Toronto 2010!

Martin ca


Sunday, May 30, 2010 9:16 AM

At the moment, I'm down here at the Harvey Milk Festival in Sarasota doing readings and writing workshops on the themes of Harvey's life and work. I have been sucker-punched by the connections between themes and what is happening back home in TO. I've written about them on American Refugee at thomvernon.com. This demonstrates Hannah Arendt's point, once again, that so-called rights don't mean a hill of beans unless you've got a State to defend them. In the case of QuAIA, it is refreshing to see the community come to their defense. Perhaps this is a hole in Arendt's argument?

t ca


Monday, May 31, 2010 11:07 AM

I think we have to be mature enough to see the big picture here - the hijacking of pride by special interest groups (unrelated to gay rights) cannot be allowed.

jb ca


Monday, May 31, 2010 12:26 PM

You're right jb, - the hijacking of Pride by special interest groups cannot be allowed. Shame on the right wing, pro-Israeli lobbyists who have forced Pride TO to CENSOR those in the LGBT community!

Congratulations to Alan Li!

Dan ca


Monday, May 31, 2010 3:00 PM

Funny how one dissenting post in this entire list results in name-calling. Guess people can't have reasonalbe differences of opinion anymore.

jb ca


Tuesday, June 1, 2010 6:33 PM

Really, what difference does it make? Pride has "jumped the shark" in Toronto, it's about a quarter as entertaining and enjoyable as it was five years ago, and bears no resemblance to the Prides of pre-2005... it is all political, all bullshit... all the time... Take it back to what it was... a celebration of the LGBT community, and what makes us unique but equal to all.

BK ca



Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

The Roundup

Xtra.ca's Roundup
blog is your source
for news and
analysis that has
queer people
talking.

The Roundup is
written by Xtra's
staff reporters:

Rob Salerno
rob.salerno@xtra.ca

Andrea Houston
andrea.houston@xtra.ca

Natasha Barsotti
natasha.barsotti@xtra.ca

and

Adam Glen
Editorial Intern


Log in
Feed Subscribe